Table 1.
Author | Year | Disease | Duration | Location | Sample size | Assessment | Selected results | Authors’ conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lee et al. | 2017 | PD | 3–5 days | Home | 92 PD | Active tasks | 20% of participants had objective improvement in motor function upon morning waking | Sleep benefit is a quantifiable motor phenomenon |
Arora et al. | 2018 |
PD iRBD |
7 days | Clinic and home |
334 PD 104 iRBD 84 HC |
Active tasks | Mean (SD) sensitivity and specificity was 84.6% (4.1%) and 88.3% (3.3%) in discriminating HC vs PD, 91.9% (3.5%) and 90.0% (3.7%) HC vs iRBD, and 87.5% (2.8%) and 90.1% (2.7%) iRBD vs PD | Smartphone tests can discriminate between iRBD, PD, and HC groups with a high degree of accuracy |
Zhan et al. | 2018 | PD | 6 months | Clinic and home |
Development Cohort: 129 PD Clinic Cohort: 23 PD 17 HC |
Active tasks | A novel mobile PD score (0–100) correlated well with the MDS-UPDRS (r = 0.81; P < .001), detected intra-day fluctuations with mean (SD) change of 13.9 (10.3), and demonstrated response to dopaminergic medications with mean (SD) improvement of 16.3 (5.6) | An objective smartphone-derived PD severity score can complement traditional assessments |
Lo et al. | 2019 | PD | 18 months | Clinic and home | 237 PD | Active tasks | Baseline smartphone data predicted the new onset of falls, freezing, postural instability, cognitive impairment, and functional impairment at 18 months with area under the curve ≥ 0.90 | Smartphone tests can predict clinical milestones at 18 months with a high degree of accuracy |
Lipsmeier et al. | 2018 | PD |
6 months (PD) 45 days (HC) |
Home |
43 PD 35 HC |
Active tasks Passive monitoring |
Test-retest reliability was moderate-excellent (mean ICC 0.84) PD participants spent 34% less time than HC on gait-related activities |
Smartphone apps generate reliable, sensitive, and meaningful data |
Cohen et al. | 2018 |
PD HD |
6 months | Home (PD) Clinic and Home (HD) |
51 PD 17 HD |
Active tasks Passive monitoring Paired smartwatch |
In the PD study, app-based medication reporting declined by 34%, symptom reporting by 44%, and streaming by 53% In the HD study, active motor task performance declined by 30% and streaming by 20% |
Long-term compliance is feasible, and appropriate participant selection is important |
Gordon et al. | 2019 | HD | 6 months | Clinic and home | 10 HD |
Active tasks Passive monitoring Paired smartwatch |
The chorea prediction model generated from the smartphone and smartwatch data had a sensitivty of 85% and specificity of 72% | Arm chorea is quantifiable with accelerometer data |
HC healthy control, PD Parkinson’s disease, HD Huntington’s disease, iRBD idiopathic REM sleep behavior disorder, MDS-UPDRS Movement Disorder Society-Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale, ICC intraclass correlation coefficient