Table 4.
Study | Sample | Climate | Intervention/Exposure | Duration | Thermal measurement | Methodological characteristics | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Part 1 | |||||||
Au et al. (2019) | 5 M, PA (T4-T11) 7 M, TP (C4-C7) 5 M, AB |
25°C 50% rh |
30′ arm cranking exercise @ 50% VO2peak | 10′ rest 2x 15′ 2′ rest between bouts |
Teso
Tint Tsk |
nRnCT cohort study | Teso/Tint in TP → , PA ↑ Teso/Tint no Δ between PA and AB Tsk upper limb → Tsk lower limb → |
Fitzgerald et al. (1990) | 5 F, PA 5 F, AB | 24–25°C 38–52% rh |
90′ WC ergometry 50–55% VO2peak | 30′ rest 90′ exercice |
Tor
Tsk |
nRnCT cohort study | Δ Tor ↑ in PA Δ Tsk ↑ in PA |
Gass et al. (1988) | 6 M, PA (T10-T12) | 22°C | 45′ WC treadmill with at 60-65% VO2max difference between Teso and Tre | 10′ rest 45′ exercise 10′ rest |
Teso
Tre |
nRnCT cohort study | Faster rise and higher Teso vs. Tre |
Griggs et al. (2015a) | 8 TP (C4-C7) 8 PA (T4-S1) |
20.6 ± 0.1°C 39.6 ± 0.8% rh |
55.5′ ISP 4 exercise blocks à 6 times (15′′ forward/ backward pushing, 15′′ sprint, 90′′ active recovery) 4.5′ in between passive recovery | 10′ WU55.5′ ISP15′ rest | Tc
Tsk ThS Fluid loss Performance |
nRnCT cohort study | Tc ↑ in TP than PA ΔTc ↑ in TP than PA Tc remained elevated in TP at rest ΔTsk ↑ in TP; TP ↑, PA ↓ ThS → Fluid loss → Performance → |
Griggs et al. (2017b) | 10 TP (C5-C7) 7 Non-SCI |
18.4–20.9°C 31.1–45.1% rh |
WC rugby game | 4x 8′ effective | Tc
Tsk ThS Fluid loss |
nRnCT cohort study | ΔTc ↑ TP ΔTsk ↑ TP ThS → Fluid loss ↑ TP |
Iturricastillo et al. (2016) | 6 SCI (C5-L3) 6 Non-SCI |
NA (in sports hall) | 16′ small sided games | 4x 4′ separated by 2′ rest | Ty | nRnCT cohort study | Ty→ |
Price and Campbell (1999a) | 7 PA (T3-L1) | 21.5 ± 1.3°C 54.2 ± 6.3% rh |
60′ arm cranking and WC ergometer at 60% VO2peak | 15′ rest 60′ exercise 30′ rest |
Tau
Tsk Fluid loss |
RCT cross-over | ΔTau → between arm cranking and wheelchair ergometer Tsk upper arm ↑ in arm cranking Fluid loss → |
Price and Campbell (1999b) | 9 PA (T3-L1) 1 TP (C6) 11 AB |
21.5 ± 1.7°C 49.0 ± 6.3% rh |
60 ′ arm cranking at 60% VO2peak | 15′ rest 5′ WU 60′ exercise 30′ recovery |
Tau
Tsk Fluid loss |
nRCT cohort study | ΔTau → AB and PA ΔTau ↑ in TP Tau ↑ during recovery in TP ΔTsk upper body → in all groups ΔTsk tight ↑ in AB Tsk calf ↓ in AB Fluid loss ↓ in TP |
Price and Campbell (1997) | 10 PA (T3-L4) 9 AB |
21.5 ± 1.7°C 47 ± 7.8% rh |
90′ arm cranking at 80% peak HR | 15′ rest 5′ WU 90′ exercise 20′ rest |
Tau
Tsk Fluid loss |
nRCT cohort study | ΔTau → AB and PA Tsk upper body ↑ PA, ↓ AB Tsk calf ↑PA ↓AB Fluid loss → |
Pritchett et al. (2015) | 7 PA 8 AB |
21 ± 1°C 55-65 ± 0.1% rh |
Incremental stage test 7′/stage; start 35 W, increment 35 W, till Tes rose more 0.2°C/min or 90 W | 7′ each stage 1′ in-between passive recovery Mean test duration 27′ 30′′ |
Teso
Tre Sweat gland density Sweat rate |
nRnCT cohort study | Active sweat gland density ↑ in AB vs. PA Sweat rate per gland → Teso → Tre→ |
Pritchett et al. (2011) | 7 PA 8 AB |
20 ± 1°C 45-65 ± 0.1% rh |
Incremental stage test 7′/stage; start 35 W, increment 35 W, till Tes rose more 0.2°C/min or 90 W | 7′ each stage 1′ in-between passive recovery |
Teso
Tre Tsk |
nRnCT cohort study | ΔTeso → AB and PA ΔTre → AB and PA Tsk ↑ PA |
Theisen et al. (2000) | 6 M, PA, (T5-T9) 6 M, PA, (T10-T12), 6 AB |
22.6 ± 1.7°C 45-65 ± 2.9% rh |
Incremental stage test: 3′/stage; start 15 W, increment 20 W, till exhaustion | 30‘rest 3‘stages |
Teso
Tsk |
nRCT | ΔTeso ↑ PA, at higher intensities only in PA (T10-T12) Tsk leg → in PA Tsk leg ↓ in AB |
M, male; F, female; AB, able-bodied; PA, paraplegia; TP, tetraplegia; SCI, spinal cord injured; C, cervical; T, thoracic; L, lumbar; WC, wheelchair; °C, degree Celsius; rh, relative humidity; WU, warm-up; Tre, rectal temperature; Teso, esophageal temperature; Tsk, skin temperature; Tint, intestinal temperature; Ty, tympanic temperature; Tau, aural temperature; ThS, thermal sensation; RCT, randomized controlled trial; nRnCT, non-randomized non-controlled trial; W, watt; Pmax, maximal power output; HR, heart rate; ↑ = higher; → = indifferent; ↓ = lower; Δ = difference; ISP, intermittent sprint protocol.