Table.
Author, Year | Clearly Stated Study Question? |
Clearly Described Eligibility/
Selection Criteria for Study Population? |
Were Participants Representative of the Clinical Population of Interest? | Were all Eligible Participants that Met the Prespecified Entry Criteria Enrolled? | Was the Sample Size Sufficiently Large? |
Was the Intervention Clearly Described and
Delivered Consistently Across the Study Population? |
Were the Outcomes Measures Prespecified, Clearly
Defined, Valid, Reliable, and Assessed Consistently? |
Were the People Assessing the Outcomes Blinded to the
Participants’ Exposures/Interventions? |
Was the Loss to Follow-up after Baseline 20% of Less? | Did Statistical Methods Examine Changes in Outcome Measures from before to after Intervention? Did they Provide p-values? | Were Outcome Measures of Interest Taken Multiple Times before the Intervention and Multiple Times after the Intervention? |
If the Intervention was Conducted at Group Level, did Statistical Analysis Take into Account the Use of Individual-level Data to Determine Effect at Group Level?
Assigned? |
Overall Quality |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kogel et al., 1995 [76] | + | + | + | NR | - | + | + | - | + | +/- | + | N/A | POOR |
N/A: not applicable, for study designs where the question could not be applied; NR: not reported; +: yes; -: no.