Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 20;11(2):359. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics11020359

Table 1.

A list of related studies that used histopathological images along with their limitations.

Article Segmentation Features Classifier Accuracy Medulloblastoma (MB) Class Limitations
[16] N/A
  • TICA 1

  • Wavelet analysis

  • 2-layered convolutional neural networks (CNN)

Soft-max 99.7% Anaplastic and Non- anaplastic
  • Use only one type of feature extraction either textural features or spatial features extracted from CNN.

  • Very small dataset (10 images only)

[28] N/A
  • TICA

Soft-max 97% Anaplastic and Non- anaplastic
  • Depends on only texture-based feature extractors.

  • Very small dataset (10 images only)

[12] N/A
  • Haar Wavelet Transform

k-NN 2 87% Anaplastic and Non- anaplastic
  • Use only one type of feature extraction (textural features) to build their computer-aided diagnosis (CADx)

  • Very small dataset (10 images only)

[29] N/A
  • Haar

  • Haralick

  • Laws textural features

RF 3 91% Anaplastic and Non- anaplastic
  • Use an only individual type of feature extraction to build their CADx

  • Very small dataset (6 images only)

[30] N/A
  • 16-layered CNN

  • 2-Layered CNN

softmax 76.6%
89.8%
Anaplastic and Non- anaplastic
  • Depends on only spatial deep learning-based feature extractors.

  • Very small dataset (10 images only)

[7] K-means clustering
  • HOG 4

  • GLCM 5

  • GLRM 6

  • Tamura

  • Color Feature

  • LBP 7

  • Morphological

  • Principal component analysis (PCA)

SVM 84.9%
  • Classic

  • Desmoplastic

  • Nodular

  • Large Cell (anaplastic)

  • Depends only on conventional handcrafted features.

  • They used only individual feature set to perform the classification task.

[31] K-means clustering
  • HOG

  • GLCM

  • rGLRM

  • Tamura

  • Color Feature

  • LBP

  • Morphological

  • MANOVA 8

SVM 65.2%
  • Classic

  • Desmoplastic

  • Nodular

  • Large Cell (anaplastic)

  • Depends only on conventional handcrafted features.

  • Used only individual feature set to perform the classification task.

[13] K-means clustering Different combinations of fused features including:
  • HOG

  • GLCM

  • GLRM

  • Tamura

  • LBP

  • PCA

SVM 96.7%
  • Classic

  • Desmoplastic

  • Nodular

  • Large Cell (anaplastic)

  • Depends only on conventional handcrafted features.

[32] N/A
  • AlexNet

Softmax 79.3%
  • Classic

  • Desmoplastic

  • Nodular

  • Large Cell (anaplastic)

  • Depends only on spatial deep learning (DL) features.

  • VGG-16 10

65.4%
[32] N/A
  • AlexNet DL features

SVM 93.21%
  • Classic

  • Desmoplastic

  • Nodular

  • Large Cell (anaplastic)

  • Depends only on spatial DL features.

  • Use Individual DL for the classification task.

  • VGG-16 DL features

93.38%

1 TICA: Topographic independent component analysis, 2 k-NN: k-nearest neighbors,3 RF: Random Forest, 4 HOG: Histogram of oriented gradients, 5 GLCM: grey level covariance matrix, 6 GLRM: grey level run matrix, 7 LBP: local binary pattern, 8 MANOVA: Multivariate analysis of variance, and 10 VGG: Visual Geometry Group.