Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 9;14(2):168–173. doi: 10.1007/s12178-021-09698-4

Table 1.

Outcomes of ulnar collateral ligament repair in published studies

Year Author # of repairs Surgical technique Suture augment Gender Mean age Primary sport Level of competition Outcomes
2019 Dugas et al. [35••] 111 Repair suture and suture tape augment secured with anchors Yes—collagen dipped

Male

Female

18.3

Baseball

Football

softball

Javelin

High school (67%), college (28%), recreational (4%), professional (1%), junior high (1%)

102/111 (92%)—returned to previous/higher level of play

Average time to return: 6.7 months

2008 Savoie et al. [31] 60

Suture/anchor

bone tunnels

No

Male

Female

17.2

Baseball

Basketball

Cheerleading

College (37%), high school (42%), junior high (21%)

56/60 (93%)—returned to previous/higher level of play

Average time to return: 6 months (4–11.7 months)

2006 Argo et al. [11] 18

10—repair/suture anchor

6—repair/plication

1—repair/muscle augmentation

1—bone tunnel

No Female 22

Softball

Gymnastics

Tennis

College (47%), high school (26%), recreational (21%), nonathlete (5%)

17/18 (94%)—returned to previous/higher level of play

Average time to return: 2.5 months (2–3.5 months)

2000 Azar et al. [33] 13 Did not specify No Male 21.6

Baseball

Football

Tennis

Wrestling

Professional, collegiate, high school

(percentages not specified)

5/8 (63%)—returned to previous/higher level of play

(5 lost to follow-up)

1992 Conway et al. [10] 14

10—repair/plication

4—bone tunnels

No Male 26.5 Baseball Professional (71%), collegiate (29%) 7/14 (50%)—returned to previous level of play
1981 Norwood et al. [9] 4

3—repair/plication

1—bone tunnel

No Male

Softball

Soccer

Recreational (50%), nonathlete (50%)

4/4 (100%)—returned to previous level of play

2/4—nondominant arm

1/4—returned to throwing

1/4—returned to soccer