Table 1.
Reference | Study design and intervention | Targeted cognitive domain(s) | Outcome | Sample | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Combined cognitive retraining and compensation strategies | Gehring et al, 200947 | RCT in lower-grade gliomas | Attention, executive functioning, learning, and memory | At 6 mo: improved attention, verbal memory, and mental fatigue | Total = 140 |
Intervention: 2 h weekly for 6 sessions including iPad app | Low-grade glioma = 117 | ||||
Control: wait-list | Anaplastic glioma = 23 | ||||
van der Linden et al, 201848 | Feasibility RCT in postoperative primary brain tumors | Attention, executive functioning, learning, and memory | Feasibility: 54% met feasibility criteria defined as ≥ 80% completion of retraining and compensation strategies | Total = 13 | |
Intervention: 3 h weekly for 10 sessions using iPad | Low-grade glioma = 4 | ||||
Control: wait-list | Meningioma = 7 | ||||
Other = 2 | |||||
Zucchella et al, 201349 | RCT in primary brain tumors postoperatively | Orientation, attention, memory, and executive functioning | At 1 mo: improved verbal memory, visual attention | Total = 53 | |
Intervention: 4 h weekly for 16 sessions | Low-grade glioma = 7 | ||||
Control: usual care without cognitive training | High-grade glioma = 25 | ||||
Meningioma = 16 | |||||
Other = 5 | |||||
Compensation strategies | Hassler et al, 201059 | Pilot study in glioblastomas and anaplastic gliomas | Perception, concentration, attention, verbal learning and memory, retentiveness, and creativity | At 12 wk: improved verbal learning | Total = 11 |
Intervention: 10 group sessions of 90 min of compensation (holistic mnemonic training) | Glioblastoma = 7 | ||||
Anaplastic glioma = 4 | |||||
Locke et al, 200860 | Primary brain tumors undergoing radiation with caregivers | Executive functioning, learning and memory | At 3 mo: 88% patients using strategies at least once per wk | Total = 13 | |
Intervention: 50 min daily for 6 sessions of cognitive rehabilitation and problem-solving therapy intervention | Glioma = 11 | ||||
Control: usual care without cognitive training | Meningioma = 2 | ||||
Miotto et al, 201361 | Pilot study in untreated primary frontal lobe tumors | Verbal learning and memory, working memory, executive functioning | At 30 min: improved verbal memory | Total = 21 | |
Intervention: 30 min of strategic semantic organizational training | Glioma = 12 | ||||
Meningioma = 9 | |||||
Miotto et al, 201462 | Pilot study in low-grade glioma of left frontal lobe | Verbal learning and memory | At 30 min: improved verbal memory | Total = 9 | |
Intervention: 30 min of strategic semantic organizational training | Low-grade glioma = 9 | ||||
Control: matched healthy volunteers | |||||
Richard et al, 201957 | Pilot RCT in brain tumors | Executive and related attention, memory, and behavioral impairments | At 4 mo: improved HRQOL, executive function, processing speed | Total = 25 | |
Intervention: 2 h weekly for 8 sessions (GMT or BHP) | Low-grade glioma = 8 | ||||
Control: wait-list | High-grade glioma = 6 | ||||
Meningioma = 7 | |||||
Other = 4 | |||||
Cognitive retraining | Maschio et al, 201546 | Pilot study in brain tumors | Memory, attention, visuospatial functions, language, and reasoning | Immediately and at 6 mo: improved attention, memory, and verbal fluency | Total = 16 |
Intervention: 1 h weekly retraining for 10 sessions | Low-grade glioma = 5 | ||||
Anaplastic glioma = 4 | |||||
Glioblastoma = 2 | |||||
Meningioma = 2 | |||||
Metastases = 3 | |||||
Yang et al, 201458 | RCT VR for retraining in brain tumors | Attention, learning, and memory | At 1 mo: improved attention, memory, and visual motor coordination, visual learning, and memory | Total = 38 | |
Intervention: 1.5 h weekly VR retraining and 1 h weekly computer-assisted cognitive rehabilitation for 4 wks | Astrocytoma = 2 | ||||
Control: 2.5 h weekly of computer-assisted cognitive rehabilitation for 4 wk | Glioblastoma = 5 | ||||
Meningioma = 10 | |||||
Metastasis = 6 | |||||
Other = 15 |
Abbreviations: BHP, Brain Health Program; GMT, Goal Management Training; HRQOL, health related quality of life; RCT, randomized controlled trial; VR, virtual reality.