Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 23;18(6):3310. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18063310

Table 1.

Original studies on sacral neuromodulation. PCOS—Polycystic Ovary Syndrome, CRDs—complex repetitive discharges, DBs—decelerating bursts, EUS—external urethral sphincter, TRUS—transrectal ultrasonography, SNM—sacral neuromodulation, FS—Fowler’s syndrome, PAG—periaqueductal grey, DRS—dorsal root stimulation, INUR—idiopathic nonobstructive urinary retention, TNS—tibial nerve stimulation, PNS—pudendal nerve stimulation.

Author Type of Study Aim Primary Outcome
Fowler et al., 1988 Cross-sectional To reveal the cause of unexplained urinary retention in young women Abnormal electromyographic activity of the external urethral sphincter in women with urinary retention associated with PCOS
Fowler et al., 1985 Observational To elucidate the electromyotonic activity of the external urethral sphincter in women with urinary retention Complex repetitive discharges and decelerating bursts, ephaptic spread of excitation between muscle fibers
Tawadros et al., 2015 Cross-sectional To investigate the presence of CRDs and DBs in the EUS during the menstrual cycle in females with no urinary symptoms CRDs and DBs in the EUS are present in 53% of asymptomatic women, more commonly in the luteal phase of the cycle
Ramm et al., 2012 Cross-sectional To compare the proportion of women with CRDs among females with and without urinary disorders CRDs detected in 30% of asymptomatic women
Noble et al., 1995 Cross-sectional TRUS assessments of the EUS volume in women with obstructed voiding and abnormal electromyography (EMG) activity and in asymptomatic women The volume of the EUS in the control group was significantly lower than in the obstructed group
Andrich et al., 2005 Cross-sectional Morphological description of the urethral rhabdosphincter in women with and without urinary retention No difference in rhabdosphincter fiber diameter was found in women with urinary retention and control
DasGupta, Fowler 2004 Cross-sectional SNM in restoring voiding function in women with urinary retention SNM has no direct relaxant effect on the sphincter
Kavia et al., 2010 Etiology (case series) To examine brain responses to bladder filling in women with FS treated with SNM Overactive urethra inhibits afferent signals blocking bladder afferent activity at the sacral level, deactivates the periaqueductal grey (PAG) and higher center, causing a loss of bladder sensation. SNM blocks inhibition by urethral afferents at the sacral level
DasGupta et al., 2005 Etiology (cross-sectional) To investigate how SNM acts on brain centers involved in bladder function in women with FS and control Enhanced limbic cortical activity with no significant activity in the brainstem was detected while bladder fulness was present in women with FS. SNM restores the midbrain activity and decreases cortical activity in this group
Karmarkar et al., 2015 Case–control study To assess the prevalence of gynecological pathologies in women with FS Statistically significant relationship between FS and endometriosis (p = 0.003), and FS and PCOS (p = 0.003), was found
Panicker et al.,2012 Observation from Prospective Clinical Study To identify the impact of opiates on urinary retention in women Exogenous opiates may compound any functional abnormalities predisposing women to urinary retention
Li et al., 2018 Animal study To test the hypothesis that DRS blocks pudendal afferent inhibition of the micturition reflex DRS blocks pudendal afferent inhibition and restores bladder capacity to control level
Swinn et al., 2000 Case–control study To evaluate the efficacy of SNM in the treatment of FS Success rate 68%
Reoperation rate 21%
Mehmood et al., 2017 Retrospective study To determine the safety and efficacy of SNM in the treatment of INUR Improvement rate 83.3%
Reoperation rate 41.6%
Li et al., 2020 Animal study To determine the effects of TNS on reflex bladder activity Repeated application of TNS produced long-lasting bladder underactivity
Mohapatra et al., 2021 Animal study To determine the effects of PNS on reflex bladder activity Repeated application of PNS resulted in long-lasting bladder underactivity