Table 2. Comparison of the proposed model with other related studies.
Researchers | Methods | Dataset (own or publicly available) | Camera to capture data | Number of observation | Learning rate | Number of iteration | Performance (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Zhou et al. (2019) | FCM-KM and Faster R-CNN fusion | Rice field of the Hunan Rice Research Institute, China | Canon EOS R (pixel: 2,400 * 1,600) | 3,010 | 0.001 | 15,000 | Rice blast: 96.71 Bacterial blight: 97.53 Blight: 98.26 |
Sethy et al. (2020) | Faster R-CNN | Farm field | Smartphone camera (48 Megapixel) | 50 | 0.001 | 5 | Initial steps to make a prototype for automatic detection of RFS Rice false smut |
Phadikar, Sil & Das (2012) | Bayes’ and SVM Classifier | Rice field images of East Midnapur, India | Nikon COOLPIX P4 digital camera | 1,000 | – | – | Normal leaf image: 92 Brown spot image: 96.4 Blast image: 84 Bayes’ classifier: 79.5 SVM: 68.1 |
Ramesh & Vydeki (2020) | Optimized Deep Neural Network with Jaya Optimization Algorithm (DNN_JOA) | Farm field | High resolution digital camera | 650 | – | – | Rice blast: 98.9 Bacterial blight: 95.78 Sheath rot: 92 Brown spot: 94 Normal leaf: 90.57 |
Li et al. (2020) | Faster-RCNN | Rice field in Anhui, Jiangxi and Hunan Province, China | Mobile phone camera (iPhone7 & HUAWEI P10) and Sony DSC-QX10 camera | 5,320 | 0.002 | 50,000 | Rice sheath blight: 90.9 Rice stem borer: 71.4 Rice brown spot: 90 |
Prajapati, Shah & Dabhi (2017) | SVM | Farm field | NIKON D90 digital SLR (12.3 megapixels) | 120 | – | – | For SVM: 93.33 (training) 73.33 (testing) 5-fold cross-validation: 83.80 10-fold cross-validation: 88.57 |
Narendra Pal Singh Rathore (2020) | CNN | Kaggle dataset | – | 1,000 | – | – | Prediction accuracy: 99.61 (healthy and leaf blast) |
Rahman et al. (2020) | Simple CNN | Rice fields of Bangladesh Rice Research Institute (BRRI) | Four different types of camera | 1,426 | 0.0001 | 100 | Mean validation accuracy: 94.33 |
Proposed Model | Faster-RCNN | Both on field data and Kaggle dataset | Smartphone camera (Xiaomi Redmi 8) | 16,800 | 0.0002 | 50965 | Rice blast: 98.09 Brown spot:98.85 Hispa: 99.17 Healthy rice leaf: 99.25 |