Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 31;7:13. doi: 10.1038/s41526-021-00141-z

Table 2.

Outline of experimental platforms, cell types, durations, and results in the literature of macrophage microgravity research.

Experiment platform Paper Cell type Time in µg Results
Clinorotation (simulated µg) Shi 2020 Primary mouse 12 d Macrophage differentiation from hematopoietic progenitor cells and functional polarization impaired in µg; RAS/ERK/NFκB pathway gravisensitive
Wang 2015 Primary mouse 24 h Simulated µg activates p38 MAPK-C/EBPβ pathway; increased arginase expression; upregulated IL-6, downregulated IL-12B
Brungs 2015 NR8383 4 h Reduced ROS production in µg; diminished Syk phosphorylation; NFκB nuclear translocation unaltered
Paulsen 2015 BV-2 microglial cells; U937; Primary human 1 d; 3 d; 5 d Reduced ICAM-1 expression in BV-2 cells; increased ICAM-1 expression in U937 and primary human macrophages
Wang 2014 RAW 264.7; Primary mouse 24 h LPS-induced TNF-α expression in µg reduced, but not IL-1β; increased HSF-1 in µg; nuclear translocation of NFκB unchanged
Adrian 2013 NR8383 30–180 m ROS release is reduced in µg, responding rapidly and reversibly
Paulsen 2010 U937 5 m Non-stimulated macrophages had enhanced tyrosine phosphorylation and c-jun activation; PMA-stimulated macrophages had reduced tyrosine phosphorylation and c-jun activation
Maier 2006 U937 24 h; 72 h Upregulation of hsp70; inhibited proliferation; altered cytokine secretion in µg
Hsieh 2005 RAW 264.7 2 d Reduction in nitric oxide and cytokine production; flavonoids compensated for loss of macrophage function in 3D culture
Maccarrone 2003 U937 2–72 h No expression of active 5-LOX or apoptosis, in contrast to lymphocytes
Hashemi 1999 Primary human 24 h Normal IL-1 synthesis
Random position machine (simulated µg) Meloni 2006 J-111 1 h; 24 h Cell motility severely reduced in µg; actin, tubulin, and vinculin structures affected
Limb suspension (simulated µg) Liu 2015 Primary rat 28 d µg increased monocyte recruitment, E-selectin and MCP-1 expression, and NFκB activation in abdominal aorta
Suborbital/sounding rocket (real µg) Thiel 2019 Primary Human 353 s µg induces cell geometry changes, rapid cytoskeleton reorganization, and rapid adaptation of the cytoskeleton
Vogel 2019 U937 300 s HIF-1 differently regulated in altered gravity; some genes have rapid response and adaptation, others altered only after 5 min. in µg
Thiel 2018 U937 300 s Transcriptome greatly altered in µg; 99.43% of all initially altered transcripts adapted after 5 min.
Paulsen 2015 U937 378 s No detectable effect on ICAM-1 mRNA expression
Parabolic flight (real µg) Vogel 2019 U937 20 s HIF-1 differently regulated in altered gravity; some genes have rapid response and adaptation, others altered only after 5 min. in µg
Thiel 2018 U937 20 s Transcriptome greatly altered in µg; 99.43% of all initially altered transcripts adapted after 5 min.
Paulsen 2015 BV-2 microglial cells; U937; Primary human 20 s Rapid, reversible downregulation of ICAM-1 in BV-2 cells; upregulation of ICAM-1 in differentiated U937 cells; Primary human inconclusive
Adrian 2013 NR8383 22 s ROS release is reduced in µg, responding rapidly and reversibly
Paulsen 2010 U937 20 s 1.3-fold increased MEK phosphorylation; rapid p53 phosphorylation in non-stimulated U937 cells
Armstrong 1995 B6MP102 20 s Macrophages respond to µg within 8 s, with increased cell spreading
Spaceflight (real µg) Shi 2020 Primary mouse 12 d Macrophage differentiation from hematopoietic progenitor cells and functional polarization impaired in µg; RAS/ERK/NFκB pathway gravisensitive
Tauber 2017 Primary human 11 d; 30 d Decreased ICAM-1 and surface-bound fucose; CD18 and CD14 surface expression unaltered
Thiel 2017 NR8383 15 m Immediate oxidative burst inhibition followed by extremely rapid adaptation to µg
Paulsen 2015 U937 5 d Upregulation of ICAM-1 in differentiated U937 cells
Paulsen 2014 U937 5 d Disturbed actin, disorganized tubulin, and reduced CD18, CD36, MHC-II expression in µg
Crucian 2011 Primary human (blood sample) 13–16 d Inflammatory phenotype and cytokine production impacted by spaceflight; LPS-stimulated cells showed reduced IL-6, TNF-α, IL-10, and increased IL-1b in µg
Meloni 2011 J-111 24 h Severe reduction in motility attributed to disruption of cytoskeleton; actin, tubulin, vinculin distribution affected
Baqai 2009 Primary mouse (spleen sample) 13 d Spaceflight can increase anti-inflammatory mechanisms; altered response to LPS stimulation; reduced monocyte/macrophage count; upregulated ROS genes post-flight
Kaur 2005 Primary human (blood sample) 5–11 d Monocytes had reduced phagocytic ability, oxidative burst, and degranulation after spaceflight
Hatton 1999 U937 9 d Kinetics of protein kinase C are modified during spaceflight.
Chapes 1999 Primary rat (peritoneal sample) 10 d Enhanced secretion of TNF, IL-6, and nitric oxide
Hashemi 1999 Primary human 22 h; 25 h Normal IL-1 synthesis
Armstrong 1995 B6MP102 6–8 d Increased macrophage proliferation; reduced IL-6 secretion; reduced differentiation
Chapes 1992 B6MP102 6 d; 9 d Greater secretion of IL-1 and TNF of LPS-stimulated macrophages in µg

µg microgravity, s second, m minute, h hour, d day.