Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 9;11(2):250. doi: 10.3390/biom11020250

Table 1.

Clinically available options for chondral injury treatment.

Treatment Description Benefits Limitations
Non-surgical methods Analgesics, weight loss, physical re-education, physical therapy, complementary medicine (e.g., acupuncture) No surgery necessary
Relatively inexpensive
Palliative treatment options
Chronic analgesic use potential
Arthroscopic chondroplasty Arthroscopic resection of detached cartilage fragments to prevent further joint irritation and damage Rapid, minimally invasive procedureImmediate weight-bearing possible Palliative treatment
Benefits not proven
Brief pain relief
MF 1 Arthroscopic procedure to create small lesions in the osteochondral interface to direct osteoprogenitor cells into damaged cartilage tissue No graft required for defects < 2 cm2
Rapid recovery
Fibrocartilage formation potential
Variable functional outcomes
Rapid deterioration
Mosaicoplasty Osteochondral autografts harvested from patient non-loaded zones of the joint Optimal for small lesions (1–4 cm2)
Pain relief
Sub-optimal surrounding tissue graft adherence
Graft-site morbidity
ACI 2 Autologous cultured and expanded chondrocytes implanted in the lesion under a tissue flap Hyaline cartilage formation potential
Extensive lesion treatment (<10 cm2)
Graft delamination
Periosteal hypertrophy
Qualitative variability of regenerated tissue
Onerous protocol
MACI 3 Autologous cultured and expanded chondrocytes seeded onto 3D scaffolds and implanted into defect Treatment of large lesions
Hyaline cartilage formation potential
Limited periosteal hypertrophy
Graft delamination
Limited integration
Qualitative variability of regenerated tissue
Onerous protocol
Joint arthroplasty Replacement of arthritic joint with an artificial implant Pain relief
Functional resurgence potential
Infectious risk
Functional outcome variability
Implant wear or loosening

1 Microfracture, 2 Autologous chondrocyte implantation, 3 Matrix-assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantation.