Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 24;104:107210. doi: 10.1016/j.asoc.2021.107210

Table 8.

The obtained results for allocating approach (TP = Test Problem, PT = Processing Time).

Algorithm TP SP1 SP2 SP3 MP4 MP5 MP6 MP7 LP8 LP9 LP10
SA Obj. 155 331 511 882 1147 1648 2659 3827 5189 6882
PT 0.31 0.46 0.465 0.577 0.615 0.864 0.925 1.576 3.013 6.18
RPD 0.00826 0.031651 0.04668 0.049662 0.05746 0.056484 0.058655 0.059451 0.061551 0.074511
PSO Obj. 165 318 504 827 1071 1590 2647 3460 4973 6335
PT 0.904 1.01 2.7 2.82 3.73 5.48 7.64 11.7 28.2 57.07
RPD 0.018034 0.008323 0.025484 0.01156 0.017571 0.036485 0.015282 0.029846 0.020808 0.02386
SEO Obj. 155 326 502 858 1072 1577 2652 3644 5071 6660
PT 0.75 0.96 1.27 1.52 1.81 3.74 4.37 7.66 16.41 32.18
RPD 0.00971 0.018034 0.024187 0.027564 0.028669 0.034414 0.036992 0.031212 0.0329 0.036599
SAPSO Obj. 153 318 487 827 1040 1571 2638 3460 4873 6258
PT 1.45 1.53 3.49 4.41 5.22 9.68 13.9 32.9 59.07 107.02
RPD 0.002312 0.007398 0.002173 0.010543 0.008508 0.025016 0.013918 0.008184 0.010695 0.011283
SASEO Obj. 151 310 490 815 1040 1483 2628 3425 4861 6234
PT 1.5 2.129 3.61 7.11 8.04 13.66 26.153 41.74 93.2 146.46
RPD 0.000925 0.000694 0.004624 0.00206 0.007225 0.005907 0.007364 0.00104 0.008901 0.007861
PSOSEO Obj. 153 313 490 817 1040 1483 2605 3443 4816 6234
PT 1.5 3.84 4.73 8.85 10.477 19.98 26.5 54.26 97.49 162.3
RPD 0.001742 0.003235 0.005648 0.004944 0.005143 0.006173 0.006636 0.005599 0.005901 0.006565