| Bone-Marrow derived Mononuclear Cells (BMMNC) |
- Most widely researched cell product for PAD.
- Several meta-analyses showed improvement in ABI, TcPO2, pain scores, and ulcer healing in BMMNC treated patients (90–92).
- Availability of long term safety result (3 years) (109).
|
Risk and complications during bone marrow aspiration. |
| Peripheral Blood derived Mononuclear Cells (PBMNC) |
- Head-to-head comparison with BMMNC showed similar benefits (65).
- Recent meta-analysis showed PBMNC, but not BMMNC are able to reduce risk of major amputation and improve ulcer healing (88).
- Availability of long term safety result (1 year) (101).
|
- Risk and complications during G-CSF/GM-CSF administration (105).
- Efficacy of stem cells mobilizations are significantly influenced by race, ethnics, and disease status (62).
|
| Mesenchymal Stem Cells (MSC) |
- Promising result from preclinical and clinical studies.
- Able to be isolated and expanded to achieve consistentand desirable dose.
- Allow larger-scale manufacturing with good quality control to produce an ‘off the-shelf’ cellular products.
- Possibility of allogeneic therapy due to its non or low-antigenic properties.
|
- Risk and complications during bone marrow aspiration (in BMMSC).
- Reports of potential role of MSC in tumor development.
- High variability of cell products between protocols and research facility.
- Relatively more expensive.
|