Table 1.
Author, year | Aim | Meta-analysis | Search date | No. and type of relevant studies | Age and chronic pain population(s) | Setting(s) | Type of intervention(s) | AMSTAR-2 quality rating |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abbott et al., 201739 | To determine the effectiveness of psychosocial interventions for reducing pain in school-aged children with recurrent abdominal pain | Yes* | 06/2017 | 18 RCTs | 6–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain, functional abdominal pain, IBS |
Gastroenterology and pain outpatient clinic, community | Psychological | High |
Abujaradeh et al., 201841 | To determine the benefits/efficacy of mindfulness-based interventions implemented among adolescents with chronic diseases in clinical settings | No | 11/2017 | 8 RCTs and NRS | 12–18 years Mixed chronic pain |
Tertiary care multidisciplinary pain clinic or hospital setting | Psychological | Low |
American Academy of Pediatrics, 200534 and Di Lorenzo et al., 200535 | To examine the diagnostic and therapeutic value of a medical and psychologic history, diagnostic tests, and pharmacological and behavioral therapy for chronic abdominal pain | No + CPG | ??/2002 | 8 RCTs and NRS | 5–17 years Abdominal pain |
?? | Psychological Pharmacological Other |
Low |
Anie and Green, 201574 | To examine the evidence that psychological interventions improve the ability of people with sickle cell disease to cope with their condition | Yes* | 02/2015 | 4 RCTs | 6–18 years+ Sickle cell disease |
“Urban setting” | Psychological | Moderate |
Arruda et al., 201862 | To review the comorbidities and treatment of chronic migraine in children and adolescents in the last ten years, summarizing evidence-based recommendations for disease management | No | ??/2017 | 4 RCTs and NRS | 7–17 years Headaches, migraine |
Inpatient, outpatient headache clinics | Pharmacological Interdisciplinary |
Critically low |
Badawy et al., 201875 | To (1) review the types of technological tools used for self-management of sickle cell disease, (2) discover and describe what self-management activities these tools were used for, and (3) assess the efficacy of these technologies in self-management | No | 11/2016 | 5 RCTs and NRS | 13–18 years+ Sickle cell disease |
e-Health | Psychological Interdisciplinary |
Low |
Bailey and McManus, 200863 | To evaluate which treatment could be effective in the emergency department for children with migraine and status migrainous | No | 06/2007 | 14 RCTs | 4–18 years Migraines |
Emergency department, outpatient neurology clinics | Pharmacological | Critically low |
Barnes, 201564 | To examine treatments for acute attacks and the effects of pharmacological prophylaxis for migraine headache in children | No | 06/2014 | 23 RCTs and reviews of RCTs | 3–18 years Migraines, headaches |
?? | Pharmacological | Moderate |
Bredlau et al., 201371 | To review the use of ketamine in the treatment of cancer-related pain in adults and children | No | 02/2013 | 5 NRS | 4–19 years Cancer pain |
?? | Pharmacological | Low |
Brent et al., 200959 | To evaluate behavioral and psychological treatments applied to pediatric functional gastrointestinal disorders | No | ??/2007 | 12 RCTs and NRS | 4–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain, IBS, functional abdominal pain, functional dyspepsia, stomachache, stomach pain |
Outpatient, community | Psychological Other Interdisciplinary |
Critically low |
Cairns et al., 201876 | To evaluate interventions for patellar tendon–related pain in children and adolescents | No | 11/2017 | 3 RCTs and NRS | 10–18 years Patellar tendon pain, Osgood-Schlatter’s |
University physical therapy, secondary care orthopedics, orthopedic surgery department | Physical Pharmacological Interdisciplinary |
Moderate |
Cohen et al., 201767 | To assess the effects of psychosocial therapies on pain and function in children with rheumatic diseases | No | 09/2015 | 5 RCTs and NRS | 5–18 years Juvenile fibromyalgia, juvenile arthritis |
?? | Psychological | Low |
Cooper, Wiffen, et al., 201742 | To assess the analgesic efficacy of antiepileptic drugs used to treat chronic non-cancer pain in children and adolescents | Yes* | 09/2016 | 2 RCTs | 7–18 years Fibromyalgia, CRPS-I or neuropathic pain |
Tertiary care centers | Pharmacological | High |
Cooper, Heathcote, et al, 201772 | To assess the analgesic efficacy of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs used to treat cancer-related pain in children and adolescents | Yes* | 02/2017 | 0 RCTs | <18 years Cancer-related pain |
Pharmacological | High | |
Cooper, Fisher, et al., 20178 | To assess the analgesic efficacy of opioids used to treat chronic non-cancer pain in children and adolescents | Yes* | 09/2016 | 0 RCTs | <18 years Chronic non-cancer pain |
Pharmacological | High | |
