Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 6;10(4):433. doi: 10.3390/pathogens10040433

Table 3.

Disease severity index (DSIb) and disease incidence (DIb, percentage of diseased plants) of clubroot in bioassays performed in a growth chamber with soil from field trials 2017/2018 with the susceptible Cultivar mix and clubroot-resistant cultivars cv. Mentor, cv. Alister, and cv. Archimedes, and number of gene copies (logarithm at calculation) of Plasmodiophora brassicae. Values are mean for soil samples from each plot (n = 4). Sites were selected based on field abundance (gene copies g−1 soil) of Plasmodiophora brassicae DNA (Simrishamn 1,100,000; Tomelilla 2,500,000; Kumla 15,000; Hallsberg 2500).

Treatment DSIb
(0–100)
DSIb
(%)
Gene Copies
(No. g soil−1)
DSIb × Gene
Copies
DIb × Gene
Copies
Gene copies P. brassicae, average:
Simrishamn 419,200 b *
Tomelilla 1,187,100 a
Kumla 55,600 c
Hallsberg 2800 c
p-value <0.001
Coeff. of var. 119
Field-wise:
Simrishamn
Cultivar mix 77.5 a * 94.5 a 562,300 p = 0.035 ns
cv. Mentor 21.9 bcd 30.5 bcd 435,700 p < 0.001 p < 0.001
cv. Alister 38.6 b 49.2 b 204,100 p = 0.012 p = 0.027
cv. Archimedes 34.4 b 46.6 b 474,700 ns ns
p-value 0.020 0.020 ns
Coeff. of var. 141 134 103
Tomelilla
Cultivar mix 75.2 a 86.4 a 784,300 ns ns
cv. Mentor 31.6 b 40.2 bc 1,129,800 ns ns
cv. Alister 32.8 b 42.9 b 1,603,200 ns ns
cv. Archimedes 7.0 de 16.5 cde 1,231,000 ns ns
p-value <0.001 ns ns
Coeff. of var. 71 66 72
Kumla
Cultivar mix 29.9 bc 42.0 bc 68,300 ns ns
cv. Mentor 9.0 cde 14.8 de 49,500 p = 0.011 p = 0.009
cv. Alister 7.5 cde 9.5 de 38,800 ns ns
cv. Archimedes 4.4 de 8.2 de 65,800 p = 0.017 p = 0.009
p-value ns ns ns
Coeff. of var. 323 323 76
Hallsberg
Cultivar mix 1.3 de 2.8 e 3800 ns ns
cv. Mentor 0.5 e 1.2 e 1700 ns ns
cv. Alister 0.8 e 1.8 e 2800 ns ns
cv. Archimedes 0.0 e 0.0 e 3020 ns ns
p-value ns ns ns
Coeff. of var. 323 323 77

Coefficient of variation. * Different letters indicate significant differences according to Tukey’s HSD-test (p < 0.05).