Skip to main content
. 2017 Aug 19;19(8):813–823. doi: 10.1111/jch.13049

Table 3.

Criteria for methodological quality used to select studies for detailed critical appraisal

Study design Study quality criteria for inclusion
Randomized controlled trials
  • Included at least one group of participants with reduced sodium intake and one group with higher sodium intake (control group)

  • Category III and IV outcomes ≥4 wk in duration; Category I, II, and V ≥1 y in duration

  • ≥2.3 g/day difference of salt intake (920 mg sodium, 40 mmol) between intervention and control group

  • Measured sodium intake using 24‐h urine collection

  • The intervention group did not have concomitant interventions (ie, antihypertensive drugs or other dietary interventions) so that the only difference between the intervention and control groups must have been sodium intake

Cohort studies
  • Prospective

  • Dietary sodium or sodium excretion alone as the primary exposure variable

  • Included ≥400 patients (continuous outcomes) or events (dichotomous outcomes)

  • Category III outcomes ≥4 wk in duration; category I, II, and V ≥1 y in duration

  • Measured sodium intake for at least 24 h using 24‐h urine collection, food record, 24‐h food recall, or a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire