Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 12;62(6):617–630. doi: 10.4103/psychiatry.IndianJPsychiatry_136_19

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies

Author Study location/community Objectives Study design/type Sample size, participants and methods Results
Banerjee et al., 1986[47] District of Nadia West Bengal
Santal
Rate and pattern of mental disorders Cross-sectional study 205 families in urbanized tribal community by the method of door-to-door survey Depression was common. Very low prevalence rate of Neurotic illness, epilepsy and mental retaliation. Married individuals were affected more than the unmarried ones. Males had a slightly higher rate to mental morbidity. The population showed a general tendency of greater vulnerability to mental illness with advancing age
Nandi et al., 1992[41] West Bengal Assess the change if any in the extent and pattern of mental morbidity in the urbanized group in comparison to the rural group of the same tribe Cross-sectional study Urban Santals (771) Urbanization had little effect on the total mental morbidity. But stress-dependent disorders were more common in the urban tribe
Santal Rural Santals (653)
Household survey
Ganguly et al., 1995[16] Western Rajasthan
Meena and other tribes
Understand the health issues related to the use of opium Qualitative Traditional opium users (200) from six villages, ethnographic information of opium use Majority of the addicts were between 40 and 60 years of age. Consumption starts with 10 g/day. Some were hard-core users who consumed around 100 g a day or 250-300 g
Aparajitaet al., 1996[36] Ganjam district, Orissa Assessing social support network and the satisfaction of the children’s needs belonging to high and low sociocultural status families Cross-sectional Disadvantaged group (300) and advantaged group (150) and equal number from both genders from the 8th, 9th, and 10th grades were taken as samples Children from advantaged socio-cultural environment were found to have health and enriching family climate, whereas children from socioculturally disadvantaged environment were deprived of getting necessary interpersonal and intra family support. In spite of getting negative support and responsibilities from their families, the need satisfaction rate was found to be more in disadvantaged children. Girls received more negative response from their family members than the boys. This paper confirmed the continuous positive social support in satisfying children’s needs in the Indian social system
Mixed Population Structured questionnaire (35 item questionnaire)
Chaturvedi et al., 2013[18] Changlang district, Arunachal Pradesh Assesses the types of substance use Cross-sectional Households (1092) respondents, age ≥10 years (5135) Prevalence of opium use was more among males. Usage was higher in higher altitudes
Tangsa, Singpho, Khamti, and Tutsa Structured pretested questionnaire
Prabhakar and Manoharan, 2005[32] Tamil Nadu
Malayali and Lambadi
Evaluate health system to examine the health status of the target population Cross-sectional Villages (21), respondents (2785), Examine the health system from the perspective of the base hospital Gender and age susceptibility patterns revealed specific age intervals for mental health disorders
Sushila et al., 2005[25] Southern Rajasthan Explore factors responsible for physical and mental discomfort; availability of health care facilities; preferred system to cure such problems Qualitative Households (156), Bhil, households of village Madri and tribal households from village Jamun Services of traditional healers are used by the people in all kind of physical and mental discomforts
Bhils The perceptions of illness, socio-cultural beliefs, and practices regarding illness
Mixed-methods study
Hackett et al., 2007[42] Wayanad, Kerala Examine association between CMD, anemia, malnutrition, and physical symptoms Cross-sectional Tribes (721) seeking treatment at Swami Vivekananda medical mission CMD was not associated with anemia, malnutrition and physical symptoms
NR Quantitative data collection by interview and estimation of hemoglobin from blood samples
Giri et al., 2007[40] Jharkhand Study the sociodemographic and clinical profile of cases through a retrospective case record analysis of tribal populations and compare it with nontribals Cross-sectional All the patients registered (1752) in the three community outreach centers (Jonha, Khunti, Saraikella-kharsawan) from November 2005 to April 2006 were included in the study About half of the cases from both groups are of age-group 20-39 years with gradual decline. Psychiatric morbidity among males was more than females in both tribals and nontribals. Patients with epilepsy were higher in tribal group. Tribals were more irregular with substantial number of dropouts
Mixed population of tribals and non tribals Sociodemographic profile and service utilization were recorded by reviewing the case records of the participants during that time
Sobhanjan and Mukhopadhyay, 2007[26] Sikkim Examine if perceived stress affects BP, lipids and obesity Cross-sectional Healthy volunteers (398) (age ≥20 years, urban males: 100; urban females (100); rural males (103) rural females (95) Urban Bhutias experienced perceived stress to a significantly higher extent (mean±SD of PSSI value: male: 0.48±0.06, female: 0.48±0.07) than that of rural Bhutias (male: 0.22±0.07, females: 0.20±0.05)
Bhutia Structured questionnaire
Chowdhury et al. 2008[37] Sundarban Delta
Not mentioned
Examine the extent and impact of human-animal conflicts vis-a-vis psychosocial stressors and mental health of the affected people Cross-sectional 3082 households (Satjelia, 1572, Lahiripur, 1512), were surveyed among the mixed population of tribals and nontribals
Survey, FGD, IDIs, and medical clinics
During the last 15 years, 111 persons (male 83, female 28) became victims of animal attacks, viz., tiger (82%), crocodile (10.8%), and shark (7.2%), of which 73.9% died. In 94.5% cases, the conflict took place in and around the SRF during livelihood activities. Tracking of 66 widows, resulted from these conflicts, showed that majority of them (51.%) were either disabled or in a very poor health condition, 40.9% were in extreme economic stress and only 10.6% remarried. 1 widow committed suicide and 3 attempted suicide. A total of 178 persons (male 82, female 96) attended the community mental health clinics.
