Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 30;13(7):1105. doi: 10.3390/polym13071105

Table 1.

Comprehensive analysis of naturally occurring and synthetic biopolymers along with their advantages and disadvantages.

Polymer Structure Desirable Properties and
Advantages
Disadvantages Ref
Natural polymer-, Polypeptide-, and Protein-based scaffolds Collagen
Inline graphic
  • Triple helical structure held together by hydrogen bonds.

  • Major amino acid

groups include:
Glycine
Proline
Hydroxyproline
  • Favorable for cell adhesion, proliferation, differentiation, and ECM secretion.

  • Excellent biocompatibility.

  • Biodegradability.

  • Low toxicity.

  • Rough surface morphology.

  • Low immunogenicity.

  • Weak antigenicity.

  • Low mechanical strength.

  • Difficult disinfection.

  • The deformation and contraction of collagen-based scaffolds have restricted their use in load-bearing tissues.

  • Poor stability in an aqueous environment.

  • Potential for antigenicity through telopeptides.

[52,124,125]
Silk fibroin
Inline graphic
  • Consists of short amino acid side chains that assemble into β-sheet structures.

  • SFs are sturdy, lightweight, and have exceptional strength and elasticity.

  • Osteoconductivity.

  • Biocompatible.

  • Deliver good support for cell adhesion and proliferation without initiating cell toxicity.

  • Promote cell migration and vascularization.

  • Moderately degradable.

  • Thermostable (up to ∼250 °C).

  • Commonly employed as a cell carrier for cell seeding on scaffolds.

  • Prolonged presence of silk may induce degradation, which releases certain residues or degraded products that may prompt the immune response.

[64,126,127]
Fibrinogen and fibrin
Inline graphic
  • Fibrinogen:

  • Dimer consisting of three pairs of polypeptide chains (Aα, Bβ, and γ)

  • Biocompatibility.

  • High affinity for biological surfaces and molecules.

  • Promotes cellular interactions.

  • Variety of cell-adhesive/binding properties.

  • Nonimmunogenicity.

  • Low mechanical strength.

  • Quick rate of degradation.

[67,128,129,130]
Gelatin
Inline graphic
  • Contains glycine residues, proline, and 4-hydroxyproline

residues
  • Better infiltration, adhesion, spreading, and proliferation of cells on resulting scaffolds.

  • Good stability at high temperature in a broad range of pH.

  • Biodegradability.

  • Osteoconductivity.

  • Non-immunogenic.

  • Low antigenicity.

  • Bioactivity is questionable in higher-order gelatin structures in scaffolds.

  • Low stability in physiological conditions.

[60,131,132]
Keratin
  • It is a cysteine-rich fibrous protein that associates with intermediate filaments (IFs) forming the bulk of the cytoskeleton and epidermal appendageal structures

  • Facilitates cell adhesion and proliferation.

  • Unique chemistry afforded by high sulfur content.

  • Propensity for self-assembly.

  • Intrinsic cellular recognition.

  • Intrinsic biological activity.

  • Cytocompatibility.

  • Gradual degradation.

  • Poor mechanical properties.

  • Quick loss of mechanical integrity.

[133,134]
Polysaccharide-based scaffolds Starch
Inline graphic
  • Comprised of carbohydrates.

  • The structure consists of two types of alpha glucan which are amylose and amylopectin.

  • Biocompatible.

  • Thermoplastic behavior.

  • Non-cytotoxic.

  • Guides various developmental stages of cells.

  • Hydrophilicity.

  • Good substrate for cell adhesion.

  • Good biodegradation period.

  • Very high water uptake.

  • Low mechanical strength.

  • Unstable for long-term application.

  • Chemical modifications may lead to toxic byproducts and reduce the rate of degradation.

[135,136]
Chitin/chitosan
Inline graphic
  • Chitin:

  • N-acetyl glucosamine and N-glucosamine monomers

  • Chitosan:

  • N-deacetylated derivative of chitin

  • Accelerates tissue repair.

  • Prevents formation of scar tissue.

  • Promotes cell adhesion.

  • Non-toxic and non-allergenic.

