Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 21;17(4):934–942. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2020.1805991

Table 1.

Characteristics of the studies (N = 568)

    N %
Type of vaccine    
  Bivalent 131 23.1
  Quadrivalent 175 30.8
  Nonavalent 23 4.0
Objective    
  Vaccination/Vaccine 250 44.0
  Vaccination Schedule 49 8.6
  Vaccination Policy 34 6.0
  Cost 38 6.7
  Intervention to increase HPV vaccine coverage 63 11.1
  Efficacy 264 46.5
  Safety 176 31.0
  Patient knowledge, opinion and attitude 173 30.5
  Healthcare professional knowledge, opinion and attitude 37 6.5
  Vaccine intention 48 8.5
Method    
  Case study/case series 38 6.7
  Cross sectional study 111 19.5
  Ecological study 7 1.2
  Cohort study 57 10.0
  Case-control study 2 0.4
  Non-controlled study 18 3.2
  Comparative trial 197 34.7
  Medico economic study 32 5.7
  Qualitative study 11 1.9
  Systematic review 53 9.3
  Quantitative meta-analysis 26 4.6
  Mathematical modeling 9 1.6
  Unspecified method 7 1.2
Sex    
  Male 85 15.0
  Female 388 68.3
Profile    
  Healthcare Professional 34 6.0
  Parents 59 10.4
  School/University 43 7.6
  Specific sub-populations# 55 9.7
Number of authors    
  1–2 Authors 31 5.5
  3–6 Authors 251 44.2
  7–12 Authors 184 32.4
  13–24 Authors 74 13.0
  >24 Authors 28 5.1
Impact factor    
  [0–2] 91 16.0
  [2–5] 319 56.2
  [5–10] 64 11.3
  10–30 29 5.1
  ≥ 30 17 3
  Without Impact factor 43 7.6
  Undetermined Impact factor (date of publication: 2019) 5 0.9
Geographic origin    
  Africa 13 2.3
  North America 274 48.2
  South America 26 4.6
  Asia 72 12.9
  Europe 158 28.0
  Oceania 25 4.4
Funding    
  None 45 7.9
  Public sector only 141 24.8
  Private sector only 219 38.6
  Shared (private and public) 59 10.4
  Unspecified 93 16.4
  Missing data 11 1.9
Disclosure of interest    
  No conflicts 179 31.5
  Conflicts 276 48.6
  Unspecified 101 17.8
  Missing data 12 2.1

#Specific sub-population: HIV+ person, men who have sex with men, pregnant women, patients with auto-immune disease