Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Mar 10.
Published in final edited form as: Transplantation. 2018 May;102(5):e219–e228. doi: 10.1097/TP.0000000000002148

Table 3.

Parameter inputs for decision tree and Markov model. L+/−: functioning or non-functioning liver allograft. K +/−: functioning or non-functioning kidney, allograft (if initial transplant is SLK) or native (if initial transplant is liver). KD: Kidney disease. OPTN-: Kidney disease not meeting OPTN criteria for SLK. OPTN+: Kidney disease meeting OPTN criteria for SLK.

Parameter Stratum Base Model Range Distribution Source Technical Appendix
Probability of outcome at month 1 post-index transplant
Post-SLK transplant:
  L+K− OPTN− 0.012 0.003–0.026 beta (4,334) SRTR cohort A
OPTN+ 0.019 0.010–0.030 beta (13,687)
  L−K+ OPTN− 0.003 0.000–0.011 beta (1,337) SRTR cohort A
OPTN+ 0.013 0.006–0.022 beta (9,691)
  Death OPTN− 0.024 0.010–0.042 beta (8,330) SRTR cohort A
OPTN+ 0.020 0.011–0.032 beta (14,686)
Post-liver transplant:
  L+K− No KD 0.003 0.001–0.005 beta (11,3289) 9 A
OPTN− 0.006 0.005–0.007 beta (215,34185)
OPTN+ 0.033 0.019–0.046 beta (23,680)
  L−K+ No KD 0.022 0.020–0.023 beta (722,32933) SRTR cohort A
OPTN− 0.018 0.016–0.020 beta (306,16758)
OPTN+ 0.013 0.009–0.019 beta (25,1866)
  Death No KD 0.023 0.021–0.024 beta (759,32896) SRTR cohort A
OPTN− 0.036 0.033–0.038 beta (609,16455)
OPTN+ 0.044 0.036–0.054 beta (84,1807)
Transition probabilities per cycle, month 1 and beyond post-index transplant
Post-SLK transplant:
  Death (L+K+ → death) time-dependent, see Table A5 non-parametric SRTR cohort A
  Liver graft fails (L+K+ → L−K+L+K− → L−K−) time-dependent, see Table A5 non-parametric SRTR cohort A
  Kidney graft fails (L+K+ → L+K−) time-dependent, see Table A5 non-parametric SRTR cohort A
Post-liver transplant:
  Death (L+K+ → death) time-dependent, see Table B5 non-parametric SRTR cohort A
  Liver graft fails (L+K+ → L−K+L+K− → L−K−) time-dependent, see Table A5 non-parametric SRTR cohort A
  Native kidneys fail (L+K+ → L+K−) time-dependent, see Table A5 non-parametric 9 A
Post-both transplants:
  Death on dialysis (L+K− → death) all death rate without dialysis × hazard ratio (3.32) hazard ratio: 2.96–3.71 hazard ratio: log-normal (1.200,0.058) 10 A
  Liver graft failure on dialysis (L+K− → L−K−) all liver failure rate without dialysis × hazard ratio (1.49) hazard ratio: 1.10–2.04 hazard ratio: log-normal (0.3988,0.1573) 11 A
  Death after second transplant (kidney) all death rate without second transplant × time-dependent hazard ratio time-dependent, see Figure B2 non-parametric 12 B
  Kidney graft failure after second transplant (kidney) time-dependent, see Table B2 non-parametric 12 B
Kidney wait-list information
  Proportion of patients who have matching living donors all 0.059 0.049–0.069 beta (132,2105) 12 B
Adjustment for liver / SLK re-transplantation
  Hazard ratio for death (compared to first transplant) all 1.7 1.56–1.84 log-normal (0.531,0.042) 13 A
Probability of receiving SLK pre-OPTN (based on 2013 data)
No KD 0.000 0 none 2013 SRTR cohort
OPTN− 0.022 0.015–0.030 beta (34,1510)
OPTN+ 0.326 0.272–0.382 beta (91,188)
Utility weights
Post-liver transplant:
  No kidney failure all 0.747 0.720–0.774 beta (742,251) 14 D
  With kidney failure all 0.573 0.523–0.624 beta (210,156) 14,15 D
a

Gamma distribution is described here by a shape parameter, α, and an inverse scale parameter, β.