Note
| Author | Age (σ) | TC | LC | AC | IAQ | Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ahmed 22 , 23 | 15‐22 |
ta tr va= RHi= |
Eamb= | LAeq= | CO2 |
Actual thermal sensation Thermal comfort sensations Air‐conditioner set temperature at home Self‐reported ability to focus related to thermal discomfort Self‐reported ability to focus related to other symptoms than thermal discomfort Self‐reported headache Self‐reported fatigue Self‐reported dizziness Percentages of errors for cognitive tasks |
| Sarbu 26 | 21.17 (0.79) |
RHi ta tg top va |
CO2 |
Actual thermal sensation Concentrated and distributive attention |
||
| Siqueira 27 | 21 (2.89) |
RHi ta tg tr twb va pa |
Verbal Reasoning Numeric Reasoning Abstract Reasoning Spatial Reasoning Mechanical Reasoning Overall Score Heart rate Blood pressure |
|||
| Xiong 28 | 20‐24 | ta | Eamb | SPL |
Perception Memory Problem‐solving Attention |
|
| Yan 29 | 18‐21 |
RHi ta |
CRI CT LF Eamb |
CO2 | Recognition rate | |
| Gentile 30 | 16‐17 |
RHi ta |
Ec Eamb Lc Lw CRI CCT SPD |
CO2 |
Students' mood Light perception Saliva cortisol concentration |
|
| Barbic 31 |
20.07 (3.1) |
ta | = | CO2 |
Actual thermal sensation Short‐term memory and verbal ability test Reasoning test |
|
| Choi 32 | 23.53 (0.87) |
RHi ta |
LogCh LogCy LogEr LogPh LogRh Eamb CT |
LAeq |
Circadian system (melatonin and cortisol) Sleepiness perception Students' mood Visual comfort |
|
| Hoque 33 | 20.7 (4.2) |
RHi RHo ta to va |
Actual thermal sensation Exam scores |
|||
| Almaqra 34 | 22.02 (0.21) | Rhi = ta | SPL= |
Cognitive performance |
||
| Bajc 35 | 20‐25 |
RHi ta to tr va |
CO2 CO2o |
Concentration Productivity Actual percentage of dissatisfied Prediction of academic performance Actual thermal sensation |
||
| Mishra 24 , 25 | 18‐20 |
RHi tg to va vao |
CO2 |
Actual thermal sensation |
||
| Norbäck 36 | 20‐25 |
RHi to |
AC ACR CO2 N2O NCHO PM10 PSV VB VM |
Sinusitis problems Perceived indoor air quality Actual thermal sensation |
||
| Shelton 37 | ‐ | LAeq |
Transfer of knowledge Lexical decision task |
|||
| End 38 | 20.21 (2.13) | LAeq | Knowledge | |||
| Liu 39 | 20 (17‐22) |
CLO RHi ta tg to tout tr va |
CO2 PM2.5 |
Actual thermal sensation Perceived IAQ |
||
| Rabelo 40 | 29 (22‐50) |
F0 SPL Pho CyD |
Vocal intensity Percentage of phonation Cycle dose |
|||
| Lee 41 | 21‐30 |
RHi ta tr top |
Ehor |
LAeq SPL |
CO2 |
Actual thermal sensation Calculated occupants acceptance of the indoor environment The calculated overall acceptance of the indoor environmental quality Self‐reported learning performance |
| Castro‐Martínez 42 |
22.4 (2.4) 21.7 (2.6) |
RT |
Statistics Mathematics Attention |
See footnote to Table for explanation of all variables and symbols used.
σ = standard deviation.
TC = Thermal performance indicators: CLO = clothing insulation value, RHi = indoor relative humidity, RHo = outdoor relative humidity, ta = air temperature, tdb = dry bulb temperature, tf = floor temperature, tg = globe temperature, tmr = mean radiant temperature, to = mean outdoor temperature, top = operative temperature, tr = radiant temperature, tw = temperature of walls, twb = wet‐bulb temperature, va = air velocity.
Lighting performance indicators: Cc = contrast ((object luminance/ambient luminance)/object luminance), CCT = correlated colour temperature, CRI = colour rendering index, CT = colour temperature, DF = daylight factors, DFC = daylight factor contour, Eamb = ambient illuminance (illuminance), Ec = cylindrical illuminance, Ehor = horizontal illuminance, Ever = vertical illuminance, Lc = average ceiling luminance, Lf = luminous Flux (lm), LogCh = chloropic lux, LogCy = cyanopic lux, LogEr = erythropic lux, LogMe = melanopic lux, LogPh = photopic lux, LogRh = rhodopic lux, Lw = average wall luminance, SPD = spectral power distribution.
Acoustic performance indicators: BGN = background noise or ambient noise, CyD = Cicle dose as a total quantity of complete oscillatory periods performed by the vocal folds in a set time, F0 = fundamental frequency, Pho = the relative time spent in phonation compared with the elapsed time monitored expressed in a percentage, RT = reverberation time, SPL = sound pressure level.
Indoor air quality performance indicators: AC = allergen concentration, ACH = air exchange rate, Cl2 = chlorine, CO = carbon monoxide, CO2 = carbon dioxide, CO2o = carbon dioxide outside, D = dust, Fl = flow, HCHO = formaldehyde, NO2 = nitrogen dioxide, O3 = ozone, Pa = partical pressure of water vapour in ambiant air, PM10 = particles <10 µm, PM2.5 = particles <2.5 µm, PSV = personal supply ventilation, SD = settled dust, SO2 = sulphur dioxide, TSP = total respirable suspended particulate matter, TVOC = total volatile organic compounds, VB = viable bacteria, VM = viable mouts.
“=” behind performance indicator means that condition was kept constant.