Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 May 1.
Published in final edited form as: Surg Endosc. 2021 Jan 4:10.1007/s00464-020-08231-x. doi: 10.1007/s00464-020-08231-x

Table 1.

Studies included in the systematic review

Reference Problem addressed Intervention Implementation (S: suggested, E: evaluated) Intervention category Intervention details Intervention challenges
Ahmad [25] Impact of workspace congestion on workflow during robotic-assisted surgery S Environment Redesigning the operating room layout Proposed interventions may only be applicable to some specialties/ may only be ideal for only certain OR types
Ahmed [37] “Assess potential hazards in robotic-assisted urological surgery” S Checklist A 22-item checklist was developed after analysis of systemic-level issues using the Healthcare Failure Mode and Effects Analysis n/a
Allers [38] “Interruptions during robotic-assisted surgery” S Environment Redesigning the operating room layout and providing training to surgical team members n/a
Catchpole [14] Safety and efficiency during robotic-assisted surgery S Workflow Improving system-level issues such as communication, coordination, and training n/a
Collins [29] The need for a proficiency-based standardized curriculum that includes both technical and non-technical training S Training Simulation training for non-technical skills and team training n/a
Craven [39] Upper limb ergonomic strain of the surgeon on console S Ergonomics Ergonomic modifications to the console workstation and posture Ergonomic modifications may not withstand the duration of the procedure and may not be applicable for all surgeons
Dru [40] Identification of flow disruptions that can lead to patient harm, surgical inefficiency, frustrations, communication breakdown, and longer operating times S Training Technical and non-technical simulation training for surgical team members n/a
Franasiak [41] Ergonomic positioning of the surgeon at the console E Training Training on ergonomic modifications to the console workstation and posture Reports of strain are subjective
Jain [8] Flow disruptions during robotic-assisted surgery S Training, Briefings Teamwork training, preoperative briefings, and improvement of equipment maintenance and use n/a
Jing [33] Effectiveness of a checklist for robotic-assisted radical prostatectomies E Checklist Implementation of a checklist for robotic-assisted prostatectomies n/a
McCarroll [34] Evaluate the effectiveness of a checklist for robotic-assisted gynecological procedures E Checklist Implementation of a computerized checklist for robotic-assisted surgery OR staff members were not as motivated to use the checklist if a specific nurse was not present, potentially resulting in a pseudo-Hawthorne effect
Myklebust [42] Assess the technical/non-technical elements of teamwork that enhance efficiency and flow, and patient safety S Training, Checklist Simulation-based team training, checklists, and team leader designation during robotic-assisted surgery n/a
Raheem [43] Communication during robotic-assisted surgery S Communication, Training Standardized communication system to improve exchange of information n/a
Randell [44] “Integration of robotic-assisted surgery into routine practice” S Environment, Teamwork, Training Operating room staff engagement, training, and operating room setup n/a
Schiff [45] “Quality of communication and surgical outcomes in robotic-assisted surgery” S Communication, Teamwork A systematic approach to introducing inexperienced operating room staff into robotic-assisted surgery n/a
Schuessler [46] Assess the non-technical aspects of robotic-assisted surgery that contributes to improved patient and system outcomes S Training Team-focused training to improve the practice of robotic-assisted surgery n/a
Sexton [47] Investigate the impact of anticipation as a measure of efficiency in robotic-assisted surgery S Teamwork Develop an understanding of team dynamics and familiarity to improve team efficiency during robotic-assisted surgery n/a
Song [48] Complications and obstacles that occur during RAS Ea Checklist Development of a checklist to improve patient safety during robotic-assisted surgery n/a
Souders [49] Identify flow disruptions that contribute to decreased efficiency, errors, and suboptimal patient outcomes S Environment Modification to the operating room setup for robotic-assisted abdominal sacrocolpopexy surgeries to improve efficiency n/a
Tiferes [50] Team communication during robotic-assisted surgery S Communication Improve team communication through nonverbal actions and usability testing of surgical equipment n/a
Tiferes [10] The gap in literature addressing the analysis of team activities during robotic-assisted surgery S Teamwork, Environment Modification to the operating room setup for robotic-assisted surgery to improve safety and team efficiency n/a
Tsafrir [51] Quality of verbal and auditory communication in a robotic operating room E Technology Evaluation of wireless audio headsets in a robotic operating room to improve the quality of communication Ambient noise levels are not eliminated because the headset covers one ear
Van’t Hullenaar [52] Ergonomic positioning of the first assistant during robotic-assisted surgery S Ergonomics Implementation of ergonomic modifications for the first assistant during robotic-assisted surgery n/a
Van’t Hullenaar [53] Address possible deficiencies in training when optimizing the ergonomics and positioning of the surgeon E Training Development of an ergonomic training program to provide instructions for ergonomic setup of the robotic console Optimal interpretation and accuracy of the ergonomic setup are not guaranteed
Wastler [54] “Communication and patient safety during robotic-assisted surgery” S Checklist Development of a checklist to improve “patient safety during robotic-assisted surgery” n/a
Weber [55] Effect of flow disruptions on workload and performance S Training Implementation of team training and strategies to improve nonverbal communication, situational awareness, and team coordination n/a
Weigl [56] Severity and impact of flow disruptions on the perception of teamwork S Communication. Teamwork, Environment Improving system-level issues such as communication, coordination, operating room setup and management and training n/a
Yu [11] Assess ergonomics and workload for the first assistant and surgeon on console S Technology Introduce wearable intraoperative motion tracking sensors to identify ergonomic risks in the operating room during robotic-assisted surgery A trained researcher is required to analyze motion tracking data and sensors are not able to “differentiate whether musculoskeletal efforts of static posture are demanding or not”
Zattoni [57] Non-technical errors during the conversion of robot-assisted to open radical prostatectomy E Guidelines Development of guidelines for conversion from robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy to open radical prostatectomy The guidelines were developed for a specific type of surgery and may not account for other surgical complications and patient factors
Zattoni [58] Evaluate the impact of training and checklists on improving teamwork during open conversion from robotic-assisted partial nephrectomy E Training Evaluation of a standardized training and institutional checklist on improving teamwork during complications requiring open conversion from robotic-assisted partial nephrectomy The simulated environment produces shorter conversion times and may not accurately represent real-life experiences during robotic-assisted surgery
a

Evaluation of intervention was discussed, but no data were presented