Table 2.
Compound | Conventional Solvents | NADES | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MeOH | EtOH 80 | Water | Gly:CA | Gly:U | Glu:CA | Glu:U | Glu:LA | CC:U | CC:X | CC:MA | CC:LA | Pro:LA | |
O-Caffeoylquinic acid | <LOQ | 68.41 | <LOQ | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. |
Gallic acid | <LOD | n.d. | <LOD | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | <LOD | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. |
Vanillic acid | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | 68.03 b | <LOQ | 78.69 b | 86.98 b | 91.35 b | <LOQ | <LOQ | 97.55 b | 179.1 a |
Caffeic acid hexoside | 79.90 bc | 67.76 bcd | 62.22 cd | 53.25 d | <LOQ | <LOQ | 106.1 a | 77.97 bc | 86.24 b | 64.47 cd | 68.43 bcd | 81.32 bc | 72.92 bcd |
Caffeic acid hexoside | 112.8 a | 93.26 abc | 72.44 cd | 60.23 d | <LOQ | <LOQ | 100.1 ab | 89.62 bc | 100.5 ab | 72.22 cd | 79.22 bcd | 81.64 bcd | 86.19 bc |
Chlorogenic acid (5-O-caffeoylquinic acid) | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | n.d. | <LOD | n.d. | <LOD | n.d. | <LOD | n.d. | n.d. |
Fertaric acid | 53.15 g | 163.1 f | 278.8 bc | 174.6 ef | 283.5 b | 91.70 g | 229.4 bcde | 277.8 bc | 341.7 a | 208.8 ef | 213.5 def | 270.2 bcd | 223.7 cde |
Caffeic acid | 81.50 cd | 75.14 d | 427.4 a | 103.4 cd | <LOD | <LOQ | 90.72 cd | 160.0 c | 248.3 b | 76.68 cd | <LOQ | 157.3 cd | 137.6 cd |
Feruloyl hexose | 259.8 a | 233.5 b | 201.2 c | 97.46 g | 195.8 cd | 56.95 h | 140.5 f | 197.7 c | 212.0 bc | 163.6 ef | 170.4 de | 208.7 bc | 184.9 cde |
Ferulic acid | 1846 e | 3079 c | 3657 ab | 1427 f | 3020 c | 546.9 g | 2868 cd | 3105 c | 3774 a | 2557 d | 2979 c | 3417 b | 2585 d |
Rosmarinic acid | 7224 a | 6882 a | 2416 cde | 2973 bcde | 59.66 e | 1620 de | 1556 de | 4252 abcd | 5239 abc | 5828 ab | 4181 abcd | 4375 abcd | 6089 ab |
Salvianolic acid A isomer I | 57.46 c | 121.2 ab | 95.52 bc | 58.66 c | 46.13 c | <LOQ | 81.72 bc | 90.11 bc | 158.8 a | 104.7 abc | 87.88 bc | 101.5 abc | 132.2 ab |
Salvianolic acid I | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ |
Salvianolic acid B | 930.9 bcd | 2322 a | 1414 abc | 701.2 bcd | <LOD | 342.3 cd | 233.7 d | 1710 ab | 1220 abcd | 1472 abc | 1527 ab | 2144 a | 2277 a |
Salvianolic acid A isomer III | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD |
Total Phenolic Acids | 10646 ab | 13106 a | 8624 bc | 5649 cd | 3673 d | 2658 d | 5485 cd | 10048 ab | 11473 ab | 10549 ab | 9307 abc | 10934 ab | 11967 ab |
Luteolin-7-O-glucuronide | 84.32 gh | 216.6 bcd | 97.82 fgh | 66.94 h | 145.7 ef | <LOD | 121.3 efg | 265.7 ab | 209.2 cd | 170.4 de | 203.7 cd | 291.9 a | 231.4 bc |
Luteolin-7-O-glucoside | 58.11 cde | 71.07 bc | <LOD | <LOQ | 25.97 f | <LOD | <LOQ | 64.38 cd | 45.98 de | 44.07 e | 52.84 cde | 91.15 a | 83.54 ab |
Apigenin-7-O-glucoside | 98.05 a | 73.68 a | <LOD | 31.59 b | 95.37 a | <LOQ | 44.44 b | 25.20 b | 32.84 b | 30.31 b | 24.74 b | 28.22 b | 37.23 b |
Apigenin-7-O-acetylglucoside | <LOD | 30.67 | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ |
Luteolin | 154.1 c | 78.26 ef | 632.8 a | 90.82 de | <LOD | 32.22 f | <LOD | 94.14 de | 114.4 cde | 171.1 bc | 58.78 ef | 138.8 cd | 215.3 b |
Naringenin | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD |
Apigenin | 242.8 a | 208.4 ab | 267.3 a | 126.1 bcd | <LOD | 63.78 d | 55.70 d | 131.9 bcd | 92.54 cd | 129.0 bcd | 111.6 bcd | 140.3 bcd | 175.1 abc |
Total Flavonoids | 637.4 bcd | 678.6 bc | 998.0 a | 315.4 efg | 267.0 fgh | 96.00 h | 221.4 gh | 581.3 bcd | 495.0 cde | 544.9 bcd | 451.6 def | 690.4 bc | 742.6 b |
Herniarin | <LOQ | 43.96 ± 6.05 | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | n.d. | <LOQ | <LOQ | n.d. | <LOQ |
Total Phenolic Compounds | 11283 a | 13828 a | 9623 ab | 5965 bc | 3940 c | 2754 c | 5707 bc | 10629 a | 11968 a | 11094 a | 9759 ab | 11625 a | 12709 a |
Notes: n.d.—not detected; LOD—limit of detection; LOQ—limit of quantification. The results were analyzed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Duncan’s new multiple range test. Different letters (a–h) in each row and for each phenolic compound mean significant differences (p < 0.05) among extracts.