Table 1.
The proportion of additionally detected infections by ultrasensitive molecular methods is associated with transmission intensity
Reference | Setting | N | Plasmodium falciparum prevalence by detection method, % | Ratio | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Microscopy/RDT | Standard PCR* | usPCR* | ||||
LOD 50–200 p/µL | LOD: 0.1–10 p/µL | LOD: 0.002–0.2 p/µL | ||||
Awandu et al.2 | South Africa | 1,475 | 0 | 0 | 3.9 | N/A |
Gruenberg et al.9 | Brazil | 651 | – | 0.80 | 1.7 | --: 1: 2.1 |
Gruenberg et al.9 | Thailand | 773 | – | 1.3 | 1.9 | --: 1: 1.5 |
Gruenberg et al.9 | Papua New Guinea | 828 | – | 8.6 | 12.2 | --: 1: 1.4 |
Girma et al.1 | Gambella region, Ethiopia | 562 | 2.0† | 13‡ | 21.5 | 0.15: 1: 1.7 |
Hofmann et al.11 | Madang Province, Papua New Guinea | 300 | 8.1 | 29 | 33 | 0.28: 1: 1.1 |
53 (high-volume) | ||||||
This work | Bagamoyo, Tanzania | 319 | 17† | 32 | 37 | 0.53: 1: 1.2 |
Hofmann et al.10 | Rufiji, Tanzania | 498 | 25 | 50 | 58 | 0.50: 1: 1.2 |
RDT = rapid diagnostic tests. Standard PCRs all targeted 18s rRNA, either as a nested PCR (Awandu), (Gambella) or a real-time qPCR [Gruenberg], [Hofmann], this work.
Ultrasensitive PCR methods differed by study: (Awandu) TARE-2 qPCR, (Gruenberg) varATS, (Girma) 18s rRNA qRT-PCR, [Hofmann 2018] varATS, this work: 18s rRNA qRT-PCR (usPCR), (Hofmann et al.10) TARE-2/varATS qPCR.
Average of prevalence values reported for microscopy and RDT.
Estimated based on a sub-study of 48 of the usPCR-positive samples.12