Maximum cases were major depressive disorder (14.6%), followed by somatoform pain disorder (14.0%), posttraumatic stress disorder-animal attack related (9.6%), and adjustment disorder (9%). 11.2% cases had a history of deliberate self-harm attempt, of which 55% used pesticides
Tripathy et al. 2010[35] Jharkhand and Odisha Assess the effect of a participatory intervention with women’s groups on birth outcomes and maternal depression Cluster randomized controlled trial Intervention (2457) and control (2235). Women between the age group of 15 and 49 years NMR was 32% lower in intervention clusters adjusted for clustering, stratification and baseline differences during the 3 year period and 45% lower in 2 and 3 years. No significant effect on maternal depression was noted
Not mentioned Primary outcome was to see the reduction in neonatal mortality rate and maternal depression scores after implementation of strategies to address the above-mentioned problems in the intervention arm compared to the control arm
Mohindra et al., 2011[19] Waynad District, Kerala/ Understand the reasons, concerns, and consequences of consumption of alcohol Qualitative Households (393), age >15 years Paniyas reported consumption of alcohol as a problem and is increasing among younger men
Paniya FGDs and semi-structured interviews Reasons for consumption
Easily available, produced illicitly in some colonies, employers using this as a strategy to attract Paniyas to work. The other reasons are range of socioeconomic consequences that are rooted in historic oppression and social discrimination
Sreeraj et al., 2012[20] Ranchi, Jharkhand Examine the reasons for alcohol intake, belief about addiction, their effect on the severity of addiction in people with different ethnic background Cross-sectional Tribal (40) and nontribal (20) communities Patients from both the groups had a similar age of onset of substance intake, duration of intake in a dependence pattern, and duration of incubation from first intake to intake in dependence pattern. In spite of these similarities problems related to alcohol were more in tribals. Social enhancement, to cope with distressing emotions and peer pressure were some of the reasons for alcohol intake
NR Structured questionnaire through an interview
Yalsangi, 2012[34] Trivandrum, Kerala
Paniya
Kattunaicken
Bettakurumba
Mullukurumba
Irula
Assess the community health program run in a tribal area in Nilgiris Cross-sectional- Program Evaluation 218, ST with an age of ≥25 and more were selected. No upper limit. Mixed-methods study The intervention area had better awareness score (5.13±2.27) than that of control area (1.57±2.82)
Manimunda et al. 2012[23] The Andaman and Nicobar Islands Estimate the prevalence and determinants of tobacco use and nicotine dependency Cross-sectional 18,018, both ST and non-ST population with an age group of ≥14 years Prevalence of current tobacco use was 48.9%. Tobacco chewing alone was prevalent in 40.9% of the population. One-tenth (9%) of the males were nicotine dependent, while it was 3% in females. Three-fourths of the tobacco users initiated use of tobacco before reaching 21 years of age. Age, current use of alcohol, poor educational status, marital status, socioeconomic groups, and comorbidities were the main determinants of tobacco use and nicotine dependence
Nicobarese tribe, Ranchi tribes Structured questionnaire
FTND test was used to estimate nicotine dependence
Diwan, 2012[28] Ranchi, Jharkhand
Not mentioned
Examine the main and interaction effects of ethnicity, marital status, and stress on mental health of tribal school teachers Cross-sectional study 400, female school teachers of Ranchi town (160 tribal and 160 non tribal)
GHQ-12, Stress scale was used to collect the data
Out of the three factors namely stress, marital status, and ethnicity, only ethnicity was found to produce main effect on mental health. Neither second-order interaction nor third-order interaction was found to be significant
Diwan., 2012[46] Ranchi, Jharkhand Know the impact of gender, socio-economic status, and age upon the mental health of tribal factory workers Cross-sectional 400, tribal female workers from different factories Out of the three factors namely gender, socio economic status, and age, gender was found to produce main effect on mental health
Not mentioned Personal data schedule, GHQ-12
Singh et al., 2013[24] Roing and Anini districts, Arunachal Pradesh Evaluate psychological traits of Idu Mishmi tribes to validate earlier report of high suicide rates Cross-sectional, qualitative 218, unrelated school children aged 13-19 years, family members of unrelated individuals aged 19-85 years who had committed suicide Suicide attempt was higher in Idu Mishmi population (14.22%) than urban population (0.4%-4.2%). Females were at higher risk. Depression (8.26%) was comparable with earlier reports, whereas anxiety syndrome (6.42%), alcohol abuse (36.24%), and eating disorder such as binge eating (6.42%) and bulimia nervosa (1.38%) were also recorded in the population
Idu Mishmi Data collection done using mixed-methods approach
Chaturvedi et al., 2013[18] Arunachal Pradesh
Tangsa, Singpho, Khamti and Tutsa
Estimate prevalence of opium use among tribes, association between sociodemographic factors and opium use Cross-sectional Age >15 years (3421), participated in substance survey, secondary data were used which were collected in a previous survey which assessed the types of substance use Higher prevalence of opium use in men (10.6%) compared to women (2.1%). Opium use was significantly higher among Singpho and Khamti tribes. Variation seen according to age, educational level, occupation, marital status, and religion of the respondents
Raina et al., 2013[43] Bharmour, Himachal Pradesh Systematic methods for developing cognitive screening instrument for tribals Cross-sectional 50, 60-75+ age groups, trained sample randomly picked Modifications and testing of modified version of MMSE questionnaire resulted in an effective customized screening tool exclusive for Brahmouri population
Gaddi Different phases for development of MMSE questionnaire relevant for Bharmouri population
Longkumer et al., 2013[29] Nagaland Explore the existing knowledge and attitudes regarding mental disorders and see whether formal education has any relationship with their attitudes toward such disorders Cross-sectional Christian males (500) and (272) females in the age above 21 years A great majority recognized mental health problem in the case vignette but used general terms such as psychosocial problem/mental problem/mental illness. Majority attributed the problem to psychosocial problems and chose a psychiatrist/psychologist over other options. However, a considerable number of participants reported evil spirit possession as the cause of mental disorders and preferred seeking for divine intervention as a treatment mode
Nagas/Ao Naga Tribes A brief instruction, respondent’s personal identification chart, a case vignette and a questionnaire based on the vignette
Raina et al., 2014[44] Himachal Pradesh Know the prevalence of dementia and to generate a hypothesis on the differential distribution across populations Cross-sectional 2000, 60 years and above age, Two-phase study; screening and clinical phase No case of dementia reported in tribal population
Not mentioned Screening - urban, rural, and migrant populations using HMSE questionnaire
For tribal population modified version of MMSE was used
Clinical evaluation- involved a psychiatrist and public health expert
Nizamie et al., 2015[31] Jharkhand
NR
Develop an effective health-care delivery model for epilepsy to reduce treatment gap in a rural community Cross-sectional 114,068
6 health workers, traditional practitioners (267 faith healers and qualified practitioners, local practitioners)
Involved training, awareness campaigns, diagnosis, treatment delivery, follow-up, and free medication
213 patients enrolled in a study completed 12 months treatment leaving 75% seizure free. The model was successful
Nimgaonkar and Menon, 2015[33] Tamil Nadu
Bettakurumba, Mullukurumba and other ST
Improve the health-care delivery through task shifting Feasibility study 542, from 184 villages Low cost task shifting was successfully implemented. Patients were well treated and they volunteered to increase the acceptance
Ozer, 2015[39] Ladakh To assess how two groups of Ladakhi college students navigate through different degrees of exposure to acculturation and how this affects their mental health Mixed methods study (cross-sectional) 292 - quantitative and 12 - qualitative Students with less acculturation exposure were more oriented toward ethnic culture and to a greater extent experienced impaired mental health when compared with the sample with more acculturation. Most prevalent among the students (34.2%) was a bicultural orientation, integrating both ethnic and mainstream culture. In general, acculturation orientation was not associated with quantitative measures of depression or anxiety. The qualitative analysis revealed agency and cultural identity to be pivotal factors in the process of reproducing culture and negotiating cultural change
