Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 13;18(1):81–99. doi: 10.1515/jib-2019-0097

Table 5:

Specificity, Gmean, F-score values for ELM, TLBO-ELM, Jaya-ELM and CJaya-ELM.

HN ELM TLBO-ELM Jaya-ELM CJaya-ELM
Spe Gmean F-score Spe Gmean F-score Spe Gmean F-score Spe Gmean F-score
10 0.6923 0.7773 0.7721 0.7385 0.8462 0.8384 0.6462 0.7866 0.7716 0.6406 0.7833 0.7678
20 0.8141 0.8411 0.8406 0.8571 0.9112 0.9095 0.7714 0.8589 0.8540 0.7714 0.8589 0.8540
30 0.7632 0.8179 0.8160 0.8026 0.8871 0.8827 0.7237 0.8368 0.8280 0.7200 0.8347 0.8257
40 0.6974 0.7876 0.7818 0.7368 0.8556 0.8461 0.6579 0.8032 0.7874 0.6579 0.8032 0.7874
50 0.7879 0.8346 0.8332 0.8333 0.9045 0.9015 0.7424 0.8484 0.8409 0.7385 0.8462 0.8384
60 0.6765 0.7727 0.660 0.7206 0.8410 0.8310 0.6324 0.7828 0.7653 0.6324 0.7828 0.7653
70 0.7160 0.7934 0.7893 0.7531 0.8620 0.8542 0.6790 0.8129 0.7999 0.6750 0.8106 0.7972
80 0.6825 0.7645 0.7596 0.7302 0.8338 0.8265 0.6349 0.7726 0.7580 0.6349 0.7726 0.7580
90 0.7662 0.8131 0.8116 0.8052 0.8825 0.8788 0.7273 0.8331 0.8254 0.7237 0.8311 0.8232
100 0.7260 0.7813 0.7792 0.7671 0.8504 0.8459 0.6849 0.7981 0.7888 0.6849 0.7981 0.7888
110 0.6712 0.7819 0.7729 0.7123 0.8494 0.8364 0.6301 0.7938 0.7731 0.6250 0.7906 0.7692
120 0.7000 0.7937 0.7875 0.7375 0.8616 0.8513 0.8625 0.8112 0.7949 0.6625 0.8112 0.7949
130 0.7813 0.8261 0.8248 0.8281 0.8962 0.8934 0.7344 0.8387 0.8313 0.7302 0.8364 0.8287
140 0.6184 0.7141 0.7068 0.6579 0.7816 0.7701 0.5789 0.7281 0.7094 0.5789 0.7281 0.7094
150 0.7302 0.7962 0.7932 0.7778 0.8659 0.8610 0.6825 0.8061 0.9151 0.6774 0.8032 0.7917
160 0.8000 0.8442 0.8430 0.8462 0.9143 0.9115 0.7538 0.8577 0.8506 0.7538 0.8577 0.8506
170 0.7313 0.7869 0.7848 0.7761 0.8563 0.8522 0.6866 0.8001 0.7909 0.6818 0.7976 0.7878
180 0.6471 0.7150 0.7115 0.6912 0.7838 0.7777 0.6029 0.7270 0.7144 0.6029 0.7270 0.7144
190 0.7500 0.7906 0.7895 0.7941 0.8603 0.8576 0.7059 0.8058 0.7987 0.7015 0.8035 0.7961
200 0.6986 0.7808 0.7760 0.7397 0.8490 0.8410 0.6575 0.7952 0.7811 0.6575 0.7952 0.7811
210 0.6757 0.7475 0.7437 0.7162 0.8159 0.8090 0.6351 0.7630 0.7504 0.6301 0.7602 0.7470
220 0.8133 0.8195 0.8195 0.8533 0.8904 0.8896 0.7733 0.8417 0.8387 0.7733 0.8417 0.8387
230 0.7500 0.7982 0.7966 0.7969 0.8681 0.8650 0.7031 0.8103 0.8022 0.8413 0.8865 0.8853
240 0.6494 0.7399 0.7337 0.6883 0.8077 0.7974 0.6104 0.7553 0.7385 0.7403 0.8318 0.8262
250 0.8116 0.8001 0.8000 0.8551 0.8715 0.8713 0.7681 0.8202 0.8184 0.9063 0.8913 0.8911
260 0.7536 0.7949 0.7938 0.7971 0.8646 0.8618 0.7101 0.8107 0.8036 0.8551 0.8896 0.8889
270 0.7887 0.8214 0.8207 0.8310 0.8913 0.8891 0.7465 0.8392 0.8335 0.9143 0.9289 0.9288
280 0.7465 0.7782 0.7776 0.7887 0.8481 0.8459 0.7042 0.7958 0.7899 0.9437 0.9213 0.9210
290 0.6462 0.7271 0.7221 0.6923 0.7960 0.7883 0.6000 0.7361 0.7210 0.9688 0.9356 0.9350
300 0.8143 0.8165 0.8165 0.8571 0.8874 0.8869 0.7714 0.8361 0.8334 0.9143 0.9103 0.9103

Bold values are the highest values.