Table 1.
Ref. | Species | PS | Light Source | Methodology | Log10
Reduction |
Inoculation Source | Tolerance |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bacteria | |||||||
[36] |
P. micros
A. actinomycetemcomitans |
GlamTMPn BOTHMPn |
4 × 250 W tungsten lamps | 10 cycles | Lethal a | Solid agar plates | No |
[18] |
E. coli
S. aureus |
MB | Non-thermal diode laser, 670 nm | 11 cycles (E. coli) 25 cycles (S. aureus) |
Sublethal | Surviving colonies from previous cycle | No |
[19] |
V. fischeri
E. coli |
Tri-Py+-Me-PF | 13 × 18W OSRAM 21 lamps, 380–700 nm |
10 cycles | Lethal | Single colony survivors from previous treatment used further as overnight culture | No |
[20] |
S. aureus
P. aeruginosa |
RLP068/Cl | Non-coherent halogen lamp, 600–700 nm | 20 cycles | Lethal | From each sample, 10 µL was subcultured to perform subsequent cycles | No |
[23] | S. aureus | - | SLD light probe/405 nm | 7 cycles | No data | Irradiated cells were growing in solid medium, then subcultured on another fresh medium and finally used for next experimental stage | Yes |
[22] | S. aureus | - | Tri-wave light ultrasound device, 464 nm, 850 nm; SLD light probe, 405 nm | 7 cycles | No data | Irradiated cells grown in solid medium then subcultured on another fresh medium and used for next experimental stage | Yes |
[24] |
A. baumannii
|
- | Omnilux clear-U light- emitting diode array, 415 nm | 10 cycles | Sublethal | Surviving bacterial cells from agar were collected and recultured for next cycle | No |
[26] | P. aeruginosa | - | LED, 415 nm | Irradiation of Petri dish containing bacterial suspension (10 cycles) | Sublethal and lethal | Treated suspension | No (after 9th cycle surviving fraction was increased by 2 log10) |
[27] | S. aureus | - | LED, 405 nm | 15 cycles | Sublethal | Surviving colonies | No |
[28] |
S. aureus
E. coli |
ZnTnHex-2-PyP | Overhead projector OHP-3100 p, broad spectrum | Continuous growth under sublethal conditions for 48 h (10–20 cycles) | Sublethal | Treated suspension | No |
[29] |
P. aeruginosa
A. baumannii E. coli |
- | LED, 405 nm | 20 cycles | Lethal | Single surviving colony | No (increased unstable aBL tolerance in 9th, 16th, and 17th cycles) |
P. aeruginosa (mouse skin abrasion wounds) | - | - | 5 cycles | Sublethal | - | No | |
[30] | E. faecalis | Ce6 MB |
No data | 4 cycles | Sublethal and lethal | Single surviving colony from agar plate | No |
[31] | S. aureus | RB - |
LED, 515 nm LED, 411 nm |
15 cycles | Sublethal | Treated suspension | Stable tolerance to RB-aPDI and aBL |
[33] | S. agalactiae | RB | LED, 515 nm | 15 cycles | Sublethal | Treated suspension | Stable tolerance |
[32] |
S. aureus
E. coli |
Zn-TBut4PyP | Tungsten lamp, 320–780 nm | 10 cycles | Lethal | Single surviving colony | No |
[35] | S. aureus | MB | Broadband visible light, 575–700 nm | 7 cycles | Sublethal | Treated suspension | Stable tolerance (cross-tolerance to TBO-aPDI) |
Viruses | |||||||
[21] | T4-like phage | Tri-Py+-Me-PF | 13 OSRAM 21 fluorescent lamps (18 W), 380–700 nm | 10 cycles | Lethal | Phage suspension prepared from previous experimental cycle sample | No |
Yeast | |||||||
[25] | C. albicans | - | LED, 415 nm | 10 cycles | Lethal | Surviving cells | Reduced aBL susceptibility with increasing number of cycles |
[20] | C. albicans | RLP068/Cl | Non-coherent halogen lamp, 600–700 nm | 20 cycles | Lethal | From each sample, 10 µL was subcultured to perform subsequent cycles | No |
a Cell viability reduction by 1–2 log10 (sublethal treatment) and by >3 log10 (lethal treatment). PS, photosensitizer; Ce6, chlorin chlorin-e6; GlamTMPn, (2,7,12,17-tetrakis(2-methoxy- ethyl)-9-glutaramidoporphycene); MB, methylene blue; RB, Rose Bengal; RLP068/Cl tetracationic Zn(II) phthalocyanine chloride; TMP, meso-tetra (N-methyl4-pyridyl) porphine tetra tosylate; Tri-Py+-Me-PF, tricationic porphyrin 5,10,15-tris(1-methylpyridinium-4-yl)-20-(pentafluorophe-nyl)porphyrin tri-iodide; Zn-TBut4PyP, tetracationic Zn-mesotetra-[4-N-(2‘-butyl) pyridyl]porphyrin; ZnTnHex-2-PyP, Zn(II) mesotetrakis (N-n-hexylpyridinium-2-yl)porphyrin.