Table 4.
Pneumonia Capture and Assessment | TRILOGY25 | KRONOS20 | FULFIL21,87 | TRIBUTE23 | ETHOS24 | IMPACT22,89 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Assessment method | NR | According to a clinical diagnosis of pneumonia by the investigator and confirmatory radiography within 14 days of diagnosis and treatment with antibiotics and at least two clinical signs, symptoms, or laboratory findingsa | A diagnosis of pneumonia was assigned according to the clinical judgement of the investigator. All suspected pneumonias were required to be confirmed by the presence of new infiltrate(s) on chest imaging and at least two signs or symptomsa | In cases of clinical features suggesting a diagnosis of pneumonia, investigators were asked to undertake, whenever possible, further investigations based on their clinical experience and judgement; over 80% of pneumonia cases were diagnosed based on medical imaging | According to a clinical diagnosis of pneumonia by the investigator and confirmatory radiography within 14 days of diagnosis and treatment with antibiotics and increased respiratory symptomsa | A diagnosis of pneumonia was assigned according to the clinical judgement of the investigator. All suspected pneumonias were required to be confirmed by the presence of new infiltrate(s) on chest imaging and at least two signs or symptomsa |
Capture and analysis/presentation method | Events reported as AEs, according to MedDRA v16.0 preferred terms: pneumonia, bronchopneumonia, and pneumonia aspiration | Events reported as AEs | Events reported as AEs and analyzed/presented as AESIs (according to a selection of 69 MedDRA preferred terms) | Events reported as AEs, according to MedDRA v18.0 preferred terms: pneumonia, bronchopneumonia, lobar pneumonia, pneumonia bacterial, pneumonia streptococcal, pneumonia viral, and interstitial lung diseaseb | Events reported as AEs | Events reported as AEs and analyzed/presented as AESIs (according to a selection of MedDRA preferred terms) |
Adjudication | No | All AEs reported as pneumonia were reviewed by an independent clinical endpoint committee | All SAEs were adjudicated by an independent clinical endpoint committee | No | All AEs reported as pneumonia were reviewed by an independent clinical endpoint committee | All SAEs were adjudicated by an independent adjudication committee blinded to treatment assignment |
Notes: AESIs/serious AESIs were defined as AEs/SAEs that are pharmacologically related to the use of ICS, LAMA, or LABA. aIncreased cough, increased sputum purulence or production, adventitious breath sounds on auscultation, dyspnea or tachypnoea, fever, elevated white blood cell counts, hypoxemia; bin addition, one event of pulmonary tuberculosis was considered, since the investigator reported that this was a tuberculous pneumonia; other events belonging to the pulmonary tuberculosis preferred term were not considered.
Abbreviations: AE, adverse event; AESI, adverse event of special interest; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; ICS, inhaled corticosteroid; LABA, long-acting β2-agonist; LAMA, long-acting muscarinic antagonist; MedDRA, Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities; NR, not reported; SAE, serious adverse event.