Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 12;7:e411. doi: 10.7717/peerj-cs.411

Table 13. Results of all datasets.

EM LR SVR WELM
k = 100
KELM
k = 100
ELM
k = 100
DCS-ELM
Chebyshev
DCS-ELM
Iterative
DCS-ELM
Logistic
DCS-ELM
Piecewise
DCS-ELM
Tent
Energy1 R2 0.92 0.91 0.9336 0.9055 0.9809 0.8672 0.9905 0.8723 0.9826 0.9794
RMSE 2.9421 2.09736 2.5596 3.0598 1.5470 5.5700 1.2450 4.9494 1.6421 1.2402
MAE 2.0877 2.0435 1.9333 2.3510 1.0524 3.1354 0.8039 2.8124 1.0862 0.8969
Energy2 R2 0.89 0.88 0.9516 0.8838 0.9730 0.9478 0.9779 0.9626 0.9708 0.9636
RMSE 3.2188 3.2484 2.0968 3.1851 2.0885 2.2023 1.7219 2.4084 1.9607 2.6307
MAE 2.2643 2.2441 1.5415 2.3735 1.1709 1.5281 1.0744 1.5189 1.1168 1.2881
House R2 0.57 0.56 0.6041 0 0.5677 0.5932 0.6087 0.5676 0.6143 0.5292
RMSE 8.9474 9.041 8.0768 29.2569 7.3118 7.2347 6.6873 7.4086 6.5335 7.2982
MAE 6.2745 6.2238 5.7113 24.6785 5.5837 5.7505 5.0731 5.7930 5.2752 5.7343
Servo R2 0.48 0.17 0.4936 0.6997 0.7893 0.7189 0.8271 0.2270 0.8265 0.7924
RMSE 1.1348 1.4304 1.0887 0.7698 0.4511 0.5118 0.3574 0.8743 0.6183 0.3832
MAE 0.9169 0.7850 0.7978 0.5153 0.3549 0.4323 0.2626 0.6280 0.4905 0.2798
Vfunnel R2 0.7820 0.8011 0.6995 0.6746 0.6617 0.6894 0.7056 0.6949 0.6794 0.6656
RMSE 2.2727 2.1707 2.4589 2.6789 2.8365 2.4968 2.0798 2.8948 2.7398 2.8453
MAE 1.8330 1.7657 1.9675 2.2002 2.0797 2.2025 1.6262 2.4825 2.1089 2.5755
T50 R2 0.7669 0.7705 0.8569 0.7577 0.8565 0.8499 0.8533 0.8687 0.8665 0.8528
RMSE 2.2360 2.2190 1.5121 2.1675 1.0099 0.9122 1.0020 0.8541 1.0644 1.0727
MAE 1.6917 1.5372 0.9690 1.6974 0.7960 0.7198 0.7318 0.6539 0.8750 0.7789
Slump-flow R2 0.6123 0.6607 0.6247 0.4873 0.6324 0.6862 0.6999 0.6453 0.6942 0.6251
RMSE 3.8928 3.6417 3.3328 4.4134 2.7543 2.4183 2.1685 2.8308 2.1747 3.0299
MAE 2.9481 2.6285 2.3177 3.3497 1.9247 1.7383 1.5668 2.0878 1.4862 1.7589
fc R2 0.7307 0.7630 0.7541 0.7298 0.7604 0.7905 0.8183 0.7882 0.8235 0.7750
RMSE 6.5560 6.1514 5.1207 5.9819 5.5749 6.2847 5.2188 4.4419 4.8539 4.8080
MAE 4.6861 4.3750 3.8332 4.5412 4.1536 4.8892 3.7992 3.3678 3.3575 3.5935