Table I.
Diagnostic criteria for COVID-19-associated pulmonary aspergillosis (CAPA) according to various studies included in our review
| Diagnostic criteria | Clinical | Radiological | Mycological |
|---|---|---|---|
| EORTC/MSG [17] | One of the following host factors: (A) severe neutropenia, (B) allogeneic stem cell/solid organ transplant, (C) corticosteroid therapy (0.3 mg/kg per day for >3 months), (D) haematological malignancy, (E) congenital/inherited/acquired immunodeficiency, (F) treatment with T-cell/B-cell immunosuppressants | One of the following: (A) dense, well-circumscribed lesions with/without halo sign, (B) air-crescent sign, (C) cavity, (D) lobar or segmental consolidation | Proven: histopathological/microscopic evidence of septated hyphae with evidence of tissue damage or positive culture from sterile material Probable (all 3 criteria): (A) positive direct test (culture/microscopy on sputum, ETA, and BAL or 2 and more positive PCR on either BAL or serum), OR (B) positive indirect test (GM in serum or BAL) |
| AspICU [13] | One of the following: (A) refractory fever despite 3 days of antibiotic therapy, (B) recrudescent fever of at least 48 h despite antibiotic therapy, (C) pleuritic chest pain/rub, dyspnea, (D) haemoptysis, (E) worsening respiratory failure despite antibiotic therapy and ventilatory support | Abnormal imaging on chest radiography or chest CT | Proven: histopathological/microscopic evidence of septated hyphae with evidence of tissue damage or positive culture from sterile material Putative (all 3 criteria): (A) positive lower respiratory tract specimen in patient with either host risk factors (severe neutropenia, haematological/oncological malignancy treated with cytotoxic agents, corticosteroid therapy (prednisone equivalent, >20 mg/day), congenital/acquired immunodeficiency) OR (B) semiquantitative positive BAL culture in the absence of bacterial growth |
| CAPA-European Excellence Centre for Medical Mycology [14] | One of the following: (A) refractory fever despite 3 days of antibiotic therapy, (B) pleuritic chest pain/rub, dyspnea, (C) haemoptysis | Abnormal imaging on chest radiography or chest CT | Proven: histopathological/microscopic evidence of septated hyphae with evidence of tissue damage or positive culture from sterile material Probable (all 3 criteria): (A) positive lower respiratory tract specimen on BAL OR (B) BAL GM >1.0 ODI OR (C) serum GM >0.5 ODI OR (D) positive serum and BAL PCR, OR (E) positive serum PCR × 2 Possible (all 3 criteria): (A) positive non-BAL lower respiratory tract specimen OR (B) positive non-BAL GM >4.5 ODI OR (C) positive non-BAL GM >1.2 ODI × 2, OR (D) positive non-BAL GM >1.2 ODI with non-BAL PCR |
| Modified AspICU-Gangneux et al. [15] | One of the following: (A) refractory fever despite 3 days of antibiotic therapy, (B) recrudescent fever of at least 48 h despite antibiotic therapy, (C) pleuritic chest pain/rub, dyspnea, (D) haemoptysis, (E) worsening respiratory failure despite antibiotic therapy and ventilatory support | Abnormal imaging on chest radiography or chest CT | Proven: histopathological/microscopic evidence of septated hyphae with evidence of tissue damage or positive culture from sterile material Putative (all 3 criteria): (A) positive lower respiratory tract specimen in patient with either host risk factors (severe neutropenia, haematological/oncological malignancy treated with cytotoxic agents, corticosteroid therapy (prednisone equivalent, >20 mg/day), congenital/acquired immunodeficiency), OR (B) semiquantitative positive BAL culture/PCR in the absence of bacterial growth Probable: putative plus one positive serum biomarker |
| Modified AspICU–Dutch/Belgian Mycosis Study Group [10] | One of the following: (A) refractory fever despite 3 days of antibiotic therapy, (B) recrudescent fever of at least 48 h despite antibiotic therapy, (C) pleuritic chest pain/rub, dyspnea, (D) haemoptysis, (E) worsening respiratory failure despite antibiotic therapy and ventilatory support | Abnormal imaging on chest radiography or chest CT | Proven: histopathological/microscopic evidence of septated hyphae with evidence of tissue damage or positive culture from sterile material Putative (all 3 criteria): (A) positive BAL culture, OR (B) BAL GM >1.0 ODI, OR (C) serum GM >0.5 ODI |
| Influenza-Associated Pulmonary Aspergillosis (IAPA)–Verweij et al. [16] | Influenza-like illness between 7 days before and 4 days after ICU admission | Probable: (A) pulmonary infiltrate and at least one of the following mycological criteria, OR (B) cavitating infiltrate (not attributed to another aetiology) and at least one of the following mycological criteria | Positive influenza PCR/antigen test Proven: histopathological/microscopic evidence of septated hyphae with evidence of tissue damage or positive PCR in tissue Probable (all 3 criteria): (A) pulmonary infiltrate and at least one of the following mycological criteria (serum GM >0.5 ODI, BAL GM >1.0 ODI, positive BAL culture), OR (B) cavitating infiltrate (not attributed to another etiology) and at least one of the following mycological criteria (positive sputum/tracheal aspirate culture) |
BAL, bronchoalveolar lavage; CT, computed tomography; EORTC/MSG, European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer/Invasive Fungal Infections Cooperative Group and the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Mycoses Study Group; ETA, endotracheal aspirate; GM, galactomannan; IAPA, influenza-associated pulmonary aspergillosis (IAPA) criteria-Verweij et al.; ICU, intensive care unit; LRTC, lower respiratory tract cultures; NR, non recorded/negative; ODI, optimal density index; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; Spp., species.