Table 3.
Study | Publication Year | Design | Setting | N with Migraine | Age, Mean±SD | Time from Last Menstruation (Months) | Intervention | Outcome | Follow-Up (Months) | Main Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nappi et al16 | 2006 | Randomized trial | Headache clinic | 40 | 52.4±1.3 (treated with tibolone) 52.8±1.4 (treated with estrogen-progestogen) |
≥12 | Tibolone vs estrogen-progestogen | 1) Change in number of headache days compared with baseline 2) Change in number of hours of severe headache (during which pain intensity prohibited daily activities) compared with baseline 3) Change in number of analgesics compared with baseline |
6 | 1) Tibolone did not increase while estrogen-progestogen increased headache days 2) Tibolone decreased headache intensity, while estrogen-progestogen did not 3) Tibolone decreased while estrogen-progestogen increased analgesic consumption |
Misakian et al15 | 2003 | Cross-sectional (baseline data of a randomized controlled trial) | General population (healthcare professionals) | 1909 | 55.2±6.2 | NR | Any hormonal treatment | Association (OR) between hormonal treatments and migraine | NA | - Current hormonal treatments were associated with an OR for migraine headache of 1.42 (95% CI 1.24–1.62) after multiple adjustments - Any dose and type of treatment was associated with migraine |
Aegidius et al17 | 2007 | Population-based study | General population | 801 | NR | ≥12 | Any (subgroup analyses for local and systemic use) | Migraine prevalence | NA | - Previous use: OR 1.2, 95% CI 0.9–1.6 - Current local use: OR 1.3, 95% CI 0.9–1.7 - Current systemic use: OR 1.6, 95% Ci 1.4–1.9 |
Facchinetti et al14 | 2002 | Observational prospective study | Gynecology clinic | 38 | 51.1±1.9 | 10.4±4.4 | 3 regimens of treatment: A) estradiol hemihydrate 1 mg/day plus norethisterone 0.5 mg/day for 28 days in a continuous combined scheme; B) oral conjugated estrogens 0.625 mg/day for 28days plus medroxyprogesterone acetate 10 mg/day in the last 14 days in a sequential continuous scheme; C) estradiol valerate 2 mg/day for 21 days plus cyproterone acetate 1 mg/day from day 12 to 21 in a sequential cyclical scheme |
1) Frequency (number of attacks per month) 2) Days with headache (number of days with headache per month) 3) Severity (score of 0 to 3, ranging from absent to severe headache) 4) Duration of attacks 5) Analgesic use (number of analgesics per month) 6) Greene scale for climacteric symptoms 7) Zung scale for anxiety and depression |
3; 6 | 1) Increased for every treatment 2) Increased for every treatment (with smaller increase in group A compared with groups B and C) 3) Increased only in groups B and C and stable in group A 4) Decreased in groups A and B but remained stable in group C 5) Increased for every treatment (with smaller increase in group A compared with groups B and C) 6) Decreased for every treatment 7) Decreased for every treatment |
Glaser et al19 | 2012 | Prospective pilot study | Oncology clinic | 11 | 55.5±8.7 | NR | Testosterone pellet subcutaneous implants | Headache severity on a 5-point rating scale | 3 | Mean headache severity decreased from 3.5±0.59 to 0 |
Rustichelli et al23 | 2020 | Cross-sectional | Gynecology clinic | 30 (menstrual migraine) 30 (postmenopausal migraine) | 33.5±7.1 (menstrual migraine) 56.6±4.5 (postmenopausal migraine) | ≥12 | Measurement of serum allopregnanolone, progesterone, and testosterone | Hormone levels in menopausal migraineurs compared with postmenopausal controls and with menstrual migraineurs | NA | - Allopregnanolone levels significantly lower in postmenopausal migraineurs compared with postmenopausal controls (25±13 pg/mL vs 80±17 pg/mL; P<0.001); progesterone, testosterone, and allopregnanolone levels similar between postmenopausal migraineurs and postmenopausal controls - All hormones had lower levels in postmenopausal migraineurs compared with menstrual migraineurs |
Abbreviations: NA, not applicable; NR, not reported.