Table 1.
Predetermined decision rules for item inclusion, exclusion, and revision for phases I–III
| Phases | Predetermined decision rules |
|---|---|
| Phase I | |
| Literature review | |
| Include | Activities that could be considered IADL |
| Step 1. Activities ‘pilot study’ | |
| Include | 32 pilot study IADL activities |
| Exclude |
≥ 2 HCPs: Not considered IADL < 3 Pt/Pr/HCPs: Affected |
| Revision | ≥ 2 Pt/Pr/HCPs: Unclear; rephrase or, if this was not possible, exclude |
| Steps 2 & 3. Semi-structured interviews | |
| Include | ≥ 2 Pt/Pr/HCPs: New activity generated that could be considered IADL |
| Exclude |
≥ 6 HCPs: Mean relevance & importance < 2.0 (unless ≥ 2 HCPs in top 10) or Not relevant |
| Step 4. Cognitive debriefing | |
| Exclude | ≥ 2 Pt/Pr/HCPs: Activities are too similar (redundancy) |
| Revision | ≥ 2 Pt/Pr/HCPs: Unclear; rephrase or, if this was not possible, exclude |
| Phase II | |
| Activities converted to items | |
| Revision | Revisions based on recommendations from the Translation Unit to be applicable in all languages |
| Phase III | |
| Newly generated items | |
| Include | ≥2 Pt/Pr: New activity generated that could be considered IADL |
| Round 1: Per geographical region | |
| Exclude |
Pt: Not in the top 10 most important items and < 60% score 3 or 4 on both importance & relevance and Mean score < 2.0 on difficulty with item (N/A responses excluded) |
| Round 2: All geographical regions | |
| Exclude: (in > 1 region & unless in top 10 most important) |
Pt: < 60% score 3 or 4 on both importance & relevance or ≥ 75% ‘Not applicable’ |
| Round 3: All geographical regions | |
| Exclude: (in > 1 region & unless in top 10 most important) |
Pt: Prevalence ratio > 30% or Floor or ceiling effect scores 1&2 or 3&4 were > 20% or Compliance rate ≤ 95% or Range ≤ 2 points |
| Acceptability | |
| Revision per region | > 5 Pt&Pr: Rate item difficult/confusing/annoying/upsetting |
| Revision all regions | > 5% Pt&Pr (8.5 Pt&Pr): Rate item difficult/confusing/annoying/upsetting |
Pt patients, Pr proxies, HCPs health care professionals, IADL instrument activities of daily living