Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 12;22(4):1824. doi: 10.3390/ijms22041824

Table 1.

Overview over cardiovascular mitochondrial transplantation studies.

Study Model Mitochondrial Source Protocol/Application Outcomes
Doulamis
2020 [134]
Diabetic and non-diabetic rats -autologous or from diseased animals
-pectoralis major muscle
-ischemia/reperfusion in Langendorff perfused hearts in a T2D model
-antegrade i.c.
-Prior: mitochondrial ATP content ↓ in diabetic rats
-LVdevP ↑ in both groups (higher in group with healthy mitochondria), LVEDP ↓ + IS ↓in both groups
→no difference in cardiac function, IS and CBF between both groups (except LVdevP)
-tissue ATP ↑ (higher in group with healthy mitochondria)
rats
-syngeneic
-pectoralis major muscle
-for biodistribution
-antegrade i.c.
-distributed throughout the heart
-human cardiac fibroblasts -for biodistribution
-retrograde i.c.
-distributed within myocardial fibers
Ramirez-Barbieri 2019 [132] mice -syngeneic + allogeneic
-gastrocnemius + quadriceps femoris muscle
-single or serial i.p.
in a skin graft model
-no inflammatory or autoimmune responses (IgM antibodies, IL4, TNF-α, skin graft survival time, lymphocyte infiltration, free mtDNA, histological changes in heart and lung)
Moskowitzova 2019 [130] mice -syngeneic
-gastrocnemius muscle
-heart transplantation
-29h cold ischemia time
-i.c. before transplantation + 5 min after transplantation
-beating score ↑, EF ↑and FS ↑, necrosis and inflammatory cell infiltration ↓
-no differences in TUNEL+ nuclei
-myocardial injury (contraction bands) in vehicle groups
rats -antegrade i.c. -diffuse distribution in the heart
Guariento 2020 [125] pigs -autologous
-pectoralis muscle
-circulatory death/Ischemia/cardioplegia/reperfusion
-single or two injections
(2nd after 2 h of ex-situ heart perfusion and reperfusion for additional 2 h)
-LV/ventricular peak developed pressure ↑, FS ↑, myocardial oxygen consumption ↑, IS ↓
Guariento 2020 [126] pigs -autologous
--pectoralis major muscle
-preischemic intracoronary single or serially injections
-ischemia/reperfusion
-CBF ↑ pre-RI period and during reperfusion
-myocardial function ↑ (EF ↑ + LV Pdev ↑, LV dP/dt max↑, LV Ped ↓ SS ↑, FS ↑), IS ↓; necrosis + edema ↓, preserved mitochondrial structure
→ no differences between single and serial injections
McCully 2009 [129] rabbits -allogenic
-left ventricle
-ischemia/reperfusion-in excised hearts -LVPDP + SS + ATP content ↑, LVEDP + IS + CK-MB and cTnI, caspase-3-like activity ↓,
-no differences in TUNEL+ nuclei
-mitochondria viable and detectable; located near the myocytes
-frozen mitochondria/ mitochondrial components or mitochondrial DNA/RNA -LVPDP ↓, LVEDP ↑, SS ↓ + IS ↑, RCI ↓, oxygen consumption ↓ compared to fresh mitochondria
Masuzawa 2013 [128] in vivo:
rabbits
-autologous
-pectoralis major muscle
optical mapping: liver mitochondria
-ischemia/reperfusion
recovery for 2h or 28days
-no arrhythmogenicity, decreased necrosis, enhanced postischemic function, IS ↓, CK-MB ↓ and cTnI ↓, increase of tissue ATP content in AAR, percent systolic wall thickening ↑ compared to vehicle, segmental hypokinesis in vehicles
TUNEL+ nuclei ↓ and caspase 3 activity ↓, no inflammatory effect (hsCRP↓, IL6↓, TNFa↓), no antimitochondrial antibodies after 4 weeks
-proteomic analyses: generation of precursor metabolites for energy ↑ and cellular respiration↑
-mitochondria in the interstitial spaces surrounding
cardiomyocytes at 0, 2, 4, 8 and 24 h following injection-fraction of the labeled mitochondria within cardiomyocytes 2 h after injection
-xenogeneic human mitochondria from HeLa cells
separate group:
-biodistribution
-injection in tissue
-majority of mitochondria in the interstitial spaces, partly localized within cardiomyocytes
in vitro - HeLa- derived intact and sonicated mitochondria subgroup:
-co culture of HeLa- derived intact and sonicated mitochondria and human PBMCs
no upregulation of cytokines associated with rejection (IL-1, IL-4, IL-6, IL-12, IL-18, IP-10 and macrophage inflammatory protein-1a and -1b)
EGF↑, GRO↑, IL-6↑ and MCP-3↑ →associated with enhanced postinfarct cardiac function
in vitro -syngeneic
-rat liver mitochondria
subgroup:
-internalization
-neonatal rat cardiomyocytes cocultured with mitochondria
-majority of mitochondria internalized within 24 h of incubation
-oxygen consumption ↑
in vitro -xenogeneic
-HeLa cell mitochondria
subgroup:
-internalization
-cardiomyocytes incubated with mitochondria
-mitochondria adherent to cells within 2 h and internalized within 8–24 h
-no colocalization with lysosomes or autophagosomes
Kaza 2017 [127] pigs -autologous
-pectoralis major muscle
-ischemia/reperfusion
-subendocardial injections
-4 weeks recovery
-IS↓, no immune and inflammatory response and cytokine activation, no arrhythmia,
-mitochondrial damage and contraction bands in vehicle hearts
-no differences in systolic function (EF, FS and global circumferential strain)
Blitzer 2020 [122] pigs -autologous
-pectoralis major muscle
-ischemia/reperfusion
-delayed i.c. application
-LVEF↑, EF ↑, FS ↑, fractional area change, IS ↓, LV EDP ↓
-maximal rate of rise of LV pressure ↑, SS↑, LVFS↑, LVFAC↑, transient CBF ↑
Emani 2017 [124] children -autologous
-rectus abdominis muscle
-epicardial injection
2–15 d after ECMO cannulation
-4/5 improvement in ventricular function separation from ECMO, 3/5 survived
-no signs of immune responses (respiratory and renal status)
Shin 2019 [116] pigs -autologous
-pectoralis major muscle
safety and biodistribution:
-i.c. serially autologous injections, increasing concentrations




