Table 3. Summary of study characteristics and results of included studies on myocardial function.
Author [ref], study period, country | Study design | Intervention | Number of patients | Myocardial parameters assessed | Time of measurement | Results | Quality assessment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Eicher et al. [17], ND, Canada; USA | Multicentre; randomized controlled trial | Whole body cooling | 31 cooled vs. 31 non-cooled | cTnI, CK-MB | 48h | No significant reduction in cTnI; significant increase in CK-MB in hypothermia group | Moderate |
Liu et al. [24], ND, UK | Retrospective cohort study | Whole body cooling (n = 58), head cooling (n = 4) | 61 cooled vs. 14 non-cooled | cTnI | First 3 days | Significant reduction in peak level and AUC of cTnI within 24h in hypothermia group | Moderate |
Nestaas et al. [25], 2010–2011, Norway | Single centre; prospective cohort study | Whole body cooling | 44 cooled vs. 20 non-cooled | Tissue doppler measurements, peak cTnT | Day 1, 3, 4 | Similar impairment during days 1–3, significant improvement in myocardial function in hypothermia group at day 4 (after rewarming) with a better myocardial function than at day 3 in the non-cooled group; higher median peak cTnT in hypothermia group | High |
Rakesh et al. [26], 2014–2016, India | Single centre; randomized controlled trial | Whole body cooling | 60 cooled vs. 60 non-cooled | CK-MB, cTnI, ECG, ECHO | 0, 24 and 72h | Significant increase in median of difference of CK-MB and cTnI in hypothermia group; less findings of myocardial dysfunction on ECG and ECHO at 72h in hypothermia group | High |
Vijlbrief et al. [27], 2006–2008, The Netherlands | Single centre; prospective cohort study | Whole body cooling | 20 cooled vs. 28 non-cooled | cTnI, BNP | 0, 24, 48 and 84h | Significant reduction in BNP at 48 and 84h in hypothermia group; no difference in cTnI between the two groups | Moderate |
ND = not described; cTnI = cardiac troponin I; BNP = brain natriuretic peptide; CK-MB = creatinekinase MB; ECG = electrocardiography; ECHO = echocardiography; AUC = area under the curve; cTnT = cardiac troponin T.