Eccleston et al., 201543 | To evaluate the efficacy of psychological therapies that include parents of children and adolescents with chronic illnesses | Yes* | 07/2014 | 14 RCTs | <19 years Headache, sickle cell, recurrent abdominal pain, IBS, fibromyalgia, arthritis, mixed pain conditions |
Outpatient clinics, community | Psychological | High |
Eccleston et al., 201744 | To assess the analgesic efficacy of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs used to treat chronic non-cancer pain in children and adolescents | Yes* | 09/2016 | 7 RCTs | 2–18 years Chronic non-cancer pain |
Pediatric rheumatology tertiary care units, pediatric centers, clinical centers | Pharmacological | High |
Egunsola et al., 201945 | To examine the efficacy and safety of gabapentin and pregabalin for pain in children and adolescents | No | 11/2017 | 2 RCTs | 7–18 years CRPS, neuropathic pain, fibromyalgia |
?? | Pharmacological | High |
Fellas et al., 201770 | To review the evidence for physical and mechanical interventions for lower-limb problems in juvenile idiopathic arthritis | Yes | 06/2015 | 2 RCTs | 5–19 years Juvenile idiopathic arthritis |
Hospitals, pediatric rheumatology clinics | Physical | High |
Ferro and Speechley, 200868 | To review of the prevalence of complementary and alternative medicine use in juvenile idiopathic arthritis, determinants of use, and outcomes associated with various therapies | No | 10/2008 | 3 RCTs and NRS | “Children” Juvenile idiopathic arthritis |
?? | Psychological Other |
Critically low |
Fisher et al., 201846 | To determine any effect of psychological therapy for chronic and recurrent pain in children and adolescents | Yes* | 05/2018 | 47 RCTs | 6–18 years Mixed chronic pain, headaches, abdominal pain, IBS, inflammatory bowel disease, fibromyalgia, temporomandibular disorders, sickle cell disease |
Hospitals, outpatient clinics, patient home | Psychological | High |
Fisher et al., 201947 | To determine the efficacy of psychological therapies delivered remotely for the management of chronic pain in children and adolescents | Yes* | 05/2018 | 10 RCTs | 7–17 years Headache, juvenile idiopathic arthritis, abdominal pain, musculoskeletal, sickle cell disease |
Via technology at home (Internet, CD-ROM) | Psychological | High |
Hechler et al., 201548 | To review studies the effects of pediatric intensive interdisciplinary pain treatment | Yes | 02/2014 | 10 RCTs and NRS | 8–22 years Mixed (CRPS, headache, neuropathic, idiopathic, fibromyalgia/diffuse, disease-related, back, abdominal, pelvic, musculoskeletal, etc.) |
Inpatient, day hospital setting, rehabilitation | Interdisciplinary | Moderate |
Horvath et al., 201260 | To evaluate the effect of dietary fibers for treating abdominal pain-related functional gastrointestinal disorders in children | No | 12/2011 | 3 RCTs | 3–16 years Abdominal pain |
Hospitals, community clinics | Other | Low |
Huertas-Ceballos 200877, | To determine the effectiveness of medication for recurrent abdominal pain in school-age children | Yes* | 12/2006 | 3 RCTs | 5–18 years Abdominal migraine, recurrent abdominal pain, dyspepsia, IBS |
?? | Pharmacological Other |
High |
Huertas-Ceballos 200878 | To determine the effectiveness of psychosocial interventions for recurrent abdominal pain or IBS in school-age children | Yes* | 12/2006 | 6 RCTs | 5–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain |
Community, outpatient clinic | Psychological Other Interdisciplinary |
High |
Kichline and Cushing, 201949 | To evaluate the effect of exercise on pediatric chronic pain | Yes | 12/2016 | 11 RCTs and NRS | 6–16 years Arthritis, fibromyalgia, low back pain, cancer, mixed |
?? | Physical | Low |
Liossi et al., 201950 | To review the effectiveness of interdisciplinary interventions in the management of pediatric chronic pain | Yes | 03/2018 | 28 RCTs and NRS | 6–21 years Mixed (headache, abdominal pain, back, migraines, CRPS, pelvic, neuropathic, widespread/fibromyalgia, musculoskeletal), oncology (tumors, leukemia), arthritis |
Inpatient, day treatment, outpatient | Interdisciplinary | High |
Lonergan, 201651 | To examine the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy in the treatment of chronic pain in children and adolescents | Yes | 12/2014 | 9 RCTs | 6–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain, fibromyalgia, headache or migraine |
Outpatient, university, patient home | Psychological | Critically low |
Martin et al., 201740 | To review the effectiveness of pharmacological interventions for recurrent abdominal pain in school-age children | Yes* | 06/2016 | 16 RCTs | 5–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain |
Hospital pediatric outpatient clinics | Pharmacological | High |
Michel et al., 201152 | To review relevant pediatric buprenorphine data, particularly in children suffering chronic pain | No | ?? | 12 NRS | “Children” Oncology, postoperative |
