Table 1.
Study | Design | Sample Size | Age Group * | Gender ** | PD | Activity Type and Setting | SD | Diagnosis | Results (Positive [+], Negative/no change [−], Mixed [−/+]) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ahmed et al. (2011) [19] |
RCT | 84 | 13–18 | Male and Female | 10 | Exercise (Included upper limb, lower limb, trunk, and neck aerobic exercises in addition to free running) Setting: School and home |
10 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Alesi et al. (2014) [20] |
Single subject study design | 3 | 13–18 | Male and Female | 8 | Exercise (Integrated group exercise training with goal setting) Setting: Not mentioned |
24 | Down syndrome | (−/+) Working memory (+) Alertness and speed |
Bass et al. (2009) [16] |
Quasi-experimental | 34 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 12 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Good Hope Equestrian Training Centre |
12 | ASD | (+) Attention |
Borgi et al. (2016) [21] |
RCT | 28 | 6–12 | Male | 24 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Equine-assisted therapy center |
24 | ASD | (+) Planning |
Bowling et al. (2017) [22] |
RCT | 103 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 7 | Exercise (Cybercycling during physical education classes) Setting: School |
24 | Behavior disorders | (+) Self-regulation |
Bustamante et al. (2016) [23] |
RCT | 35 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 10 | Exercise (Physically active games and modified sports) Setting: School |
13 | Disruptive Behavior disorders and ADHD | (+) Cognitive control (+) Working memory (+) Cognitive flexibility |
Chambers et al. (2016) [24] |
Single subject Study design | 5 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 4 | Exercise (short-burst high-intensity physical exercise such as lunges, side jumps, and Chinese push-ups) Setting: School | 4 | ADHD | (+) Working memory (+) Attention |
Chang et al. (2014) [25] |
Quasi-experimental | 27 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 8 | Aqua therapy Setting: Local swimming pool |
Not Stated | ADHD | (+) Response inhibition |
Choi et al. (2015) [26] |
RCT | 50 | 13–18 | Male | 6 | Exercise (Aerobic exercises consisted of running (shuttle run, zigzag run), jumping rope (individual and group jumps), and basketball (dribble, pass, shoot, and game) Setting: Not mentioned |
6 | ADHD | (+) Cognitive flexibility (+) Attention |
Chou et al. (2017) [27] |
Quasi-experimental | 49 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 8 | Yoga Setting: Dance studio |
8 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Cleary et al. (2017) [28] |
Qualitative | 28 | Students: 13–18 | Students: Male and Female | 9 | Exercise (Included indoor activities (such as treadmill, stationary bicycle, stepping machine) and outdoor activities (such as running, sprinting drills, or cycling in the school grounds) Setting: School |
8 | Students’ diagnosis: Cerebral palsy | (+) Attention |
Cuypers et al. (2011) [29] |
Quasi-experimental | 5 | 6–12 | Male | 8 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Riding School |
24 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Gabriels et al. (2015) [30] |
RCT | 116 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 10 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Riding Centre |
14 | ASD | (+) Self-regulation |
Gabriels et al. (2012) [15] |
Quasi-experimental | 42 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 10 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Colorado Therapeutic Riding Centre |
18 | ASD | (+) Self-regulation |
Garcia-Gomez et al. (2016) [31] |
Quasi-experimental | 14 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 13 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Monfragüe Equestrian Centre of Cáceres |
Not Stated | ADHD | (−) Attention |
Garcia-Gómez et al. (2014) [12] |
Quasi-experimental | 16 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 12 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Monfragüe Equestrian Centre of Cácere |
12 | ASD | (−) Attention |
Garg et al. (2013) [32] |
Prospective cohort study | 51 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 26 | Yoga Setting: Classroom |
26 | Multiple handicapping conditions, developmental disabilities, or ASD | (+) Self-regulation (+) Attention |
Grönlund et al. (2005) [33] |
Quasi-experimental | 2 | 6–12 | Male | 12 | Dance Setting: Clinic |
12 | ADHD | (−/+) Attention |
Hariprasad et al. (2013) [34] |
Prospective Cohort | 9 | 6–12 | Male | 8 | Yoga Setting: Child Psychiatry Unit |
12 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Hartshorn et al. (2001) [35] |
