Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 22;16(4):e0250356. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0250356

Table 4. Specific methods used for evidence synthesis in guidelines.

Method Guidelines n/N (%)
Formulation of the guideline question(s) or objective(s) in terms of PICOS elements 30/50 (60)
Inclusion and exclusion criteria of studies reported 29/50 (58)
Systematic search strategy 25/50 (50)
Two or more databases searched 31/50 (61)
Process reported for selecting/screening studies 27/50 (54)
Assessment of methodological quality (risk of bias) of review/overview 5/50 (10)
Assessment of methodological quality (risk of bias) of primary studies 30/50 (60)
 Cochrane risk of bias tool for randomized trials 8/30 (27)
 Other tool 11/30 (37)
 GRADE used but risk of bias methods not reported 11/30 (37)
GRADE approach reported 17/50 (34)
Other system for assessing the strength of recommendation reported 33/50 (66)
Highest “level of evidence” rating
 High quality SR/MAs 17/50 (34)
 SR/MAs 9/50 (18)
 High quality RCTs 13/50 (26)
 RCTs 4/50 (8)