Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 5;16(1):1–9. doi: 10.5114/wiitm.2020.100678

Table I.

Characteristics of included studies

References Year Country Study design Tumor size [cm]a Age [years]a Lesion type Sample size NOS
Total 3D 2D
Yamanaka et al. 2007 Japan RCS NA NA ML 226 113 113 7
Pianka et al. 2011 Germany RCS 9.5 ±3.6/
10.4 ±3.8
50 ±10.6/
48 ±10.0
ML 26 13 13 7
Fang et al. 2013 China RCS NA 50.6 ±11.5/
53.5 ±12.6
BL 98 56 42 9
Begin et al. 2014 Canada RCS NA 61.6 ±12.9/
64.8 ±16.8
ML 72 36 36 7
Fang et al. 2015 China RCS 7.6 ±2.8/
7.4 ±2.6
47.5 ±13.8/
46.5 ±13.3
ML 116 60 56 8
He et al. 2015 China RCS NA 41.4 ±13.1/
42.5 ±13.2
BL 106 59 47 9
Wei et al. 2015 China RCS 9.5 ±3.6/
10.4 ±3.8
50 ±10.6/
48 ±10.0
ML 74 31 43 8
Su et al. 2016 China RCS NA NA ML 26 16 10 8
Zhang et al. 2019 China RCS NA 55.7 ±11.2/
52.5 ±12.1
ML 64 30 34 9
a

Experimental group/control group.

ML – malignant lesions, BL – benign lesions, NOS – Newcastle-Ottawa Scale, NA – not available.