Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 8;14(3):768–779. doi: 10.1093/ckj/sfaa156

Table 1.

Measurement tools to assess physical function [ 26, 28, 55]

Characteristics Physiological impairment Functional limitations Functional disability/self-reported physical functioning
Objective/ subjective Objective Objective Subjective
Examples Exercise tolerance/capacity tests, cardiopulmonary exercise testing and muscular fitness; maximum strength and muscle endurance Physical performance tests such as walk tests and functional muscular fitness tests Self- and/or proxy reports, questionnaires such as SF-36, RAND-36, PROMIS-29 and KDQoL
Basis Lab-/hospital-based Mainly lab-/hospital-based Day-to-day life
Advantages
  • Gold standard

  • Easy to quantify

  • Less suspect of floor/ceiling effects

  • More useful in comparisons between cultures and geographical environments

  • Objectively measured

  • Easy to quantify

  • More useful in comparisons between cultures and geographical environments

  • Relatively simple, quick and cost-effective

  • Applicable to large number of individuals

  • Tests represent normal daily activities (walking and sit-to-stand transition)

  • Patient-focused information

  • Reflects one’s perception of their abilities in their environment

  • Applicable to large number of individuals

  • Easy, cost effective, time efficient and risk free

Disadvantages
  • May have limited practical utility

  • Requires trained personnel

  • Floor effect for cardiorespiratory tests

  • No gold standard

  • Potentially suspect of ceiling effects

  • Subject to external influences

  • Self-reported and therefore lower validity and reliability

Requirements Trained personnel, expensive equipment and specific analytic skills/knowledge Familiarization and adherence to protocols Literacy and ability to understand the language
Practical considerations Reliant on technical experts Lower feasibility Less easy to interpret and translate to real-world situation (e.g. walking distance improvement, 1 SPPB point increase) Choosing the outcome of the self-reported tool necessary to answer the clinical or research question

KDQoL: Kidney Disease Quality of Life.