  • Bioactivity.

  • Anti-inflammatory.

  • Osteoconductivity.

  • Hemostatic potential.

  • Scaffolds could be used for a longer period.

  • Chitosan-based scaffolds can immobilize growth factors.

  • Poor mechanical strength and stability.

  • High viscosity and low solubility at neutral pH.

  • Rapid in vivo degradation rate.

[75,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144,145,146,147,148,149]
Agarose
Inline graphic
  • Contains repeating units of agarobiose (a disaccharide of D-galactose and 3,6-anhydro-l-galactopyranose).

  • Excellent biocompatibility.

  • Thermo-reversible gelation behavior.

  • Exceptional electroresponsiveness.

  • Suitable medium for cell encapsulation.

  • Non-immunogenic.

  • Low cell adhesion.

  • Nondegradability due to the absence of an appropriate enzyme in the body.

[140,141,142]
Alginate
Inline graphic
  • Made up of mannuronate and gluronate monomers.

  • Different block configurations give rise to different materials properties.

  • Mainly made up of carboxyl groups.

  • Mimicking function of the extracellular matrix of body tissue.

  • Thickening/gel-forming agent.

  • Biocompatibility.

  • Cytocompatibility.

  • Biodegradability.

  • Bioabsorbable.

  • Hydrophilicity.

  • Difficult to sterilize.

  • Low cell adhesion.

  • Poor mechanical characteristics.

[143,144,145]
Cellulose
Inline graphic
  • Polysaccharides are formed by many D-glucose units connected by glycosidic bonds.

  • Stable matrix for tissue engineering applications.

  • Better mechanical strength.

  • Hydrophilicity.

  • Biocompatibility.

  • Cytocompatibility.

  • Bioactivity.

  • Cellulose in the human organism behaves as a nondegradable or very slowly degradable material.

[146,147,148]
Hyaluronic acid
Inline graphic
  • It is a linear, anionic, non-sulfated glycosaminoglycan with a structure composed of repeating disaccharides units:

  • β-1,4-D-glucuronic acid and β-1,3-N-acetyl-D-glucosamide.

  • Encapsulation capability.

  • Cell activity.

  • HA scaffolds are frequently used in the case of both hard and soft tissue regeneration.

  • Nonimmunogenic.

  • Nonantigenic.

  • Biocompatibility.

  • Osteocompatibility.

  • Brittle; mechanical properties need fine-tuning via chemical modification.

  • Low biodegradability in the crystalline phase.

[81,149,150,151]
Glycosaminoglycans
Inline graphic
  • Consist of repeating disaccharides linked by glycosidic bonds creating individual complex structures.

  • Biocompatibility.

  • Anticoagulant activity.

  • Antithrombotic activity.

  • Anti-inflammatory.

  • Have multiple regulatory functions, e.g., in the anticoagulation of blood, inhibition of tumor growth, and metastasis.

  • Control the inflammatory processes.

  • Very fast degradation.

  • Potential risk of contamination with infectious agents.

[152,153]
Synthetic polymers Poly(ƹ-caprolactone) (PCL)
Inline graphic
  • Aliphatic semicrystalline polyester.

  • Controls cell proliferation and angiogenesis.

  • Slow degradation rate (lower than that of PLA and PLGA).

  • Non-toxic.

  • Cytocompatibility.

  • Good mechanical properties.

  • Degraded by hydrolysis or bulk erosion.

  • Low bioactivity.

  • Hydrophobicity of PCL is another major issue that hinders wound healing application.

  • Some problems related to withstanding mechanical loads.

[154,155,156]
Polylactic acid (PLA)
Inline graphic
  • Highly crystalline.

  • Biocompatible.

  • Cytocompatibility.

  • Thermal stability.

  • Excellent mechanical strength.

  • Good degradation rate.

  • Nontoxic degradation products.

  • PLA-based materials suffer from the lack of ideal surface chemistry that could aid cell adhesion and proliferation.

  • Brittleness.

  • Poor thermal stability.

  • Hydrophobicity.

