Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 19;8:628848. doi: 10.3389/fsurg.2021.628848

Table 4.

Description of exercise prehabilitation intervention arms according to consensus exercise reporting template (CERT) domains (20) for three of the RCTs that included multimodal prehabilitation interventions as an example.

CERT domain Item no. and abbreviated item description 2020 Carli (8) 2018 Barberan-Garcia (34) 2018 Minnella (30)
What 1. Type of exercise equipment Recumbent stepper Resistance bands Cycle-ergometer stationary bicycle Resistance bands
Who 2. Qualifications, teaching/supervising expertise and/or training of the exercise instructor Kinesiologist Specialised Physiotherapist Physician prescribed; Kinesiologist demonstrated
How 3. Whether exercise are performed individually or in a group Not specified Individually Individual
4. Whether exercises are supervised or unsupervised Supervised and home based Supervised Unsupervised
5. Measurement and reporting of adherence to exercise Attendance at the in-hospital exercise session. Self-reported in diary and weekly telephone calls Attendance at exercise sessions Self-reported logbookWeekly telephone calls with kinesiologist
6. Details of motivation strategies CD with audio instructions. Weekly telephone calls Motivational Interviewing and objective setting prior to exercise program and revisited throughout program Weekly telephone calls with kinesiologist
7. Decision rules for progressing the exercise program No details in paper—references Bousquet-Dion 2018 for reporting of intervention Peak work rate increased by ~5% every week up to a maximum of 85% peak work rate and 50% peak work rate for active rest. Not reported
8. Each exercise is described so that it can be replicated (e.g., illustrations, photographs) No details in paper—references Bousquet-Dion 2018 for reporting of intervention Detailed description provided Aerobic described in terms of time, type, intensity (RPE), resistance less described
9. Content of any home program component Personalised progression of mod aerobic−30 min walking and resistance training x3/week Personalised walking program focusing on increasing steps per day (using pedometer) and optimisation of walking intensity (using BORG scale) All home based
10. Non exercised components Nutrition intervention +/– protein supplementation, psychology assessment, and personalised coping strategies, counselling for smoking and alcohol cessation. Motivational interview Nutrition assessment and supplements as needed.
11. How adverse events that occur during exercise are documented and managed No adverse events No adverse events reported No adverse events reported
Where 12. Setting in which exercises are performed Hospital prehabilitation unit and home based Community Home based
When, how much 13. Detailed description of the exercises (e.g., set, reps, ration, intensity) 1 supervised session per week for 4 weeks. Warm up: 5 minAerobic: 30 min moderate intensity Resistance: 25 min, Stretching: 5 min 1–3 sessions per week Duration: 47 min Warm up: 5 min 30% peak work rate Intervals: 2 min 70%peak work rate, 3 min active rest 40% peak work rate Cool Down: 5 min 20% peak work rate Cycling Rate: 60-70RPM Aerobic-−3 per week of 30 min moderate continuous training (incl 5 min warm up, 5 min cool down)BORG 12–13Strengthening 1 per week of 30 min (incl 5 min flexibility and 5 min stretching)–−3 sets x8-12 reps of 8 muscle groups.
Tailoring 14. Whether exercises are generic (“one size fits all”) or tailored to the individual Personalised Patient specific program Individualised
15. Decision rule that determines the starting level of exercise No detail in paper—references Bousquet-Dion 2018 for reporting intervention. Cardiopulmonary Exercise Test Based on personal level and attitude. Based on BORG or 10 point resistance intensity scale.
How well 15. Whether the exercise intervention is delivered and performed as planned Attendance of hospital sessions—mean (SD) 68% (38). Overall adherence 80% (27) Nil reported Overall compliance with programme reported (63%)

CERT tables for all included studies can be found in Supplementary 1.

RPM, revolutions per minute; HR-max, maximum heart rate.