Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 12;2021:6618581. doi: 10.1155/2021/6618581

Table 2.

Methodological quality of included studies by using the McMaster critical appraisal form.

Number Study design Level Items Score
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
1 CCT III-2 x n/a x 12/14
2 CCT III-2 x n/a x 12/14
3 CCT III-2 x n/a 13/14
4 CCT III-2 x n/a x 12/14
5 CCT III-2 x n/a x 12/14
6 CCT III-2 x x n/a 12/14
7 CCT III-2 x n/a x 12/14
8 CCT III-2 x n/a x 12/14

Level of evidence (based on NHMRC hierarchy); CCT: control clinical trial; FU/RCT: follow-up study from randomized control trial. √: yes; x: no/not reported; n/a: not applicable. McMaster Items: (1) study purpose clearly stated; (2) background literature reviewed; (3) appropriate research design; (4) sample described in detail; (5) sample size justified; (6) outcome measure reliability reported; (7) outcome measure validity reported; (8) intervention described; (9) contamination avoided; (10) cointervention avoided; (11) results reported in terms of statistical significance; (12) appropriate analysis method; (13) clinical significance reported; (14) dropouts reported; (15) appropriate conclusion.