Table.
Study ID | Setting | Country | Total randomized (n) | Mean age (years) | Intervention | Control | Primary outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Martin 1993 | Single center, ICU | France | 32 | 52.5 | Norepinephrine (0.5 mcg/kg/min) | Norepinephrine (0.5 mcg/kg/min) | Systemic and regional haemodynamic achievement |
Annane 2007 | Multi-center, 19 ICU | France | 330 | 63 | Norepinephrine (0·2 mcg/kg/min min) ± dobutamine (5 mcg/kg/min) | Epinephrine (0·2 mcg/kg/min) ± placebo | 28-day all-cause mortality |
Morelli 2008 | Single center, ICU | Italy | 32 | 70 | Norepinephrine | Phenylephrine | Study drugs requirement, systemic and regional haemodynamic achievement |
Myburgh 2008 | Multi-center, 4 ICU | Australia | 280 | 59.9 | Norepinephrine | Epinephrine | Achievement of MAP goal >24 h without vasopressors |
Russell 2008 | Multi-center, 27 centers | Canada, Australia, and USA | 778 | 60.5 | Norepinephrine (5 to 15 mcg/min) | Vasopressin (0.01 to 0.03 U/min) | 28-day mortality of any cause |
De Backer 2010 | Multi-center, 8 ICU | Belgium, Austria, and Spain | 1,679 | 67.5 | Norepinephrine | Dopamine | Rate of death at 28 days |
Patel 2010 | Single center, ICU | USA | 252 | Not stated | Norepinephrine (maximum of 20 mcg/min) | Dopamine (maximum of 20 mcg/kg/min) | 28-day all-cause mortality |
Choudhury 2016 | Single center, ICU | India | 84 | 47.5 | Norepinephrine (7.5 mcg/min to 60 mcg/min) | Terlipressin (1.3 to 5.2 mcg/min) | Achievement of MAP of >65 mm Hg and maintenance of the same for the initial 48 hours |
Gordon 2016 | Multi-center, 18 ICU | United Kingdom | 409 | 66 | Norepinephrine (maximum of 12mcg/min) | Vasopressin (maximum of 0.06 U/min) | Kidney failure-free days during the 28 days after randomization |
Liu 2018 | Multi-center, 21 ICU | China | 617 | 61 | Norepinephrine (4 to 30mcg/min) | Terlipressin (20 to 160 mcg/h) | 28-day all-cause mortality |
Permpikul 2019 | Single-center, ED | Thailand | 310 | Not stated | Norepinephrine (0.05 mcg/kg/min) | Placebo (Dextrose 5% in water) | Shock control rate by 6 hours |
ICU, intensive care unit; mcg, microgram; kg, kilogram; min, minute; U, unit; h, hour; MAP, mean arterial pressure; ED, emergency department.