Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 8;8(7):2004092. doi: 10.1002/advs.202004092

Table 2.

Performance comparison in terms of PCE and bending durability (test conditions and result) of our PSC with previously reported ITO‐free flexible PSCs

Cyclic Flex Test Ref.
Year Electrode Type Electrode Architecture PCE [%] Bending Radius [mm] Bending cycles PCEfinal/PCEinitial [%]
2020 CNT SWNT‐embedded PI 15.2 0.5 10 000 100 This work
2015 CNT PET/SWNT/HNO3 5.38 10 N/A 85.5 [ 30 ]
2017 CNT PEN/SWNT/MoO3 11 4 2,000 90 [ 20 ]
2020 Graphene PET/EG‐Graphene 12.6 9 1,000 92.2 [ 56 ]
2018 Graphene PDMS/Graphene 15 4 1,000 <80 [ 57 ]
2018 Graphene PDMS/Graphene 18.2 4 5,000 43 [ 58 ]
2018 Graphene PDMS/TFSA‐Graphene 17.5 4 5,000 ≈35 [ 58 ]
2018 Graphene, CNT Graphene, CSCNTs 11.9 4 2,000 84 [ 59 ]
2018 Graphene PET/Graphene 13.94 4 1,000 ≈92 [ 59 ]
2017 Graphene PET/APTES/Graphene 17.9 4 100 >90 [ 59 ]
2016 Graphene PEN/Graphene/MoO3 16.8 2 5,000 85 [ 39 ]
2019 PEDOT:PSS PEDOT:PSS 19 3 5,000 ≈80 [ 39 ]
2019 PEDOT:PSS PEDOT:PSS 17.03 0.5 10,000 100 [ 12 ]
2019 PEDOT:PSS PEDOT:PSS 20.25 2 5,000 97 [ 60 ]
2015 PEDOT:PSS PEDOT:PSS 10.83 1 1,000 0.9 [ 61 ]
2019 AgNW AgNW/PEDOT:PSS 15.06 5 1,000 80 [ 62 ]
2017 AgNW a‐AZO/AgNW/AZO 11.23 12.5 400 94 [ 63 ]
2016 Metal grid Ag grid/PET 14 5 5,000 95.4 [ 64 ]
2020 Metal grid PI/Cu grid/Graphene 16.4 5 10,000 97 [ 65 ]
2019 Oxide/Metal/Oxide TiO2/Ag/TiO2 13.00 1 1,000 97.6 [ 18 ]
2019 Oxide/Metal/Oxide TiO2/Ag/TiO2 13.19 <1 (single folding) 50 85.3 [ 16 ]
<1 (dual folding) 10 67.2