subgroup:
-efficacy in ischemia/reperfusion
-mitochondria located in the LV, partly in the arterial sheath and in the right carotid artery, small amount in descending aorta
-mitochondria within cardiomyocytes, interstitial spaces and the vascular walls
- enhanced regional and global LV function; CBF ↑ in higher concentrations; CBF↑ i.c., no increase after injection
-Improved myocardial function (FS↑, proportion LV fractional area change, EF ↑), IS↓
-devitalized mitochondria + mitochondria from HeLa- and HeLa-p0 cells -HeLa mitochondria: CBF ↑
CBF ↑ after i.c. injection of ATP but shorter duration
Weixler 2020 [133] in vitro
-autologous
-heart muscle, soleus muscle, gastrocnemius muscle
-internalization
-neonatal rat RV cardiomyocytes
-no differences in ATP content or mitochondrial internalization
in vivo:
pigs
-autologous
-gastrocnemius muscle
-injection into RV free wall after pulmonary
artery banding
-TAPSE ↑, contractile function↑, apoptosis ↓, myocardial fibrosis↓
Cowan 2016 [123] rabbits -human adult cardiac fibroblasts -imaging
-Langendorff hearts
-global and regional Ischemia/reperfusion
-i.c. or local injection
-most of mitochondria remained within heart throughout reperfusion
-majority within interstitial spaces between cardiomyocytes, partly co localization with cardiomyocytes
-autologous
-liver mitochondria
function:
-no ischemia or regional ischemia/reperfusion
-antegrade i.c.
myocardial function ↑ (EDP↓, IS ↓, SS ↑ and dP/dt ↑)