Table 1. Variables extracted from papers.
Author (year) | Year | Aim | Application type | Target Population | Education level | Domain | Outcome measure |
Nicholson et al. (32) | 2006 | Evaluating the effectiveness of the 3-dimensional anatomy model |
3-dimensional VR |
60 medical students | First-year medical students | Anatomical ear model | The results of the three-dimensional model evaluation in this study were positive and could enhance the learning of medical students. |
Solyar et al. (33) | 2008 | Evaluation of sinus surgery simulator | Endoscopic sinus surgery simulator | 15 medical student | First-year | Nasal | The results of the study showed that the use of the simulator as a nasal and paranasal sinus anatomy learning tool is helpful. |
Petersson et al. (20) | 2009 | Evaluation of the 3-dimensional method | Virtual reality | 137 medical student | Second and fifth-semester medical student | Anatomy | The results of the study show the positive effect of using virtual reality in learning anatomy. |
Seixas-Mikelus et al. (34) | 2010 | Evaluating the use of virtual reality robotic surgical simulator | Virtual reality robotic surgical simulator | 10 medical students and residents | --- | Surgical anatomy | Virtual reality robotic surgical simulator has been reported as an effective tool for enhancing the ability to learn surgical anatomy. |
Fang et al. (9) | 2014 | Evaluation of 3-dimensional, haptic, virtual reality simulator to teach temporal bone | 3-dimensional, haptic, virtual reality temporal bone simulator | 7 otolaryngology residents and 7 medical students |
Fifth-year of postgraduate & (MD) fifth through the seventh year |
Temporal bone | The results of the study indicated that the simulation technology would increase confidence level, efficiency and reduce educational errors. |
Küçük et al. (10) | 2016 | Assessing the effectiveness of learning anatomy with mobile augmented reality (mAR) | Augmented reality | 70 medical students | Second-year undergraduate | Neuroanatomy | The success of the students using the mAR applications for learning anatomy was more than the control group and because of flexibility, it has a positive impact on learning. |
Author (year) | Year | Aim | Application type | Target Population | Education level | Domain | Outcome measure |
Ma et al. (21) | 2016 | Develop an augmented reality system to education | Augmented reality | 72 students and 7 clinicians | Anatomy student and first-year and final year undergraduate medical students | Human anatomy | The use of the augmented reality interactive system has been reported useful for anatomy education. |
Moro et al. (12) | 2017 | Evaluating the effectiveness of using VR & AR compared to tablet-based apps for learning anatomy | VR & AR and 3D tablet | 50 Biomedical, health sciences, 5medical student and 4 other faculties | ---- | Skull anatomy | The results of this study revealed virtual reality and augmented reality as an effective learning tool for teaching anatomy content. |
Rochlen et al. (22) | 2017 | The usability and feasibility assessment of augmented reality to teach needle placement | Augmented Reality | 40 medical students and anesthesiology residents | Third and fourth-year | Internal anatomy | Results of this study indicated augmented reality has been helpful in teaching internal anatomy. |
Stepan et al. (13) | 2017 | Evaluating the effectiveness of virtual reality in teaching neuroanatomy | Virtual reality simulation | 66 medical students | First-year and 2nd year | Neuroanatomy. | Students' experience of virtual reality was positive in the field of neuroanatomy and increased their motivation for learning. |
Kugelmann et al. (11) | 2018 | Evaluation of augmented reality magic mirror system for teaching anatomy | Augmented reality magic mirror system | 880 medical students | First-year | Human anatomy | Students in this study referred to the positive impact and potential of using augmented reality. |
Maresky et al. (35) | 2018 | The effectiveness of VR for the education of cardiac anatomy | virtual reality | Forty-two undergraduate medical students | First-year medical students | Cardiac anatomy | The results of the study showed that virtual reality technology is considered as an effective tool for training anatomy of the heart. |