Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 17;9(2):412. doi: 10.3390/microorganisms9020412

Table 1.

Summary of alternative treatment strategies for fungal–bacterial biofilms.

Treatment Strengths Limitations Examples Biofilm Target Ref.
Antimicrobial peptides Broad-spectrum activity
Low toxicity
Low probability of resistance
Rapid
Efficient
Chemical instability
High production cost
Pharmacokinetic properties
gH625 analogues C. tropicalis–S. aureus–S. marcescens
C. albicans–K. pneumoniae
[75,76]
cholic acid-peptide conjugates C. albicans–S. aureus [77]
guanylated polymethacrylates C. albicans–S. aureus [78]
ε-poly-L-lysine in chitosan hydrogel P. aeruginosa–S. aureus–C. albicans [79]
Quorum quenchers Selective pressure only under QS conditions
Low probability of resistance
May disturb microbiota homeostasis
May cause enhanced virulence
thiazolidinedione-8 C. albicans–S. mutans [80,81]
QQ-5 and QQ-7 C. albicans–S. epidermidis [82]
Plant-derived components Wide variety of pharmaceutical and biological activities
Low toxicity
High volatility
Low stability
Low bioavailability Small scale production
citral and nepodine C. albicans–S. aureus [83,84]
citrus EOs and limonene P. aeruginosa–A. fumigatus or S. apiospermum [85]
eugenol C. albicans–S. mutans [86]
curcumin C. albicans–S. aureus
C. albicans–A. baumannii
[87,88]
carvacrol C. albicans–S. aureus [89]
Rhamnus prinoides stem extract C. albicans–S. mutans [90]
Photodynamic therapy Broad-spectrum activity
No toxicity
Low probability of resistance
Limited effect against biofilms
in vitro studies rarely translate into animal models
erythrosine—green light C. albicans–S. sanguinis [91]
acrylic resins doped with Undaria pinnatifida—blue light C. albicans–S. sanguinis–S. mutans–L. acidophilus [92]
Zn(II)chlorin e6 methyl ester—red light C. albicans–E. faecalis [93]
Chitosan No toxicity
BiodegradableLow cost
Good accessibility
Low immunogenicity
Poor solubility in water carboxymethyl chitosan C. albicans–C. tropicalis–S. epidermidis–S. salivarius–R. dentocariosa–L. gasseri [94,95]
C. tropicalis–S. epidermidis [96]
Nanoparticles Enhanced bioavailability of loaded drugs
Targeted delivery
Easier penetration inside biofilm
Protection of drugs from external environment
Possible toxicity to mammalian cells
Unknown processes of in vivo metabolism clearanceLong-term toxicity
Difficult scale-up
High-cost
polymeric NPs
magnetic NPs
mesoporous silica NPs
silver NPs
cf. Table 2 [97,98]
Probiotics Restores and maintains the balance of microbiota
Good accessibility
Easy to use
Limited survival of viable probiotic cells
Lack of clinical studies and mode-of-action studies
S. boulardii–L. acidophilus–L. rhamnosus–B. breve with amylase C. albicans or C. tropicalis–E. coli–S. marcenscens [99]
supernatant probiotic Lactobacillus C. albicans–C. tropicalis–S. salivarius–R. dentocariosa–S. epidermidis [100]
L. salivarius C. albicans–S. mutans [101]