Mixed population Structured data collection and IDIs
Jeffrey GS et al., 2016[38] Central India Understand human displacement’s mental health toll as well as the displacement-related changes that help explain such emotional suffering Cross-sectional Heads of the households (159) from Mazira and Behruda villages Loss of homeland compromises mental health in all aspects
Sahariyas Ethnographic information and semi structured interview
Raina et al., 2016[45] Himachal Pradesh
Not mentioned
Explore the feasibility of using EASI as an alternative to HMSE and its modifications Cross-sectional 60 years and above age (2000). Secondary data analysis As the scores on EASI rise, the scores on HMSE fall both pointing to identification of the same clinical diagnosis, that is, dementia. EASI may be used as alternative to mental state examination
Lakhan et al., 2016[30] Chikalia, Madhya Pradesh Prevalence of Down’s syndrome in a tribal population and (2) its comorbidity with ID in tribal population ST mothers (2767) All mothers of all identified DS children were in young age (18-24 years) when they had babies with DS
Not mentioned Screening for ID (intellectual through a household survey). Identified cases evaluated by therapists in IDs for diagnosis
Janakiram et al., 2016[22] Tribal colonies in Kalapetta, Kerala Find out dependency of tobacco use in indigenous population of Waynad, India Cross-sectional 103, individuals above age of 15 years in four colonies of Kalapetta Prevalence of tobacco use in this population was 73.8%. Majority of them (92%) use smokeless forms of tobacco. The mean score for nicotine dependency was 3.85% for smoked tobacco and 4.61% was for smokeless tobacco which denote moderate dependency of tobacco use. Average age of onset of tobacco use was 16.41 years for smoked and 17.53 years for smokeless forms
Adivasis A structured questionnaire, modified and adapted from NIMHANS - the tobacco cessation questionnaire - was done
Ali et al., 2016[27] Ranchi, Jharkhand Find out the mental health status (emotional, hyperactivity, relationships and conduct problems and pro-social behavior’s) among school-going tribal adolescents Cross-sectional study Males (780) in the age range of 13-17 years going to school, belonging to tribal community Out of the total participants, 5.12% of the students had emotional symptoms, 9.61% had conduct problems, 4.23% had hyperactivity, and 1.41% had significant peer problems
Not mentioned Semi structured sociodemographic data and strengths and difficulties questionnaire to assess the emotional and behavioral disorders were collected
Maulik et al., 2017[14] Andhra Pradesh Understand the feasibility and acceptability of mental health service utilization in
Remote areas using mobile technology
Evaluation of the SMART Mental Health project in rural India
Cross-sectional Age >18 years (5007), participated in survey Training was imparted to 21 ASHAs and 2 primary care doctors. 5007 of 5167 eligible individuals were screened, and 238 were
Koya Development of mobile technology-based EDSS Identified as being positive for CMDs and referred to the primary care doctors for further management
Interactive voice response system
Stigma reduction campaign
Out of the screened positive, 2 (0.8%) had previously utilized mental health services. During the intervention period, 30 (12.6%) visited the primary care doctor for further diagnosis and treatment, as advised. There was a significant reduction in the depression and anxiety scores between start and end of the intervention among those who had screened positive at the beginning
Baseline household survey Stigma and mental health awareness in the broader community improved during the project
Intervention
Postintervention

CMD – Common mental disorder; BP – Blood pressure; SD – Standard deviation; PSSI – Permanent Shear Stability Index; SRF – Sundarbans reserve forest; IDIs – In-depth interviews; FGDs – Focus group discussions; FTND – Fagerström Test for Nicotine Dependence; GHQ – General Health Questionnaire; MMSE – Mini–Mental State Examination; HMSE – Hindi Mental State Examination; NR – Not reported; EASI – Everyday Abilities Scale for India; SMART – Systematic Medical Appraisal, Referral and Treatment; EDSS – Expanded Disability Status Scale; ASHA – Accredited social health activist; ST – Scheduled Tribes; ID – Intellectual Disability, DS – Down Syndrome, NMR – Neonatal Mortality Rate