Table 2.
Study | Alfredson et al. [26, 41] | Boesen et al. [47] | Masood et al. [45] | Mayer et al. [50] | Neeter et al. [51] | Rabusin et al. [46] | Tumilty et al. [48] | Silbernagel et al. [25, 39, 49] | Sancho et al. [23] | Yu et al. [24] | Yu et al. [24] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Intervention | Eccentric exercises | Eccentric exercises | Eccentric exercises | Eccentric exercises | Toe-raises | Eccentric exercises | Eccentric exercises | Toe-raises | Hopping intervention | Eccentric exercises | Concentric exercises |
Exercise details | Straight and bend knee heel drop off step | Straight and bend knee heel drop off step | Straight and bend knee heel drop off step | Standardised physiotherapy with eccentric training 10 single 30-min sessions | Two-legged concentric–eccentric toe-raises | Straight and bend knee heel drop off step | Straight and bend knee heel drop off step | Two-legged and one-legged concentric–eccentric toe-raises, and eccentric and fast rebounding toe-raises | 4 levels of exercise include isometric, isotonic, jump and hopping | Straight and bend knee heel drop off step | Heel raises using theraband with straightened knee, sit on a chair and lift the heels. Hold onto the wall and lift the heels of both feet and progress to injured one. In addition to Hamstring and calf muscle stretching |
Equipment | Backpack and a weight machine | U | Backpack | U | U | Backpack and a weight machine | U | Backpack and a weight machine | U | Bag with dumbbell | Elastic band |
Provider | Physical therapist | Physical therapist | U | Physical therapist | Physical therapist | Podiatrist | Physical therapist | Physical therapist | Physical therapist | Research assistant | Research assistant |
Delivery | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually | Individually |
Supervision | U | U | U | U | U | U | U | Y | Y | U | U |
Reporting of adherence | N | N | N | N | N | Y | N | U | Y | N | N |
Motivation strategies | N | N | N | N | N | N | N | N | N | N | N |
Decision rules for progressing | Based on pain level | Based on pain level | Based on pain level | U | Based on pain level | Based on pain level | Based on pain level | Based on pain level | Based on load tolerance | Based on pain level | Based on pain level |
Illustrations of ex | Y | Y | Y | U | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | U | U |
Home programme content | Y | Y | U | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | U | U |
Nonexercised components | Running activity was allowed if not agg pain | sport activities were allowed if not agg pain | N | U | N | N | U | U | Running activity was allowed if not agg pain | N | N |
Incidence of adverse events documented | N | U | N | N | Y | Y | N | Y | Y | N | N |
Location of exercises performed | U | U | U | U | U | U | U | U | U | U | U |
Dosage* | 3, 15 reps, twice a day 7 days/week, for 12 weeks, NS | 3, 15 reps, twice a day 7 days/week, for 12 weeks, NS | 3, 15 reps, twice a day 7 days/week, for 12 weeks, NS | 3, 15, Freq ns, 2-3 time/week, for 4 weeks, NS | 2, 30 reps, 3 times/day for 10 weeks, NS | 3, 15 reps, twice a day 7 days/week, for 12 weeks, NS | 3, 15 reps, twice a day 7 days/week, for 12 weeks, NS | 3, 10–15 reps, once a day for 12 weeks to 6 months, NS | Starts with 5 sets of 45 s, three times a day for 12 weeks, BW | 3, 15 reps, Freq ns, for 8 weeks, NS | 3, 15 reps, Freq ns, for 8 weeks, NS |
Tailoring | Generic, intensity was based on the patients’ status | Generic, intensity was based on the patients’ status | Generic, intensity was based on the patients’ status | U | Generic, progression was based on the patients’ status | Generic, intensity was based on the patients’ status | Generic, intensity was based on the patients’ status | Generic, intensity and number of repetitions were based on the patients’ status | Generic, progression was based on the patients’ status | Individual | Individual |
Starting level | BW | U | BW | U | U | BW | U | Bilateral | Isometric seated heel raises with BW | Bilateral | Bilateral |
Exercise intervention is delivered as planned | U | U | U | U | U | U | U | U | Y | U | U |
Y,yes; N, no; U, unclear; NS, not specified; BW, body weight; ex., exercise; *dosage [sets, repetitions, duration, intensity]