Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 20;28(33):45693–45713. doi: 10.1007/s11356-021-13390-y

Table 8.

PANIC unit root test

Tests Intercept Int&Trend Intercept Int&Trend
Stat. p-value Stat. p-value Stat. p-value Stat. p-value
Developing countries
EC LNGDPPC
Pa −0.708 0.240 −1.730 0.042 1.880 0.970 0.551 0.709
Pb −0.537 0.296 −1.340 0.090 2.555 0.995 0.630 0.736
PMSB −0.589 0.278 −0.848 0.198 2.219 0.987 0.712 0.762
LNTM LNPAT
Pa −4.437 0.000 −1.412 0.079 −1.061 0.144 −0.570 0.284
Pb −2.165 0.015 −1.159 0.123 −0.846 0.199 −0.515 0.303
PMSB −1.382 0.084 −0.775 0.219 −0.480 0.316 −0.352 0.363
LNTRADE LNTCO2
Pa −3.520 0.000 −0.559 0.288 −1.869 0.031 1.047 0.852
Pb −1.815 0.035 −0.508 0.306 −1.549 0.061 1.445 0.926
PMSB −1.229 0.110 −0.383 0.351 −0.561 0.288 1.947 0.974
LNGDPPC2 LNURBAN
Pa 1.966 0.975 0.220 0.587 −4.528 0.000 −0.989 0.161
Pb 2.633 0.996 0.233 0.592 −2.338 0.010 −0.826 0.204
PMSB 2.077 0.981 0.255 0.601 −1.052 0.146 −0.591 0.277
LNFD
Pa −3.556 0.000 −1.333 0.091
Pb −1.661 0.048 −1.105 0.135
PMSB −1.394 0.082 −0.763 0.223
Developed countries
EC GDPPC
Pa 0.617 0.731 −1.356 0.088 −1.052 0.146 −0.855 0.196
Pb 20.497 1.000 −1.225 0.110 −64.530 0.000 −0.826 0.204
PMSB 1.792 0.963 −0.544 0.293 −0.491 0.312 −0.239 0.406
TM PAT
Pa 0.752 0.774 1.544 0.939 1.420 0.922 −1.706 0.044
Pb 38.234 1.000 2.606 0.995 46.343 1.000 −1.540 0.062
PMSB 6.885 1.000 4.823 1.000 1.155 0.876 −0.612 0.270
TRADE TCO2
Pa −1.090 0.138 −1.126 0.130 −2.786 0.003 −0.481 0.315
Pb −50.177 0.000 −1.065 0.143 −81.928 0.000 −0.485 0.314
PMSB −0.069 0.473 −0.387 0.349 −0.871 0.192 0.004 0.502
GDPPC2 URBAN
Pa 0.773 0.780 −0.080 0.468 −1.090 0.138 −1.443 0.075
Pb 1.251 0.895 −0.087 0.465 −50.177 0.000 −1.275 0.101
PMSB 2.099 0.982 0.510 0.695 −0.069 0.473 −0.613 0.270
FD
Pa 1.569 0.942 −1.468 0.071
Pb 67.356 1.000 −1.341 0.090
PMSB 0.853 0.803 −0.529 0.298