Quasi-experimental | 38 | 0–5 | Not Stated | 8 | Exercise (Involved using hoops and jumping in and out of them, putting different body parts in and out of the hoops, following the therapist through an obstacle course of different shape and different height gym mats, and moving to a tambourine and stopping when the tambourine stopped) Setting: Not mentioned |
8 | ASD | (+) Attention |
Hilton et al. (2014) [36] |
Quasi-experimental | 7 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 10 | Exergame Setting: Clayton Child Centre |
10 | ASD | (+) Working memory (+) Alertness and speed |
Hulls et al. (2006) [37] |
Cross-sectional | 18 occupational therapists |
Children: 6–12 | Children: Not Stated | Activity Type: Aqua therapy Setting: Not mentioned |
Not Stated | ASD | (+) Attention | |
Jang et al. (2015) [38] |
Quasi-experimental | 20 | 6–12 | Male | 12 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Equine Facility | 14 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Jenkin et al. (2013) [39] |
Quasi-experimental | 7 | 6–12 | Male | 8 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Reserved are at a riding facility |
9 | ASD | (−) Cognitive control(−) Attention(−) Language |
Jensen et al. (2004) [40] |
RCT | 19 | 6–12 | Male | 20 | Yoga Setting: Westmead hospital |
20 | ADHD | (−) Attention |
Johansson et al.(1998) [41] |
Retrospective Cohort | 92 | 13–18 | Male | 156 | Exercise (Physical education) Setting: Pacific Northwest program |
156 | Social and emotional problems | (+) Academic achievement |
Kaiser et al. (2006) [42] |
Prospective Cohort | 31 | 13–18 | Male and Female | 6 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: CHUM Riding Therapeutic Centre |
6 | Cerebral palsy, emotional impairment, learning disability | (+) Attention |
Kang et al. (2011) [43] |
RCT | 28 | 6–12 | Male | 6 | Sport (Sport therapy program) Setting: Department of Psychiatry of Chung Ang University Medical Centre |
6 | ASD | (+) Attention |
Lawson et al. (2012) [44] |
Single subject study design | 3 | 0–5 | Male | 5 | Yoga Setting: The Preschool and Language Stimulation Program School |
7 | Speech and developmental delay, behavioral problem, ADHD | (+) Attention |
Lufi et al. (2011) [45] |
Quasi-experimental | 32 | 6–12 | Male | 52 | Sport (Sport-based group therapy such as basketball and running) Setting: Not mentioned |
104 | Behavioral disorders | (+) Attention |
Macauley et al. (2004) [46] |
Prospective cohort | 3 | 6–12 | Male | 6 | Hippotherapy Setting: Merlin Farms Equestrian Center |
6 | Learning disability | (+) Language |
Mackinnon et al. (1995) [47] |
RCT | 19 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 26 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Therapeutic riding program |
26 | Cerebral palsy | (−) Attention |
MacMahon et al. (1987) [48] |
RCT | 54 | 6–12 | Male | 20 | The aerobic group’s exercise consisted of distance running, aerobic dance, and variants of soccer Setting: Not mentioned |
20 | Learning disability | (−) Academic achievement |
Majorek et al. (2004) [49] |
Case series | 5 | 6–12 | Male | 36 | Exercise (Therapeutic Eurythmy-movement therapy) Setting: Therapy rooms of a pediatrician’s surgery |
36 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
McKune et al. (2003) [50] |
Quasi-experimental | 19 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 5 | Exercise (Included activities such as relay runs, simple plyometric exercises, running through a mini obstacle course, a distance run of 1–2 km, and skipping) Setting: Home |
9 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Memarmoghaddam et al. (2016) [51] |
RCT | 40 | 6–12 | Male | 8 | Exercise (Aerobic and goal directed exercises) Setting: University Sports Hall |
8 | ADHD | (+) Cognitive inhibition |
Milligan et al. (2015) [52] |
Qualitative | 46 | Youth: 13–18 | Youth: Male and Female | 20 | Martial Arts Setting: Child Development Institute |
20 | Learning disability | (+) Self-regulation |
Morand et al. (2004) [53] |
RCT | 18 | 6–12 | Male | 12 | Martial Arts Setting: Martial arts school |
12 | ADHD | (+) Academic performance (+) Attention |
Neely et al. (2015) [54] |
Case study | 2 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 12 | Exercise (Jumping on an indoor trampoline) Setting: Classroom |
12 | ASD | (+) Academic engagement |
Nicholson et al.(2011) [55] |
Single subject study design | 4 | 6–12 | Male | 6 | Exercise (Jogging) Setting: Classroom |
6 | ASD | (+) Academic engagement |
O’Callaghan et al. (2003) [56] |
RCT | 4 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 6 | Sport (Kickball) Setting: Campus of a large public university |
6 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Ozer et al. (2012) [57] |
RCT | 76 | 13–18 | Male | 8 | Sport (Soccer) Setting: Soccer Field |
8 | Intellectual disability | (+) Attention |
Ozer et al. (2007) [58] |