[92,157,158]
Polylactic-co-glycolic acid (PLGA)
Inline graphic
  • The copolymer of hydrophobic PLA and hydrophilic PGA.

  • Excellent cell adhesion and proliferation.

  • Good mechanical properties.

  • Features faster degradation than either PGA or PLA.

  • Wide range of degradation rates.

  • Poor osteoconductivity.

  • May develop biocompatibility problems.

[159]
Polyglycolic acid (PGA)
Inline graphic
  • Linear highly crystalline aliphatic polyester.

  • Biocompatible.

  • High tensile modulus.

  • High melting point.

  • Undergoes bulk degradation.

  • Hydrophilicity.

  • High sensitivity to hydrolysis.

  • Difficult to obtain porous PGA scaffolds without toxic solvents.

[160,161]
Polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB)
Inline graphic
  • It is a homopolymer having a stereoregular structure with high crystallinity.

  • Naturally occurring b-hydroxy acid.

  • Non-toxic.

  • Biostable.

  • Biocompatible.

  • Advantages over PLA and PGA.

  • Slow rate of degradation.

  • Can be obtained naturally.

  • Inherent brittleness and rigidity.

  • Thermal instability during melt processing impedes its commercial application.

[159,162,163]
Polypropylene fumarate (PPF)
Inline graphic
  • Linear and unsaturated copolyester based on fumaric acid.

  • Biocompatibility.

  • Crosslinked PPF matrices have high mechanical strength.

  • PPF degrades in the presence of water into propylene glycol and fumaric acid, the degradation products that are easily cleared from the human body by normal metabolic processes.

  • Non-toxic.

  • It is a viscous liquid at room temperature (21 °C), making the handling of the polymer somewhat cumbersome

[159,164,165]
Poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)
Inline graphic
  • Synthesized using ring-opening polymerization of ethylene oxide.

  • Non-ionic.

  • Biocompatible.

  • Elasticity.

  • Bioadhesive.

  • Mucoadhesive.

  • Hinders protein adsorption.

  • Hydrophilic.

  • PEG as a blank template can be modified to different moieties to pass different requirements of a skin substitute like cell adhesion, short-term degradation, and minimum inflammation.

  • Non-immunogenic.

  • Lacks cell-interactive character due to

its bio-inert nature.
  • Nonreactive, creates insoluble networks.

[123,166,167]
Polyurethane (PU)
Inline graphic
  • Urethane groups are the major repeating units.

  • Synthesized by reactions of di- or polyisocyanates (hard segments) with di- or polyols (soft segments) via the catalyzed polymerization process.

  • Bio- and hemocompatibility.

  • Nontoxic.

  • Biodegradable.

  • Non-allergenic.

  • Non-sensitizing.

  • Excellent mechanical properties.

  • High flexural endurance and fatigue resistance.

  • PUs are less compatible with blood and found unsuitable for in vivo drug delivery application.

  • Limited stability in vivo.

[113,168]
Polyvinyl alcohol (PVA)
Inline graphic
  • Semicrystalline polyhydroxy polymer.

  • Prepared via hydrolysis of poly(vinyl acetate).

  • Biocompatible.

  • Nontoxic.

  • Noncarcinogenic.

  • Displays a reduced protein-binding tendency, relatively higher elasticity and water content; a highly hydrated water-soluble synthetic polymer.

  • Has relatively similar tensile strength to human articular cartilages.

  • Good lubrication.

  • Lack of cell-adhesive property.

  • Less ingrowth of bone cells.

[169,170,171]
Polypropylene carbonate (PPC)
Inline graphic
  • Product of alternating copolymerization of propylene oxide and CO2.

  • Amorphous.

  • Biodegradable amorphous polymer because of the aliphatic polycarbonate ester structure on its backbone.

  • No inflammatory response.

  • Thermoplastic behavior.

  • Biocompatibility.

  • Impact resistance.

  • PPC has shortcomings such as viscous

flow at room temperature and a relatively large brittleness at low temperature.
  • Poor thermal and processing properties.

  • Cell attachment to PPC is very limited due to its highly hydrophobic nature.

[172,173,174]