Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 13;18(1):81–99. doi: 10.1515/jib-2019-0097

Table 4:

Sensitivity, TP, FN, FP and TN values for ELM, TLBO-ELM, Jaya-ELM and CJaya-ELM.

HN ELM TLBO-ELM Jaya-ELM CJaya-ELM
Sen TP FN FP TN Sen TP FN FP TN Sen TP FN FP TN Sen TP FN FP TN
10 0.8727 144 21 20 45 0.9515 157 8 20 48 0.9576 158 7 23 42 0.9578 159 7 23 41
20 0.8688 139 21 13 57 0.9500 152 8 13 60 0.9563 153 7 16 54 0.9563 153 7 16 54
30 0.8766 135 19 18 58 0.9610 148 6 18 61 0.9675 149 5 21 55 0.9677 150 5 21 54
40 0.8896 137 17 23 53 0.9740 150 4 23 56 0.9805 151 3 26 50 0.9805 151 3 26 50
50 0.8841 145 19 14 52 0.9634 158 6 14 55 0.9695 159 5 17 49 0.9697 160 5 17 48
60 0.8827 143 19 22 46 0.9630 156 6 22 49 0.9691 157 5 25 43 0.9691 157 5 25 43
70 0.8792 131 18 23 58 0.9664 144 5 23 61 0.9732 145 4 26 55 0.9733 146 4 26 54
80 0.8563 143 24 20 43 0.9341 156 11 20 46 0.9401 157 10 23 40 0.9401 157 10 23 40
90 0.8627 132 21 18 59 0.9477 145 8 18 62 0.9542 146 7 21 56 0.9545 147 7 21 55
100 0.8408 132 25 20 53 0.9236 145 12 20 56 0.9299 146 11 23 50 0.9299 146 11 23 50
110 0.9108 143 14 24 49 0.9936 156 1 24 52 1 157 0 27 46 1 158 0 27 45
120 0.9000 135 15 24 56 0.9867 148 2 24 59 0.9933 149 1 27 53 0.9933 149 1 27 53
130 0.8735 145 21 14 50 0.9518 158 8 14 53 0.9578 159 7 17 47 0.9581 160 7 17 46
140 0.8247 127 27 29 47 0.9091 140 14 29 50 0.9156 141 13 32 44 0.9156 141 13 32 44
150 0.8683 145 22 17 46 0.9461 158 9 17 49 0.9521 159 8 20 43 0.9524 160 8 20 42
160 0.8909 147 18 13 52 0.9697 160 5 13 55 0.9758 161 4 16 49 0.9758 161 4 16 49
170 0.8466 138 25 18 49 0.9264 151 12 18 52 0.9325 152 11 21 46 0.9329 153 11 21 45
180 0.7901 128 34 24 44 0.8704 141 21 24 47 0.8765 142 20 27 41 0.8765 142 20 27 41
190 0.8333 135 27 17 51 0.9136 148 14 17 54 0.9198 149 13 20 48 0.9202 150 13 20 47
200 0.8726 137 20 22 51 0.9554 150 7 22 54 0.9618 151 6 25 48 0.9618 151 6 25 48
210 0.8269 129 27 24 50 0.9103 142 14 24 53 0.9167 143 13 27 47 0.9172 144 13 27 46
220 0.8258 128 27 14 61 0.9097 141 14 14 64 0.9161 142 13 17 58 0.9161 142 13 17 58
230 0.8494 141 25 16 48 0.9277 154 12 16 51 0.9337 155 11 19 45 0.9341 156 11 10 53
240 0.8431 129 24 27 50 0.9281 142 11 27 53 0.9346 143 10 30 47 0.9346 143 10 20 57
250 0.7888 127 34 13 56 0.8696 140 21 13 59 0.8758 141 20 16 53 0.8765 142 20 6 58
260 0.8385 135 26 17 52 0.9193 148 13 17 55 0.9255 149 12 20 49 0.9255 149 12 10 59
270 0.8553 136 23 15 56 0.9371 149 10 15 59 0.9434 150 9 18 53 0.9437 151 9 6 64
280 0.8113 129 30 18 53 0.8931 142 17 18 56 0.8994 143 16 21 50 0.8994 143 16 4 67
290 0.8182 135 30 23 42 0.8970 148 17 23 45 0.9030 149 16 26 39 0.9036 150 16 2 62
300 0.8187 131 29 13 57 0.9000 144 16 13 60 0.9063 145 15 16 54 0.9063 145 15 6 64

Bold values are the highest values.