RCT | 23 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 14 | Aqua therapy Setting: Swimming pool |
38 | Cerebral palsy | (+) Attention |
Packard et al. (2007) [59] |
Prospective Cohort | 10 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 4 | Exercise (Vigorous aerobic physical activity) Setting: School |
6 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Pan et al. (2017) [60] |
RCT | 22 | 6–12 | Male | 12 | Exercise (Motor and movement skills related to table tennis) Setting: Gymnasium |
24 | ASD | (+) Cognitive flexibility |
Pan et al. (2016) [61] |
RCT | 32 | 6–12 | Male | 12 | Sport (Racket sport) Setting: Table tennis center |
24 | ADHD | (+) Cognitive flexibility (+) Attention (+) Cognitive process |
Porter et al. (2013) [62] |
Case study | 1 | 6–12 | Male | 4 | Yoga Setting: Classroom |
4 | ASD | (+) Attention |
Ringenbach et al. (2016) [63] |
RCT | 44 | 13–18 | Male and Female | 8 | Exercise (Assisted cycling therapy) Setting: Cycling Bike |
8 | Down syndrome | (+) Response inhibition (−) Cognitive flexibility (+) Language (+) Alertness and speed |
Rosenblatt et al. (2011) [64] |
Prospective Cohort | 24 | 6–12 | Male | 8 | Yoga Setting: Medical school teaching hospital |
8 | ASD | (−) Attention |
Rosenthal-Malek et al. (1997) [65] |
Quasi-experimental | 5 | 13–18 | Male | 10 | Exercise (Mildly strenuous jogging) Setting: Urban public school and a community-based workshop |
10 | ASD | (+) Academic performance |
Smith et al. (2013) [66] |
Prospective Cohort | 17 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 9 | Exercise (Continuous moderate-to-vigorous physical activity such as hopping, skipping, etc.) Setting: Not mentioned |
11 | ADHD | (+) Response inhibition (+) Working memory |
Stickney et al. (2010) [67] |
Qualitative | 34 | Children: Not Stated | Children: Not stated | 8 | Equine-assisted therapy Setting: Central Kentucky Riding for Hope |
8 | ASD | (+) Attention (+) Language (+) Academic achievement |
Tsai et al. (2009) [68] |
RCT | 43 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 10 | Sport (Tennis) Setting: A laboratory |
10 | Developmental coordination disorder | (+) Inhibitory control |
Tsai et al. (2012) [69] |
RCT | 51 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 10 | Sport (Soccer) Setting: School |
10 | Developmental coordination disorder | (+) Inhibitory control (+) Attention |
Tsai et al. (2014) [70] |
RCT | 60 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 16 | Exercise (The endurance training program consisted of interval training and one continuous long-distance running session, and one session with another aerobic activity (e.g., cycling, step aerobics, or rope jumping)) Setting: School |
16 | Developmental coordination disorder | (+) Working memory |
Verret et al. (2012) [71] |
Quasi-experimental | 21 | 6–12 | Male | 10 | Exercise (Sessions included warm-up; progressive aerobic, muscular, and motor skills exercises; and cool down) Setting: School gymnasium |
12 | ADHD | (+) Attention |
Wehrle et al. (2017) [72] |
Qualitative | 6 | 6–12 | Male | 8 | Exercise (Includes warm-up, free play, and skill of a week) Setting: Shady Lane Elementary School |
8 | ADHD | (+) Attention (+) Academic performance |
Wendt et al. (2000) [73] |
Quasi-experimental | 24 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 6 | Exercise (Intense Aerobic-type physical activity program) Setting: SUNY Buffalo Amherst, Turf Football Stadium |
6 | ADHD | (+) Cognitive control (+) Working memory (+) Cognitive flexibility (+) Attention (+) Cognitive performance (+) Language (+) Cognitive process (+) Planning (+) Academic achievement (+) Fluid intelligence |
Yildirim et al. (2010) [74] |
RCT | 50 | 13–18 | Male and Female | 12 | Exercise (Circuit training, resistance training, and interval speed training) Setting: School |
12 | Intellectual disability | (+) Alertness and speed |
Ziereis et al. (2015) [75] |
RCT | 43 | 6–12 | Male and Female | 12 | Exercise (Various activities such as juggling, tennis, trampoline, juggling, etc.) Setting: Facilities of the University of Regensburg’s Institute for Sport Science |
14 | ADHD | (+) Working memory |
Notes: PD = Program Duration in weeks; SD = Study Duration in weeks; RCT = Randomized Controlled Trials; ADHD = Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder; ASD = Autism Spectrum Disorder. * We categorized the age to three groups including “0–5”, “6–12”, and “13–18”-year-olds. Each study has been assigned the age group based on the mean age of study participants; ** Study population has been considered as “Male” when all or more than 90% of study participants were male. Similarly, when all or more than 90% of study participants were female, the study population has been considered as “Female”.