Pharmacological | Critically low | |
Newlove-Delgado et al., 201710 | To examine the effectiveness of dietary interventions in improving pain in school-age children with recurrent abdominal pain | Yes* | 06/2016 | 19 RCTs | 4–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain, functional gastrointestinal disorders, IBS |
Pediatric gastroenterology clinics, primary care pediatric practices, community clinics | Other | High |
Ng et al., 201765 | To review the efficacy of cognitive–behavioral therapy for pediatric migraine | Yes | 05/2016 | 17 RCTs | 7–18 years Migraine |
Medical setting, school | Psychological | Critically low |
Nijhof et al., 201869 | To review the evidence for nonpharmacological treatment for chronic musculoskeletal pain in pediatric rheumatic disease | No | 10/2017 | 11 RCTs and NRS | 5–18 years Juvenile idiopathic arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus |
?? | Psychological Physical Interdisciplinary |
Low |
Ostojic et al., 201880 | To determine the efficacy of interventions for the management of pain in children and adolescents with cerebral palsy | No | 04/2018 | 50 RCTs and NRS | <18 years Cerebral palsy (postoperative, hypertonia, cerebral palsy spastic hip disease) |
Hospital, outpatient clinic | Physical Pharmacological Other Interdisciplinary |
Low |
Palermo et al., 201053 | To examine the efficacy of psychological interventions for pain and emotional and physical functioning in children | Yes | 08/2008 | 18 RCTs | 4–18 years Headache, migraine, abdominal pain, fibromyalgia |
Hospital or clinic | Psychological | Moderate |
Scheper et al., 201381 | To review state of the art of diagnostics and treatment of generalized joint hyper mobility and joint hyper mobility syndrome in children and young adults | No | ?? | 3 RCTs | 0–18 years Osteogenesis imperfecta, generalize joint hyper mobility, joint hyper mobility syndrome, Ehlers-Danlos |
?? | Physical Other |
Moderate |
Shah et al., 201654 | This review the role of interventional procedures in the treatment of chronic pain in children and adolescents | No | 03/2013 | 133 NRS | “Children” Migraine, headache, neuropathic, postoperative, cystic fibrosis, sickle cell, juvenile idiopathic arthritis, head, abdomen, fibromyalgia, CRPS, phantom limb, back, chest, cancer |
Inpatient, outpatient settings | Pharmacological | Critically low |
Sprenger et al., 201161 | To examine the effectiveness of psychological therapies for children with recurrent abdominal pain | Yes | 11/2009 | 10 NRS | 4–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain |
?? | Psychological | Critically low |
Tomé-Pires and Miró, 201255 | To review hypnotic treatments for chronic and cancer procedure-related pain in children | No | 05/2010 | 2 RCTs | 6–18 years Headache, abdominal pain |
?? | Psychological | Critically low |
Trautmann et al., 200666 | To describe the state of evidence in the treatment of pediatric headaches | Yes | 07/2004 | 23 RCTs | 7–18 years Headache |
Outpatient clinic, school | Psychological | Low |
Velleman et al., 201056 | To review the use of computerized cognitive behavioral therapy with children and adolescents with pain | Yes | ??/2008 | 4 RCTs | 7–17 years Headaches, recurrent abdominal pain, musculoskeletal |
Via computer in outpatient clinic, community | Psychological | Low |
Weydert et al., 200357 | To review treatments for recurrent abdominal pain in children | No | ??/2001 | 10 RCTs | 3–18 years Recurrent abdominal pain, IBS, abdominal migraine |
Primary and tertiary care, community | Psychological Pharmacological Other Interdisciplinary |
Critically low |
Wicksell et al., 201558 | To provide an overview of research on acceptance and commitment therapy for youths with physical concerns | No | ?? | 8 RCTs and NRS | 7–18 years Chronic pain |
?? | Psychological | Critically low |
Wiffen et al., 201773 | To assess the analgesic efficacy, of opioids used to treat cancer-related pain in children and adolescents | Yes* | 02/2017 | 0 RCTs | <18 years Cancer-related pain |
— | Pharmacological | High |
Yeung et al., 201779 | To review characteristics and management of endometriosis in adolescents | No | ?? | 8 NRS | 10–25 years Endometriosis |
?? | Other Interdisciplinary |
Critically low |
Zernikow et al., 201237 and Häuser et al., 201236 | To provide a definition, diagnosis, and therapy of chronic widespread pain and so-called fibromyalgia syndrome in children and adolescents | No + CPG | 12/2010 | ?? RCTs and NRS | “Children and adolescents” Chronic widespread pain, fibromyalgia |
Inpatient, outpatient | Psychological Physical Pharmacological Interdisciplinary |
Moderate |
* = Cochrane review; RCT = randomized controlled trial; IBS = irritable bowel syndrome; NRS = nonrandomized study; CPG = clinical practice guideline; ?? = unclear/unknown; CRPS = complex regional pain syndrome; — = no studies.