Table 6.
Study | Sample | Climate | Intervention/Exposure | Duration | Thermal measurement | Methodological characteristics | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Armstrong et al. (1995) | 6 PA (C6-T12) | 32.9 ± 0.1°C 75 ± 3% rh |
30′ WC on stationary roller @ self-selected 10 km pace (67-70% VO2 peak) DUR with headpiece or DUR with IV |
20-25′ rest in heat 30′ exercise |
Tre
Tau Tsk Sweat rate ThS |
RCT cross-over | No differences between tests in Tre, Tau, Tsk, sweat rate, ThS |
Bongers et al. (2016) | 10 M, PA (T4-T12) | 25.4 ± 0.4°C 41.0 ± 8.4% rh |
45′ arm cranking @ 50% peak power with DUR with IV |
10′ rest in heat 10′ WU 45′ test 5′ cool down 10′ rest in heat |
Tin
Tsk Fluid loss ThS |
RCT cross-over | Tin no between test differences Tsk mean ↓ with IV ThS ↓ with IV Fluid loss: no differences between tests |
Griggs et al. (2017a) | 1 F, TP 7 M, TP (C5-C7) |
20.2 ± 0.2°C 33.0 ± 3.1% rh |
4x 15′ intermittent sprint protocol 4x 15′ with different sprint bouts in 3 conditions No cooling PRE with IV (incl. during WU) PRE with IV and DUR with WS |
15′ rest 20′ WU 4x 15′ exercise with 2′/5′/2′ rest in between |
Tin
Tsk ThS Fluid loss |
RCT cross-over | ΔTin ↓ in PRE/DUR condition Tsk mean ↓ in PRE/DUR condition No differences between tests in ThS,fluid loss |
Hagobian et al. (2004) | 6 M, SCI (C5-T5) 6 M, AB |
31.8 ± 0.2°C 26 ± 1% rh |
45′ arm cranking @ 66 ± 5% VO2peak DUR with foot cooling |
30′ rest in heat 10′ rest in heat (baseline) 45′ exercise 30′ passive recovery |
Ty
Tsk |
RCT cross- over | ΔTy ↑ in non-cooling ΔTy ↑ in cooling compared to AB Tsk face ↑ in SCI Tsk back ↑ in SCI |
Pritchett et al. (2010) | 3 M, PA (T3-L1) 4 F, PA (T3-L1) |
22 ± 1°C 45-50 ± 0.1% rh |
Incremental stage test 7′/stage; start 30 W, increment 20 W, till Tes rose more 0.2°C/min or 90 W DUR with WS |
7′ each stage 1′ in-between passive recovery |
Teso
Tre Tsk ThS |
RCT cross-over | No differences between tests in in Tre, Tsk, ThS, Teso |
Trbovich (2019) | 1 TP 1 PA 1 AB |
75°F control 90°F hot |
30′ WC treadmill 5 different conditions: control, hot, hot with IV, hot with WS, hot with ice slurry |
10′ rest 30′ treadmill |
Tin | RCT cross-over | All three cooling interventions mitigated the rise in Tin in TP WS and ice slurry mitigated the rise in PA |
Trbovich et al. (2014) | 6 TP (C5-C7) 5 PA, (T3-T5) 6 PA, (T7-T12) 19 AB |
21.1–23.9°C | Playing WC basketball or rugby DUR with IV Without cooling |
20′ rest 60′ exercise |
Tin | RCT cross-over | Tin ↑ in TP than PA, AB No between test differences in Tin for any group or condition |
Trbovich et al. (2019) | 7 TP (C5-C7) 4 PA (T4–L1) 16 AB |
19-22°C 55-60% rh | 90′ intermittent sprint exercise under two conditions DUR with WS application every 15′ without cooling TP played WC rugby PP played WC basketball | 15′ WU 60-90′ WC basketball or rugby |
Tin | RCT cross-over | ΔTin ↑ in TP than PA, AB ΔTin ↓ in TP with WS |
Webborn et al. (2005) | 8 M, TP (C5-C7) | 32.0 ± 0.1°C 50.0 ± 0.1% rh |
14x 2′ intermittent sprint protocol arm cranking PRE with IV DUR with IV |
15′ rest in temperate 20′ IV or rest in thermal neutral 7′ WU 14x 2′ exercise |
Tin
Tsk ThS |
RCT cross-over | Tin ↑ without cooling ΔTin ↓ lower in DUR than other conditions Tsk ↓ with DUR than control ThS no differences between tests |
Webborn et al. (2010) | 8 M, TP (C5-C7) | 32.0 ± 0.1°C 50.0 ± 0.1% rh |
30x 2′ intermittent sprint protocol arm cranking PRE with IV DUR with IV |
15′ rest in thermal neutral 20′ IV or rest in thermal neutral 7′ WU Up to 30x 2′ exercise |
Tc
Tsk Performance |
RCT cross-over | Tin ↑ without cooling Tsk ↓ with DUR than control Performance ↑ with PRE than control Performance ↑ with DUR than PRE |
M, male; F, female; AB, able-bodied; PA, paraplegic; TP, tetraplegic; SCI, spinal cord injury; C, cervical; T, thoracic; L, lumbar; WC, wheelchair; °C, degree Celsius; °F, degree Fahrenheit; rh, relative humidity; WU, warm-up; Tre, rectal temperature; Teso, esophageal temperature; Tsk, skin temperature; Tint, intestinal temperature; Ty, tympanic temperature; Tau, aural temperature; ThS, thermal sensation; HR, heart rate; RCT, randomized controlled trial; nRnCT, non-randomized non-controlled trial; W, watt; Pmax = maximal power output; ↑ = higher; → = indifferent; ↓ = lower; DUR = cooling during exercise; PRE = cooling before exercise; IV = ice vest/cooling vest; WS = water spray.