honeybees |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
bisulfite sequencing of a single gene, experimental manipulation |
n/a |
[43] |
2008 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
bioinformatic study of existing datasets. Genes that are differentially expressed between queens and workers show evidence of methylation over evolutionary time |
four ‘caste specific’ genes showed differential methylation |
[44] |
2009 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
WGBS of 50 pooled queen brains and 50 pooled worker brains |
none at individual level |
[45] |
2010 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
no |
WGBS and an array-based system |
five adult queens and workers |
[46] |
2012 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
WGBS of 96 pooled queen and 96 pooled worker larval heads |
none at individual level |
[36] |
2012 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
no |
MSRFLP |
five each: adult and pupal queens and workers |
[47] |
2013 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
MeDIP |
nil at three ages |
[48] |
2013 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
amplicon bisulfite sequencing of two genes |
three sets of five brains from queens and workers |
[49] |
2017 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
MeDIP |
pools of 10 larvae, three queen and three worker |
[50] |
2017 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
no, but no direct comparison across castes |
WGBS and RNA sequencing |
two biological replicates and multiple tissues |
[51] |
2019 |
Apis mellifera |
yes |
yes |
WGBS of queen-destined and worker-destined larvae at three ages |
tree replicate colonies but samples pooled across colonies |
[52] |
2020 |
bumblebee |
Bombus impatiens |
size only |
no |
MSRFLP |
five each: adult and pupal queens and workers |
[47] |
2013 |
ants |
Camponotus floridanus |
yes |
yes |
WGBS of whole individuals |
two biological replicates but queens and workers harvested from different colonies |
[37] |
2012 |
Harpegnathos saltator |
minimal |
yes |
WGBS of whole individuals |
two biological replicates |
[37] |
2012 |
Pogonomyrmex barbatus |
yes |
yes |
MSRFLP |
adult virgin queens (n = 9) versus workers (72) |
[53] |
2012 |
Ooceraea biroi |
no |
no (between reproductive phases) |
WGBS of adult brains |
four replicates of pools of 20 brains |
[54] |
2016 |
Dinoponera quadriceps |
no |
no (between gamergate and worker) |
WGBS of adult brains |
three biological replicates |
[55,56] |
2015 |
Formica exsecta |
yes |
yes |
RRBS |
comparisons of 5–7 old and young workers and queens randomly selected from 19 colonies |
[57] |
2019 |
wasps |
Dolichovespula maculata |
size only |
no |
MSRFLP |
five each: adult and pupal queens and workers |
[47] |
2013 |
Polistes dominula |
no |
yes |
MSRFLP |
five each: adult and pupal queens and workers |
[47] |
2013 |
Polistes canadensis |
no |
no |
WGBS of adult brains |
three biological replicates |
[55,56] |
2015 |
termites |
Zootermopsis nevadensis |
yes |
yes |
WGBS of male and female workers and alates |
replicate individuals from a single colony |
[33] |
2016 |