Table 2.
Study | Design | Population | Risk Factors for Inclusion | Imaging Technique | Baseline vs. Serial TBP |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Prospective Trials | |||||
Banky 2005 | prospective single cohort |
>16 years median age 38 years (range 16–74) n = 309 (female n = 168, male n = 141) Australia |
>4 dysplastic nevi >100 nevi positive family history of melanoma positive personal history of melanoma |
14 baseline photographs 35 mm single-lens reflex camera dermoscopy allowed, no SDDI |
baseline TBP |
Goodson 2010 | prospective single cohort |
n = 1076 USA |
≥3 atypical nevi >50 nevi personal history of melanoma positive family history of melanoma extensive lentiginosis |
approx. 27 regional photographs on standard poses; additional photographs were taken to monitor atypical lesions in other regions FinePix S2 Pro digital camera dermoscopy allowed, no SDDI |
baseline TBP |
Kelly 1997 | prospective single cohort |
>18 years mean age 37 years (range 18–67) n = 278 (female n = 162, male n = 116) Australia |
dysplastic melanocytic nevi | systematic set of 14 baseline photographs with definition of standard views epiluminescence microscopy |
baseline TBP |
Moloney 2014 | prospective single cohort |
>18 years median age 53 years (range 21–85) n = 311 Australia |
4 groups: (i) personal history of at least one invasive melanoma and dysplastic nevus syndrome (ii) personal history of at least one invasive melanoma and a family history of at least three first-degree or second-degree relatives with a confirmed history of malignant melanoma (iii) personal history of at least two primary invasive melanomas with at least one occurring in the 10 years prior to recruitment for patients with only two melanomas (iv) confirmed CDKN2A (OMIM 600160) or CDK4 (OMIM123829) gene mutation |
12–24 digital high-resolution photographs according to a standardized protocol SDDI allowed |
serial TBP |
Nathansohn 2007 | prospective single cohort |
0–82 years median age 34 years n = 895 (female n = 401, male n = 494) Israel |
>20 nevi or multiple freckles multiple dysplastic nevi positive family history of melanoma children with congenital nevi |
12 MP digital single-lens reflex camera and 7 MP digital camera with polarized light dermoscope standard set of 20 photos and photos of marked lesions |
serial TBP |
Salerni 2012 | prospective single cohort |
mean age 37 years n = 618 (female n = 337, male n = 281) Europe |
moderate to severe atypical mole syndrome (>100 nevi and/or >10 atypical and/or dysplastic nevi) personal and/or family history of melanoma carriers of melanoma gene mutations other cancer risk conditions (congenital nevus, immunosuppression, genodermatosis) |
standardized digital system for images (standardized method for total body mapping) total-body mapping with digital images SDDI allowed |
serial TBP |
Retrospective studies | |||||
Drugge 2019 | retrospective two cohorts (TBP 1 vs. non-TBP) |
>18 years median age 54 years (IQR 29) n = 4692 (2473 with TBP) USA |
no special risk factors as inclusion criteria | simultaneous image capture of 25 cameras dermoscopy allowed |
serial TBP |
Drugge 2020 | retrospective single cohort |
n = 218 (subgroup of Drugge 2019) USA |
personal or family history of melanoma ≥4 dysplastic nevi ≥100 nevi |
simultaneous image capture of 25 cameras dermoscopy allowed |
serial TBP |
Feit 2004 | retrospective single cohort |
n = 576 USA |
no special risk factors as inclusion criteria | standardized series of poses dermoscopy allowed, no SDDI |
baseline TBP |
Rademaker 2010 | retrospective two cohorts |
n = 100 patients (female n = 53, male n = 47) with melanoma (n = 52 invasive, n = 48 in situ) mean age 51 years New Zealand |
patients diagnosed with melanoma or melanoma-in-situ | panoramic views, macroscopic views and dermoscopic views Nikon D50 Digital SLR camera for panoramic images Hewlett Packard Photosmart 912 or Canon Photoshot G6 1/1.8 inch 7 megapixel CCD digital camera for macro/micro images SDDI |
serial TBP |
Risser 2007 | retrospective two cohorts (TBP vs. non-TBP) |
median age 33.6 years n = 128 (female n = 71; male n = 57) USA |
multiple atypical nevi | no dermoscopy | n.r. |
Strunck 2020 | retrospective two cohorts |
>18 years median age 40 years (range 18–84) n = 1955 (female n = 1179, male n = 776) US |
no special risk factors as inclusion criteria |
dermoscopy, but no SDDI | n.r. |
Truong 2016 | retrospective single cohort |
>18 years median age 39.0 years n = 926 (female n = 541, male n = 385) USA |
no special risk factors as inclusion criteria |
n.r. | n.r. |
1 Abbreviation: n.r. = not reported, SDDI = sequential digital dermoscopy imaging, TBP = total body photography.