Table 1.
Sir Bradford Hill criteria and their application to SDB and preeclampsia [17••, 26••, 27, 54••, 73, 74••, 75–78]
Pros | Cons | |
---|---|---|
Strength | Two-three-fold increased risk | |
Consistency | Association across study designs and populations | |
Specificity | Some markers associated with OSA but not snoring | Minimal data |
Temporality | SDB at 6–15 weeks associated with later development of PEC | Unclear if SDB preceded biological changes associated with PEC and not just clinical changes since PEC is usually determined in early pregnancy |
Biological gradient | Severity of SDB associated with higher risk of PEC | |
Biological plausibility | Explained by shared mechanisms and placental involvement | |
Coherence | Minimal laboratory-based data exist | |
Experiment | Recent experimental data of gestational intermittent hypoxia demonstrate changes in mechanistic pathways linked to PEC | |
Analogy | High altitude model of chronic hypoxia | Mechanisms for chronic vs. intermittent hypoxia may be different |
Reversibility | Data mainly on hemodynamic improvement- ongoing trials pending |
PEC: preeclampsia; SDB: sleep disordered breathing; OSA: obstructive sleep apnea