Table 1.
Methodology | Strengths and clinical relevance | Prediction of extubation, highest reported area under the curve | Limitations | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Electromyography (EMG) | Detection of the electrical signal of the diaphragm on the surface or with indwelling oesophageal and gastric catheters | Sensitive detection of the start of a breathing effort and provides insight in the amount of breathing effort, applicable in NAVA ventilation | 0.7760 | Specialised equipment is required |
Maximal respiratory pressures (PImax, PEmax) | Measurement of the maximal pressures during inspiration and expiration generated during crying against an occluded airway | Maximal pressures are a surrogate for muscle strength and increase with maturation | 0.9035 |
Assessment is effort-dependent. Large scatter of normal values |
Phrenic nerve stimulation | Electric or magnetic stimulation of the phrenic nerve and measurement of the diaphragm EMG and transdiaphragmatic pressure | Non-volitional method | Has not been assessed in neonates | Specialised equipment is required |
Tension Time Index (TTI) of the diaphragm | Product of the ratio of the mean transdiaphragmatic pressure to the maximum inspiratory transdiaphragmatic pressure times the ratio of the inspiratory time to the total breathing cycle time | Composite index of respiratory muscle efficiency: less efficient function when inspiration involves a high proportion of the maximal inspiratory pressure and happens during a large part of the respiratory cycle | 1.0040 | Specialised equipment and post measurement analysis are required |
Thoraco-abdominal asynchrony (TAA) | Lack of synchrony between the chest and abdomen during respiration and calculation of the corresponding phase angle |
Non-invasive method. Continuous positive airway pressure decreases TAA. Asynchrony decreases post feeding |
Not applicable | Only useful in non-ventilated infants |
Relaxation rate of the respiratory muscles | A longer time to relax after contraction signals respiratory muscle fatigue |
Ventilator pressure waveforms can be used as a surrogate for calculating the rate of relaxation. Less efficient respiratory muscle function in the presence of systemic infection and in infants of a lower gestational age |
0.93753 |
Difficult calculations. Currently not available in real time |
Diaphragmatic ultrasound | The thickness of the diaphragm and the range of diaphragmatic displacement can be non-invasively measured | Inexpensive, non-ionising and accessible method. Diaphragmatic velocity decreased during fatigue. Diaphragmatic thickness is higher in term compared to preterm infants | 0.9863 | More meaningful in spontaneous breathing infants |